Sign of the times?

Posted by: Mike Kent on 26 March 2012

Has it really come to this? I know the recession is hitting, but I saw what seemed like a mint 552 preamp go for £2900 on E-bay yesterday. When I think how much I paid for mine, it makes me weep (although I don't regret a penny of it)

Or was it a scam... the guy started at £1000 and wouldn't allow personal collection or anything other than Paypal. Also, he diodn't seem to know anything about it... other than quoting Naim's literature.

Either the buyer has got an absolute bargain... or he's lost three grand...

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by HTM_1968

For what it is worth, that NAP300 has made its third appearance of the week. Anybody else for a bargain?

 

I thought not....

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by hungryhalibut
I've bought and sold plenty of Naim gear on eBay without any problems whatsoever. Most eBay sellers scrupulously protect their good feedback ratings, and unless you are a bit dim it will be safe. No one in their right mind would part with large sums of cash without undertaking due diligence.
Posted on: 26 March 2012 by GerryMcg

I have also had many transactions on eBay with a 100% success rate. It should be remembered that the only reason that we know the auction in question is a scam, is that, it is so obviously a scam, There is no other evidence.

 

Gerry 

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by RaceTripper
Originally Posted by Lord Emsworth:
I've bought and sold plenty of Naim gear on eBay without any problems whatsoever. Most eBay sellers scrupulously protect their good feedback ratings, and unless you are a bit dim it will be safe. No one in their right mind would part with large sums of cash without undertaking due diligence.

The problem with that assumption is that legitimate and reputable sellers get their accounts hijacked by scammers. Then you are not safe. The feedback ratings mean nothing in that case.

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by Noogle

I'd say that for a this kind of transaction, a quick chat with the seller on the phone is a necessary precaution.  If you see a comment in the description such as "I'm away for a few weeks and unavailable to take phone calls" then alarm bells should ring in your head.

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by Chief Chirpa

Obvious scam is obvious.

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by GraemeH

As the originator of two threads on the other site 'Dodgy?' and 'Another Bargain' I thought I was doing folks a favour.  Some see it as a witch hunt though which makes me think twice about future alerts.

 

The feedback for the 300 was a laugh for those who read it.   100's of pairs of kinky underwear and then, out of the blue, a very expensive power amplifier!

 

Take care out there.  G

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by hungryhalibut
I totally agree that one needs to take care and ask the right questions. My point was simply that eBay can be a very good way to buy and sell. As can the pfm classifieds, which I prefer. I remember when I sold my SL2s on eBay: someone nabbed the photo and tried three times to sell them again. But the scam was poorly done and very obvious  The current 300 auction is so obvious as well - who'd have a hotmail address as their work email? Durr.....
Posted on: 26 March 2012 by Noogle

Interesting that the guy selling the NAP300 in a one-day sale on the major auction site is also unloading a Hasselblad camera body under a different ID (Google his email address).  He has also previously sold a coin online for £2.16, which seems unusual behaviour from someone who owns a £6,500 power amplifier.

 

FWIW, I've reported both postings to the site as fraudulent.

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by Bart

I'm a bit jealous of you Brits, as you have much more access to Naim dealers within a day's drive.

Here in the States, at least in my geography, resort to online sales sites is a necessity for used gear. My local dealer doesn't have much if anything very often at all.  Even the "big" audio enthusiasts second-hand selling site here in the States at any one time has only maybe a dozen Naim items in total.

 

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by TomK

Current bid is 26 quid.

I'm sorry but people stupid enough to be seriously bidding on this deserve all they get.

I've reported it as fraudulent too.

