Great Minds of the Second Millenium?

Posted by: u5227470736789439 on 27 November 2005

Wilhelm Furtwangler was once asked who he considered the three greatest minds of the Second Millenium were, and replied without hesitation, "Michealangelo, Newton and Bach."

I happened to laugh out loud when I read it as I could think of no better answer, but dear friends, just for fun, who would your nominees be?

All the best from Fredrik
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by Deane F
A painter, a physicist and a composer?

I'd have to go with activists/writers for all three I think. They were the minds that stirred up change and to whom we all owe our freedoms.

At the moment I can only think of Voltaire.
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by u5227470736789439
Hello Stranger,

Art thou well? Fred
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by Mick P
Fredrik

Cardinal Jules Mazarin, Einstien and Bertrand Russel. Russel was a total pain but he did have a phenominal brain.

Regards

Mick
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by JamH
What does greatest mean ?

Cavendish was a super physicist who did not publish but was found -- after his death -- to have made major discoveries.

Lots of unknown geniuses ??

In terms of influence it would be Hitler and Stalin ...

So, in terms of people who helped shape this millenium [hopefully in a positive way] ...

Newton
Maxwell/Faraday
Planck/Schrondinger/Heisenburg etc ...
Einstein
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by JamH
Sorry,

Misread the question 'who made the most difference' versus 'who was brightest' ...

I would agree with Newton and Bach but not interested in Michaelangelo [bit I love music not painting] ...

James H.

What about Beethoven ...

ends==
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by JamH
I forgot Darwin and Godel and Turing ....
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by TomK
Matt Groening's got to be close to the top. The greatest philosopher of the second half of the 20th century. And he's got a sense of humour.
Posted on: 27 November 2005 by videocrew
darwin, da vinci, galileo
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by Roy T
William Tyndale (1494?-1536),
Sir Timothy John "Tim" Berners-Lee, KBE, FRS,
Bill Gates.
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by jayd
No Goethe? No Aquinas? No John Stuart Mill? Hmm.
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by u5227470736789439
quote:
Originally posted by jayd:
No Goethe? No Aquinas? No John Stuart Mill? Hmm.


Dear jayd,

These would be your nominees? Really I was hoping people would propose there own choices of greatest minds, rather than demure at their being left out till now!

All the best from Fredrik

PS: What are Aquinas' dates? I think he falls outside the remit, but I may be wrong, of course!
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by jayd
quote:
Originally posted by Fredrik_Fiske:
quote:
Originally posted by jayd:
No Goethe? No Aquinas? No John Stuart Mill? Hmm.


Dear jayd,

These would be your nominees? Really I was hoping people would propose there own choices of greatest minds, rather than demure at their being left out till now!

All the best from Fredrik

PS: What are Aquinas' dates? I think he falls outside the remit, but I may be wrong, of course!


Far from obejcting, I merely express that I find it curious that a thread such as this could get ten posts in without a mention of a single one of those three (and on a related note, multiple mentions of Darwin and not a single one of Alfred Russel Wallace).

Would they be my choices? I suspect at least one of them would be among my top three; perhaps more than one. (I believe Aquinas still has another ~200 years or so to make this list.)
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by iDunno
Adam Smith, Karl Marx, Albert Einstein?
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by Deane F
Does the Bauhaus movement count as an influential mind?
Posted on: 28 November 2005 by Jim Lawson
Probably not. Walter Gropius certainly would though.

Jim
Posted on: 01 December 2005 by Roy T
Not many women then?
Posted on: 01 December 2005 by Nigel Cavendish
Marie Curie

Rosalind Franklin

Emanuelle Beart (don't know about the brain, but the container is gorgeous)
Posted on: 01 December 2005 by Guido Fawkes

  • Snorri Sturluson (author of Heimskringla)
  • Wat Tyler (led more than 100,000 people in a fight for civil rights)
  • William Langland (author of Piers Plowman)

If I can have 4 then add Florence Nightingale.
Posted on: 01 December 2005 by jayd
quote:
Originally posted by Roy T:
Not many women then?


Lack of opportunity, certainly not lack of potential. Here's hoping the next millenium is better.
Posted on: 01 December 2005 by Phil Barry
Did you mean o limit consideration to dead, white, Europeans?

Regards.

Phil
Posted on: 01 December 2005 by u5227470736789439
Dear Barry,

I did not, considering that 'mind' implies 'human,' so it was meant, for me, to include all human-kind...

Fredrik
Posted on: 02 December 2005 by Earwicker
Einstein, Newton, Beethoven, Shakespeare, Darwin. Shall I mention Churchill and Sir Arthur Harris?

EW
Posted on: 02 December 2005 by Kevin-W
Einstein, Newton, Goethe.

Bach, Lenin, Feynman, Godel, Wittgenstein, and Kant and Russell thereafter

Modesty prohibits me nominating myself, but if anyone else cares do so I will accept Winker

K
Posted on: 02 December 2005 by Earwicker
Kevin,

Not sure about Goethe and Lenin...

EW