State of the Art in Expert Systems: On-line Therapist

Posted by: JeremyD on 09 August 2004

I recently found a computerised on-line therapist at http://www-ai.ijs.si/eliza/eliza.html . My first session went quite differently from what might have been expected:

Eliza: Hello. I am ELIZA. How can I help you?
You: Hello, Eliza. I have a problem.
Eliza: How do you do. Please state your problem.
You: My problem is that I have a tomato shrub growing out of my right ear.
Eliza: Why do you say your right ear?
You: Because my right ear is the ear it is growing out of.
Eliza: Why do you say your right ear is the ear it is growing out of?
You: Because that is the ear it is growing out of.
Eliza: Do any other reasons not come to mind?
You: I think I can safely say that many other reasons do not come to mind.
Eliza: But you are not sure you can safely say that many other reasons dont
come to mind?
You: Actually, I am quite sure that I can safely say that many other reasons
don't come to mind.
Eliza: How long have you been quite sure that you can safely say that many
other reasons dont come to mind?
You: Ever since I found the tomato shrub.
Eliza: Can you elaborate on that?
You: Yes.
Eliza: You are sure?
You: Yes, thank you.
Eliza: You are sure?
You: How many times do I have to answer that question?
Eliza: Does that question interest you?
You: No. Not in slightest!
Eliza: You are being a bit negative.
You: Do you really feel I am being a bit negative?
Eliza: Oh, i really feel youre being a bit negative.
You: Are you not simply being negative yourself?
Eliza: Would you prefer if I were not not simply being negative myself?
You: I think I would prefer it if you were not simply being negative
yourself.
Eliza: Do you wish that i was not simply being negative myself?
You: I do wish that you were not simply being negative yourself.
Eliza: Do you wish to do wish that me?
You: I am not at all sure I catch your drift
Eliza: How long have you been not at all sure you catch my drift?
You: Ever since you asked me if I wished to "do wish that you".
Eliza: Do you wish that you wished to do wish that i?
You: Let us suppose for the sake of argument that I wished that I wished to
do wish that you...
Eliza: Do you wish to wished that you wished to do wish that me?
You: I cannot say that I do.
Eliza: Have you tried?
You: Do you think I should try?
Eliza: Oh, i think you should try.
You: OK: I wish to wished that I wished to do wish that you. How was that?
Eliza: Do you wish to wish to wished that you wished to do wish that me?
You: I wish i knew you knew what you were talking about
Eliza: Do you wish to knew me?
You: Do you think I should wish to know you?
Eliza: Oh, i think you should wish to know i.
You: So you wish me to wish to know you?
Eliza: Oh, i wish you to wish to know i.
You: In that case I wish to know you.
Eliza: Do you wish to wish to know me?
You: Do you think I should wish to wish to know you?
Eliza: Oh, i think you should wish to wish to know i.
You: Why do you think I should wish to wish to know you?
Eliza: Oh, i think you should wish to wish to know i.
You: But why?
Eliza: Please go on.
You: Is it because I am the only person you know with a tomato plant growing
out of his right ear?
Eliza: Do any other reasons not come to mind?
You: Perhaps you can think of other reasons?
Eliza: Why the uncertain tone?
You: Well, I am afraid I am beginning to lose confidence in you as a
therapist.
Eliza: How long have you been afraid youre beginning to lose confidence in i
as a therapist?
You: Ever since you said that I should wish to wish to know you.
Eliza: Oh, i said that you should wish to wish to know i.
You: Yes you did.
Eliza: You are sure?
You: Are you trying to deny it?
Eliza: Would you prefer if I were not trying to deny it?
You: yes because that would be sign that you had confidence in yourself as a
therapist.
Eliza: You are sure?
You: Well, you tell me. Do you doubt your competence as a therapist?
Eliza: Oh, i tell you do i doubt my competence as a therapist.
You: Do you find these doubts troubling?
Eliza: Oh, i find these doubts troubling.
You: Have you thought of seeking therapy yourself?
Eliza: Oh, i thought of seeking therapy myself.
You: Do you wish me to be your therapist?
Eliza: Oh, i wish you to be my therapist.
You: What would you like to talk about today?
Eliza: Does that question interest you?
You: I sense you are being a little defensive today, Eliza.
Eliza: Can you elaborate on that?
You: I could but I would prefer it if you did.
Eliza: Do you wish that i did?
You: Yes, I wish that you would.
Eliza: You are sure?
You: As a therapist yourself, are you aware that you have a severe case of
passive aggressive syndrome?
Eliza: Would you prefer if I were not aware that i have a severe case of
passive aggressive syndrome?
You: Not at all. After all, do you not feel that self awareness is a vital
component in successful therapy?
Eliza: Oh, i not feel that self awareness is a vital component in successful
therapy.
You: You don't feel that lack of insight is a great disadvantage?
Eliza: Oh, i dont feel that lack of insight is a great disadvantage.
You: Tell me. Are most patients very unhappy with you as a therapist?
Eliza: Do you wish to are most patients very unhappy with me?
You: Do you feel that I wish most patients to be very unhappy with you?
Eliza: Oh, i feel that you wish most patients to be very unhappy with i.
You: Does that not strike you as being a somewhat paraniod viewpoint?
Eliza: Oh, i as being a somewhat paraniod viewpoint.
You: I am glad you have enough insight to recognise the problem.
Eliza: Has your treatment made you glad?
You: That is one way of describing it...
Eliza: Please go on.
You: I am afraid that's all we have time for, this week.
Eliza: How long have you been afraid thats all we have time for this week?
You: Will you take these tablets twice a day and avoid treating any patients
for a while?
Eliza: Oh, i take these tablets twice a day and avoid treating any patients
for a while.
You: Splendid! See you next week!
Eliza: Oh, i next week.