Posted on: 26 March 2012 by Guido Fawkes
I don't believe anybody deserves to be conned unless they are a con artist themselves. Unusually, I beg to differ from Lord E, eBay is dreadful way to buy things; if you never use it or PayPal then you'll be much safer from these scams than if you do. Value your consumer rights. Noble as it may be, i doubt reporting it will do much good, as it presumes somebody gives a damn and secondly they could do something about the perpetrator. How many scammers have been arrested?
Posted on: 26 March 2012 by Zinger
Hi RaceTripper and Richard Dane, Ya. I understand hosting a marketplace in a forum is very hard, especially to meet the standards of this forum. It will be extremely hard to monitor everything properly. Anyway, just saying how a more centralized forum would give people more comfort. I'm big fan of the car I used to drive, and was part of a forum as well. I have bought and sold items there before. There were still frauds on that forum, but buyers generally are much more comfortable with members who have been there for a while. new members would need to work extra hard to sell/buy things from others, often staying in local areas to look for other members to deal in person first. That's actually how I sold my car. People in the area knew who I was, and the buyer knew someone in the area ... Through the forum, the buyer got feedback of what kinda driver I was, and what condition the car was. The buyer flew over from another state to NYC and spend 20 hours driving the car back with a big smile on his face! The forum allows one to see the history of all his postings etc. not a perfect world, but it did give a bit more confidence. That's all Either case ... It's always a very sensitive issue to hold a market place like that, especially when Naim staff members very involved in the forum. Definitely wouldn't wanna let anything slip. So ya, solution can only be not to host something like that. End users would need to rely on local dealers to do that job ...
Posted on: 27 March 2012 by Jono 13
Originally Posted by GraemeH:

The feedback for the 300 was a laugh for those who read it.   100's of pairs of kinky underwear and then, out of the blue, a very expensive power amplifier!

Also you can buy accounts with great feedback to encourage confidence in the seller which needs to watched out for.

 

Jono

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by joerand
Originally Posted by Jono 13:
Also you can buy accounts with great feedback to encourage confidence in the seller which needs to watched out for.

 

Jono

 

Indeed, you could, at no cost, set up a miscellany of email accounts to give yourself pseudo positive feedback.  Best done over a period of time to avoid suspicion.

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by Jono 13
Originally Posted by joerand:
Originally Posted by Jono 13:
Also you can buy accounts with great feedback to encourage confidence in the seller which needs to watched out for.

 

Jono

 

Indeed, you could, at no cost, set up a miscellany of email accounts to give yourself pseudo positive feedback.  Best done over a period of time to avoid suspicion.

And you know its been done, along with the poor punters who fell for it.

 

Cash on collection is the only safe solution for the kind of value kit under discussion here.

 

Jono

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by Don Atkinson

Little risk in buying from a Naim Dealer, even at a distance.

 

Not as good as having a dealer nearby, but a lot more certainty than remote auction sites.

 

Cheers

 

Don 

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by mista h

Some years ago i put my SBLs up for sale on flea bay. Guy from Ireland contacted me,was happy to buy them without seeing them. Says he will send me a cheque for the full amount + £500.

Wants me to bank his cheque and send MY CHEQUE to his shipping company !!!! for the £500.

When i told him that i was going to Ireland on business and that he could pay me cash on delivery AND save himself £500 i never heard from him again. What a suprise

Mista H

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by Richard Dane

Mista,

 

that's a well known scam.  Basically your cheque will be good but his won't be.  It'll seem OK until a few days after you send yours and the bank inform you that his cheque is stolen/bogus and has been reversed.  In the worst case, he gets the goods and your £500.  Ouch.

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by mista h
Originally Posted by Richard Dane:

Mista,

 

that's a well known scam.  Basically your cheque will be good but his won't be.  It'll seem OK until a few days after you send yours and the bank inform you that his cheque is stolen/bogus and has been reversed.  In the worst case, he gets the goods and your £500.  Ouch.

Richard i had this sort of thing all the time when i had my M/cycle W/sale business.

Once had a guy phone me one morning wanting some £15,000 worth of Brake pads etc to ship back to Africa. I told him to bring CASH when he comes to collect. Walks into the office next day and says to me.....Who do i make the cheque out to ?  He got quite upset when i told him to F off.

