The round earth may be hiding inside your Naim....

Posted by: bec143 on 15 March 2004

I'm beginning to wonder a bit about this whole flat earth versus round earth debate that sorrounds Naim. Over the past several years I have come to accept the idea that to achieve the things that my Naim system does extremely well, it was necessary to sacrifice some things that other audiophiles appreciate. Things such as (cover your ears!) soundstage and imaging.

Well, I'm now beginning to think that this isn't so much a feature of the boxes themselves, but rather reflects the speakers that are often the choice of fellow Naimophiles. Case in point, I came close to buying a pair of neat Elites, which sounded fast, tuneful, but oh so flat in my system, that I just couldn't grow to like them. I recently changed my speakers to Audio Physic Virgos, and suddenly my system produced an incredibly lush and round sound, but still had all of the rhythmic characteristics that initially brought me to Naim.

Now maybe this is more reflective of the "new" Naim sound, but I think that the idea that the "flatness" of Naim is inherent in the electronics may be incorrect. Instead, the speakers that tend to attract Naim-owners may be keeping them in the pre-Columbian era of flatness.

Bruce
Posted on: 15 March 2004 by Top Cat
Virgos rock. But then I would say that...

That said, I think the 'flat' presentation is as much a factor of the way by which you set up your speakers (flat:round -> flat-against-the-wall versus free-space & slightly toed?) as anything inherent in the speakers themselves.

Glad you're liking the Virgos. Great speakers, I moved to them from Neat Petite III with Gravitas isobaric bases, all of that on Mana, and I've never regretted the move - more of everything except the deepest bass (Gravitas goes deeper than my Virgo III)

John
Posted on: 15 March 2004 by okyknot
I am currently trying a pair of Aerial Acoustics Model 5 (American sealed box monitors). I have noticed the same thing. The depth of sound is much greater than my Neat Petite IIIs. I am not going to sell my Neats yet, but I really do like the Aerials, which would probably be considered "Round Earth" by most on this forum.
Posted on: 15 March 2004 by okyknot
Been thinking about this one. What happens when you put the Flat Earth speakers with a Round Earth amp....?
Posted on: 15 March 2004 by blythe
quote:
Originally posted by okyknot:
Been thinking about this one. What happens when you put the Flat Earth speakers with a Round Earth amp....?

You go to sleep....Zzzzzzzz.
Boring music in, boring music out Big Grin

Computers are supposed to work on 1's and 0's - in other words "Yes" or "No" - why does mine frequently say "Maybe"?......