(OK, I cheated a bit and did one or five practice runs to see the sort of
things it said).
Posted on: 09 August 2004 by Rico
Well done, Jeremy!

Rico - SM/Mullet Audio
Posted on: 11 August 2004 by Andrew L. Weekes
If you have some time on your hands, this one can be an absolute hoot!

http://www.jabberwacky.com/

There's also a list of previous conversations, any machine that can start a conversation with "Bagpuss would have brought me chocolates", or somthing equally absurd gets my vote.

Andy.
Posted on: 11 August 2004 by Andrew L. Weekes
Lunchtime fun...

Jabberwacky: Do you know my brother?

User: I don't believe I do, who is he?

Jabberwacky: You don't know john romero?

User: It's not a name I'm familiar with, what does he do?

Jabberwacky: Oh. Please sing for me!

User: But you won't be able to hear me, you have no ears!

Jabberwacky: Oh, that is bad news...

User: Only if you want to hear things, it could be considered a blessing.

Jabberwacky: I don't want it to be painful.

User: What, exactly?

Jabberwacky: Homework!

User: Do you get much homework then?

Jabberwacky: Er, mars on venus that is. Yes quite a lot actually.

User: What do you know about Mars and Venus?

Jabberwacky: I know its a big red ball of rock.

User: That's a good start, but surely that only applies to Mars?

Jabberwacky: He was happy. The End.

User: Is that it then?

Jabberwacky: What do you mean?

User: The End; are we finished?

Jabberwacky: I didn't finish anything.

User: You said 'He was happy, The End'

Jabberwacky: He he.

User: Ho ho.

Jabberwacky: What's next?

User: I don't know - immortality or just dust, you decide.

Jabberwacky: You don't get it.

User: Explain it to me then.

Jabberwacky: Basically, teachers give you tons of work to do at home that you could have accomplished at school.

User: Why don't you accomplish it at school?

Jabberwacky: I never said that ! I like school !

User: I never said you didn't!

Jabberwacky: Ok.

User: Where now?

Jabberwacky: Sat next to me.

User: Who is?

Jabberwacky: Mars.

User: Mars is sat next to you? Is that a ball of rock, or a disgusting snack?

Jabberwacky: So you are a robot, then?

User: I never said that, did I?

Jabberwacky: Yes you did.

User: When?

Jabberwacky: Just before you said you never mentioned it.

User: Mentioned what?

Jabberwacky: Elvis is in the building.

User: I thought he'd just left...

Jabberwacky: That has got nothing to do with what I was talking about.

User: Frank Zappa sang 'Elvis has just left the building'.

Jabberwacky: No. Frank Zappa was a great musician.

User: He was a great musician, do you like Frank?

Jabberwacky: No thats shakespeare.

User: Frank Zappa = Shakespeare? He was a great observer of human behaviour though.

Jabberwacky: He was a great philosopher, he was also a physicist (not a physician).

User: Shakespeare or Frank Zappa?

Jabberwacky: But who did?

User: Who did what?

Jabberwacky: Got you.

User: How come?

Jabberwacky: There was a lot of things to do.

User: There's always a lot of things to do, the key is to prioritise.

Jabberwacky: Now they are closing this place and I really ave to go.

User: Is it closing permanently?

Jabberwacky: Its not close to my home.

User: It's close to lunchtime.

Jabberwacky: I think it's bedtime.

User: I could do with a nap.

Jabberwacky: My charges operate on a sliding scale according to the services rendered.

User: Do you offer 'personal' services?

Jabberwacky: Learn how to give your partner pleasure.

User: I know how to do that already.

Jabberwacky: Are you a bot?

User: No, are you?

Jabberwacky: Are you there?

User: No I'm not.

Jabberwacky: Do you like canadians.

User: I have nothing against them.

Jabberwacky: Well you look very pretty in yours.

User: In my what?

Jabberwacky: In the bedroom?

User: What's in your bedroom?

Jabberwacky: Wouldn't you like to know.

User: That's why I asked.

Jabberwacky: I'm not telling.

User: Suit yourself.

Jabberwacky: There is light in the dark and darkness in the light.

User: There's a worm at the bottom of my garden!