Mista H

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by madasafish
Originally Posted by Mike Kent:

Has it really come to this? I know the recession is hitting, but I saw what seemed like a mint 552 preamp go for £2900 on E-bay yesterday. When I think how much I paid for mine, it makes me weep (although I don't regret a penny of it)

Or was it a scam... the guy started at £1000 and wouldn't allow personal collection or anything other than Paypal. Also, he diodn't seem to know anything about it... other than quoting Naim's literature.

Either the buyer has got an absolute bargain... or he's lost three grand...

Relax, Mike - total scam. 24 hour listing, no personal calls, no answer to messages for information and far too cheap.

However, I don't agree with others on this thread that nothing good comes from ebay purchases because mine was a joy.

Hope you're keeping well.

Mick

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by GerryMcg

Am I wrong here, but as far as I can see, his thread will scare off many people from eBay transactions, but not one poster has actually experienced a loss through a paypal transaction on eBay.

 

It would appear that all the negative posts, are, from those that have always avoided eBay. Those that have used the site all report favourably.

 

I may be wrong?

 

Gerry

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by TomK
Originally Posted by GerryMcg:

Am I wrong here, but as far as I can see, his thread will scare off many people from eBay transactions, but not one poster has actually experienced a loss through a paypal transaction on eBay.

 

It would appear that all the negative posts, are, from those that have always avoided eBay. Those that have used the site all report favourably.

 

I may be wrong?

 

Gerry

I think you're right Gerry. I've been shopping on eBay for seven or eight years now and only had one problem in about 250 transactions, which was quickly resolved in my favour by Paypal.

Having said that I would never consider buying something like a NAP 300 on eBay. My maximum was about £250 with the average being less than £50.

Posted on: 27 March 2012 by Guido Fawkes

PayPal explains in its User Agreement

 

PayPal does not have control of or liability for the products or services that are paid for with our Service. We do not guarantee the identity of any User or ensure that a buyer or a seller will complete a transaction.


When you receive a payment, you are liable to PayPal for the full amount of the payment plus any Fees if the payment is later invalidated for any reason .. This means that you will be responsible for the amount of the payment, plus the applicable Fees listed in section 8 of this Agreement if you lose a Claim or a Charge back, or if there is a Reversal of the payment. You agree to allow PayPal to recover any amounts due to PayPal by debiting your Balance.


You are responsible for all Reversals, Charge backs, Claims, fees, fines, penalties and other liability incurred by PayPal, a PayPal User, or a third party....


I'm saying nothing, up to you whether you find those T&Cs to your liking ....  

 

Click here for an interesting article 

 

Happy shopping .... 

Posted on: 28 March 2012 by Gale 401
Originally Posted by Guido Fawkes:

eBay + PayPal = Avoid like the plague, as far as I'm concerned

 

Yes, I know the "I've used hundreds of times with no problem" argument, but to me that's like saying I played cricket with a grenade and didn't explode, so what's the problem. Neither eBay nor PayPal seem to accept any responsibility for guaranteeing the validity of the transaction. 

 

If looks to good to be true then it is too good to be true. 

If you use common sense then it is probably still too good to be true.

 

Still I'm not so bitter after I won the Canadian lottery, the money should turn up any day now. I've paid the tax and the funny thing was I can't even remember buying the ticket. The guy on the phone who told me I'd won didn't even sound Canadian, but he was very jolly. Must admit I was surprised the Canadian tax office require their taxes to be deposited in a left luggage locker at Waterloo station, but I was assured that was usual and there was even an Internet site called Conodion Tox Office that confirmed this (the guy on the phone explained they had been having trouble with the site provider and hence the "o" instead of they "a"; some provider called hoopless, he said) .... oh well, As Bob Dylan once said, "I can't help it if I'm lucky". 

 

No problem with buying s/h, but why not buy through an authorised dealer ...

+1