epson v600 or canon 9000f

Posted by: zorba on 16 January 2012

Hi all, can anyone help me make a decision.

 

I am a total beginner and would like to digitise the family photos that were taken before we had a digital camera. There will be quite a few old pre 1960's phtos and  I may even do some important negatives I become more competent.

 

I have an imac and mac book pro

I use a panasonic TZ3 camera

Normally have preference for epson printers but next camera looks like a Canon

 

Do epson have the better scanning hardware or Canon due to their high end camera background?

 

Help appreciated

Many thanks

zorba

Posted on: 16 January 2012 by Huwge

I like Epson, but it depends a lot on the film stock you are trying to scan. B&W is pretty straightforward, colour can have you changing your name to Sisyphus. It's definitely worth looking for Silverfast software, which may come bundled with the Epson. I use an Epson 750 but I think the hardware is all pretty consistent.

 

You might be better posting the query on an analogue film forum. 

Posted on: 16 January 2012 by The Hawk

I don't have experience with Epson. I have owned many Canon printers and scanners (I use a Canon A95 camera), and have loved them to pieces. I have never had a problem, and I'm amazed at how good the scans of photographs have been. I'm very careful to keep the glass spotlessly clean. I own a very high end Canon printer, with several inks, that get expensive fast, and have resorted to using one of their cheapest scanner/copier/printers, to save on the cost of ink. The scans are flawless from this cheap printer of theirs. Believe it or not, it cost me $79! I'm amazed at how much quality they've crammed into this all-in-one. Good luck with your purchase.

 

Dave

Posted on: 16 January 2012 by zorba

Sorry for the bad punctuation above but I could not edit my post.

 

Thanks for your replies, I just cannot decide between the two, they must be very similar in performance that I am splitting hairs. 

 

Cheers