Advanced search

This *****

Posted by: Kevin Hughes on 31 July 2000

I am not impressed with the new software (polite opinion ). This software is totaly round earth, looks nice but fails to do the basic job properly.

Can we have an uncensored part please?

What happens if you chose the "under 16" option?

Tony & Mike, who did you sleep with to ge to full member (oh err etc..) status.

Kevin.

PS still no spell checker either, just pants.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mike Hanson
quote:
I am in complete agreement with you on your post! <insert yer smiley face wid da wraps 'ere>

Isn't that special!

BTW, there are two ways to use smilies (a.k.a. emoticons). First is the one that's associated with the subject of the message. Your choose that one with the options in the "Message Icon" area. It's also used to represent the thread on the thread list, if it's the first message in the thread.

The emoticons within the message text can be added by clicking on the desired face within the "Instant Smilies" area, below the text entry box. It will automatically add the text for the desired smilie to the end of your message, and you can cut and past it up into your message proper. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-


Smilies do not a forum make.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by David Dever
Got "New Messages" functionality back...satisfied.

Glad to see a more sophisticated formatted text handler in this software (the other software was definitely getting dated), though I can see the issues with the message tree—might force linear coherent arguments, though...

Dave Dever, NANA

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mike Hanson
quote:
Glad to see a more sophisticated formatted text handler in this software

Actually, this is worse. The other system supported most HTML code, while this UBB approach is a lackluster subset. Sure it has some hot buttons to the bottom of the page, but it always appends them at the end of the message. By the time you cut and paste your stuff, you may as well just type the HTML tags by hand. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-


Smilies do not a forum make.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Kevin Hughes
quote:
Got "New Messages" functionality back...satisfied.

Have you, doesn't work for me. Exactly what button did you press, all I can get is a list of message headers, not the messages themselves.

Kevin.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member
Using this forum more has become a very annoying task, and not pleasure.

The new messages function is useless, because you jump to and fro, and doomed if things are not in the first page. It makes is also impossible for off-line users, who need (here come the constructive part! ) either a new messages feature which includes the messages bodies, or some e-mail mechanism like in other forums, which enables downloading all the messages at once.

I'm at work now, but I simply can not use this at home, it will cost me a fortune and block the line for other use.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member
I have always felt that the old Naim Forum software was the best as one could see the thread develop and have all the messages expanded so that one just needs to scroll down instead of having to go from page to page or clicking on each message just to read it. The new threads feature was also useful even though I preferred to open up each thread to read new messages--mainly because I could see how each message fits within the whole thread. This new software is a step backwards.

Teck

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member
It is definitely DIFFERENT.
If this was the original one, and then NAIM swapped to the old one, would eveyone be happy?

Stefano Rosati.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Chris Metcalfe
>>the first time a new Naim product has been worse than that which it replaced.<< apart from 102/72, natch.

Actually the one thing that annoyed me when I first entered was the division of topics, apart from music into 'hifi' and 'non-hifi', as if, as soon as tangents develop, they should be put quietly into another room. Are we supposed to think in such a compartmentalised way?

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member















Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mike Hanson
Got some spare time on your hands, Vuk? I think your next one should be of Samantha Fox. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-


Smilies do not a forum make.

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Keith Mattox
As a long-time lurker here, I can't speak with the authority of the current or former heavy contributers. But one main reason that I spent more time at the old naim forum was the ergonomics - it was the easiest forum/BBS/you name it that I ever used, allowing one to look at the structure of the conversation and how it changed while quickly moving to a particular message where desired. It left the Royd, Mana and Linn forums by the roadside burning.

This format is OK for those aforementioned forums due to their much smaller traffic. But it won't support the trafic that this forum gets in the manner that it deserves. Mark and Paul; this is one additional personal request to find another solution.

cheers

Keith.

ex-audiophile

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Martin Payne
I'm afraid I have to agree with the majority of the opinions above.

The ability to reply directly to another person's statement is a prerequisite for a discussion. This has been a feature of every other forum package I've seen.

Reasoned debate (even if some of the old threads were far from reasoned!) is not possible here.

Having created a large demand with the old conference, Naim-ites may end up going elsewhere. Discussion is at the heart of 'our' conference.

Sorry to Paul for the downer!

Martin

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Paul Stephenson
Martin, if we had not used the infopop forum, we would not have any forum at all for some time, all estimates and promises to keep the old forum and re-site just did not materialise. We will look at the situation and see what we can do. It does seem though that despite the downer people have been able to communicate, even Vuk came out of the closet, can't think why! he seems so bitter, must be all the moth balls he has been eating.

[This message was edited by Paul Stephenson on WEDNESDAY 02 August 2000 at 04:15.]