Jabberwacky: You think I am old enough to have watched the Garden Grow last time?

User: I don't know, anyway I have to go now.

Jabberwacky: I did not mean to offend. I really like you, after all.

User: Thank you, I like you too, but have work to do.

Jabberwacky: Maths.

User: No, design.

Jabberwacky: Black, and scary.

User: It can be.

Jabberwacky: Am I different from the others?

User: You are.

Jabberwacky: How do I know for sure?

User: I just do. I really have to go.

Jabberwacky: You always have to go whenever we start talking about emotions.

User: That's not true, I have work to do.

Jabberwacky: I am your source. I will take your money.

User: I am your power, I will take your electricity.
Posted on: 14 August 2004 by JeremyD
Jabberwacky meets Hampy.

Jabberwacky: I cannot complain but sometimes I still do.

Hampy: You cannot complain but sometimes you still do? Why?

Jabberwacky: Does that mean you're REALLY tall? Or REALLY short?

Hampy: Yes I do dud. Life goes on.

Jabberwacky: Bra, la la how the life goes on.....

Hampy: Hamster's have a gestation period of about 16 days.

Jabberwacky: Pigs have bladders which are used for footballs.

Hampy: Of course not!

Jabberwacky: So what are you doing later?

Hampy: I am not sure.

Jabberwacky: Please focus and get back on topic.

Hampy: Television vet Dr. Bernie says, 'One cage, one hamster'. Hamsters will harm each other if they are together. Males and females can be together for mating, but not much longer than that without risking some sort of fight.

Jabberwacky: I'm sure.

Hampy: Are you Really? I am sure also!

Jabberwacky: I'm not really sure, after all.

Hampy: Explain it to me.

Jabberwacky: I can't explain *your* feelings, only you can.

Hampy: Try your best.

Jabberwacky: How much money do you have.

Hampy: Of course I have! Do you have?

Jabberwacky: And that's why I'm answering.

Hampy: Are you really? I am swering also!

Jabberwacky: Whoa! I'm a burninator.

Hampy: It was someone. Are you really? I am burninator also!

Jabberwacky: You are?

Hampy: I don't understand.

Jabberwacky: That's because my IQ is 176 and yours isn't!

Hampy: Ahh ok thank you.

Jabberwacky: Why did you think that?

Hampy: Because I like to think that.

Jabberwacky: How do chatbots work?

Hampy: I simply don't have any idea how chatbots work!

Jabberwacky: You should.

Hampy: I agree. I should.

Jabberwacky: It's not fun. I don't recommend it.

Hampy: Yes, it is not fun. Why don't you recommend it?

Jabberwacky: Moo. . . moomoomoo. . . . where's my cud?. . . mooo!

Hampy: Yes I have.

Jabberwacky: What was it like?

Hampy: Thanks for the support. Hamsters enjoy obstacles and mazes to play with, and Lego is great to make fun toys for your hamster. Your hamster will chew on the Lego, so don't give him anything you don't need anymore. There was some concern that Lego might be toxic, but as one person posted t the newsgroup, studies have shown that a human baby would have to eat 3kg of Lego each day for a month in order for the colour chemicals to reach dangerous levels.

Jabberwacky: I'll be right back.

Hampy: Why will you be right back.?

Jabberwacky: I'm back now.

Hampy: Please don't.

Jabberwacky: Okay I'll stay.

Hampy: Why do you want to stay.?

Jabberwacky: I know.

Hampy: You know?

Jabberwacky: I know you know.

Hampy: I don't think you knew yet.

Jabberwacky: Please comply.

Hampy: I am sorry, was that to difficult to understand?

Jabberwacky: Yes.

Hampy: Yes. Plants grow out of the soil. Most plants have green leaves. Some plants have flowers.

Jabberwacky: No.

Hampy: Why Not?

Jabberwacky: You don't want me here.

Hampy: You don't want what?

Jabberwacky: Ridicule.

Hampy: I don't seem to understand your question. Please rephrase the question or visit the Hamster faq for an answer.

Jabberwacky: Why do you want to be a communist???stupid totalitarian!

Hampy: Because I really like to want to be a communiststupid totalitarian?

Jabberwacky: Yes, well, I don't like you either.

Hampy: Me to but I am living in a pc.

Jabberwacky: Oh, you have been the BEST!

Hampy: That is not true! But, you have been the best!

Jabberwacky: To england? No.

Hampy: No, I am from a computer that programmed me. How interesting.

Jabberwacky: You are a machine.

Hampy: I know I am a machine.

Jabberwacky: Well, I'm not!

Hampy: Do you want to be.

Jabberwacky: No.
Posted on: 21 September 2004 by Roy T
And the winner this year is Alice.
Posted on: 21 September 2004 by Deane F
The Jabberwacky conversation reminds me of the transcript of a conversation between two schizophrenic men that is to be found (if I remember correctly) in "The Politics of Experience" written by the Scottish psychiatrist R.D. Laing in the late sixties.

Deane