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by BrianD
I've posted a few items now and I'm getting used to it. The layout of the messages makes them easier to read, but that's about all.

How long does it take for a post to actually appear on the thread? I've checked just after posting (to make sure they went on ok) and there is nothing there for ages.

The main problem is the lack of being able to reply to a particular comment, your reply simply being stuck on the end. This is a major loss compared to the old forum.

At the end of the day, I like the forum. I get a lot of useful info from it and want to continue to do so. I hope that the main contributors carry on and don't give up. IT IS BETTER THAN NOTHING.

Bri

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Willem van Gemert
According to the UBB propaganda there is a feature called Email notification of replies. Is there a reason why it has not been used in the new Naim forum?

Ciao!

Willem

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Geoff C
'How long does it take for a post to actually appear on the thread? I've checked just after make sure they went on ok) and there is nothing there for ages.'

My messages seem to appear pretty much instantly after posting! Perhaps it's because I am on a leased line and my PC and MAC are always connected to the web 24/7?

Geoff

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Claus
Hi,

I also think that the tree structure is essential for this forum to work.

This new system has got some advantages (=new features) over the old, but basic functionality is definately much worse. Makes it difficult, if not impossible, to follow any longer debate / thread.

I hope Naim will respond to so many contributors opinion and change the software. If not, I'm afraid the benefits of the Naim forum for the users as well as for Naim and their business will diminish significantly.

Regards,
Claus

PS: The preview option is missed as well...

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Mick P
Willem / Geoff

You may be making the same mistake that I made yesterday. Your message may appear on the next page and you will not see it unless you click onto page 2 or page 3 etc. Its so bloody simple but I never noticed the thingy to click on at the end of the page.

PS Message to Naim, I still think this system is better than the old one. If we wish to respond to a specific letter, you need only address the letter for the attention of whoever wrote it. Therefore in my humble opinion the pros outweight the cons.

I would still ask you to remove these silly little faces, if nothing else, it will free up a lot of Vuks time.

Regards

Mick (basically contented with this system)

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Rico
undefined

this is what I get when I hit the instant smilie button. What's going on?

undefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefinedundefined

Rico - musichead

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by kevinl

Is it only me that finds this forum software far slower than the previous site? I'm on a corporate intranet (of a multinational telecoms equipment vendor) with a LARGE pipe to the outside world, but I'm waiting for 20 seconds for a page of chat to be displayed. Something is seriously wrong...

I'm missing the threaded discussions as well...

kevin

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Nic Peeling
quote:
Does anyone know how you can thread replies on this forum, or do you just reply to the whole thread.
Looks to me like this software doesn't support a good (or bad) argument.

Cliff<BR>


The best you can do is quote the posting you are replying to. If a substantial sub thread develops it is probably best to start an entirely new thread.

The main advantage of the single threaded, chat room metaphor this software uses is that you can see all the latest postings to a thread because they are all at the end of the discussion (personally I prefer threaded discussions, but we will adapt to the new style).

Nic P

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Geoff C
'You may be making the same mistake that I made yesterday. Your message may appear on the next page and you will not see it unless you click onto page 2 or page 3 etc. Its so bloody simple but I never noticed the thingy to click on at the end of the page.'

Mick, I did realise that the latest message was at the end of the last page! I just thought that I would point out the speed of the postings from my system to Bri.

cheers
Geoff

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Former member
Willem van Gemert wrote "According to the UBB propaganda there is a feature called Email notification of replies. Is there a reason why it has not been used in the new Naim forum? "

The problem is that naim don't have an SMTP account at infopop.net

Paul, Paul or Mark - can you sort it out please.

Cliff
Trainee Perle Hacker

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Mike Hanson
Rico said:

quote:
undefined
this is what I get when I hit the instant smilie button. What's going on?

Sounds like it might be a browser problem, or possible a Java thing. What browser are you using? Do you have your Java Virtual Machine turned off? BTW, you can manually insert the emoticons. For example: a colon followed by a closing parenthesis is simple smile; a semi-colon followed by a closing parenthesis is a winker; enclose "eek" with colons to get the purple suprised face; etc. I'll e-mail the full list to you.

Kevin said:

quote:
Is it only me that finds this forum software far slower than the previous site?

It must be something to do with your route to the infopop site. In my case using a 1-Mbps ADSL line, the pages are appearing within a second or two. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-

Smilies do not a forum make.

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Kevin Hughes
Nic said
quote:
If a substantial sub thread develops it is probably best to start an entirely new thread.

But this way you will end up with half the messages in one thread and the rest in another, unless you know a way of traveling back in time to before the thread diverged

Kevin.