Is it worth to even consider a Tuner in my area of NYC?

Posted by: Jaybar on 30 March 2001

I live in an area with EXTREME multipath problems, being between the Booklyn and Manhattan bridges. My apartment complex does not permit an antennae and I am limmited to the kind of ribbon antennae that attaches to the tuner and hangs down. Is it even worth considering a Naim tuner? or any tuner? Years ago, before my current Spectral/Naim sytem, I yried a Yamaha and NAD tuner with disasterous results. Again, is it worth considering again?

Jay Fischer

Posted on: 30 March 2001 by Paul B
Jay:

Have you considered trying the Magnum-Dynalab whip antenna (ST-2 Vertical, Omnidirectional FM Antenna) with a Naim tuner. It can be used outside or inside and gives much better results than a ribbon antenna. I use one indoors with an 02. It is worth trying because a Naim tuner is truly worth the effort. It could end up being you most used and best source.

Paul

Posted on: 31 March 2001 by Arthur Bye
Jaybar:

I have an apartment in Philadelphia with lots of multipath singal problems. I have tried 3 differenct tuners.

The first was a Sony ES-50 that worked passably but frequently would get out of sorts with multipath reflections and I eventually gave up on it.

My next try was a Linn Kremlin. This on worked a good bit better that the Sony (at 8 times the cost), but still had problems with multipath. I found myself too often using the mono switch to clean things up. If I had to live with it I would have survived as its a great tuner and does a good job of locking in stations. It also has a remote control which is nice.

Lastly I tried a Nat-01. It was like two steps up in quality and control. The Nat-01 locks onto stations like a dog to a bone, and stays there. It was definitely a keeper. The analog control means no remote control but the dramatic increase in sound quality was worth the upgrade. The downside is that the Nat-01 could only get about 2/3 of the stations that the Linn Kremlin could.

I finally upgraded to a Ron Smith Galaxie antenna which increased the number of stations I could get and imporved the signal strength as well. The Kremlin worked better as well in the RS antenna, but the difference in sound quality against the Nat-01 is still there. Analog tuners are simply better than digital ones.

I agree with the prior post to stay away from signal amplifiers. I had poor success with them as well.

The Nat-01 is an incredible tuner that has to be heard to be believed.

Arthur Bye

Posted on: 31 March 2001 by Jaybar
I have no balcony and cannot hang things out the window. Where would I place the freakin antenna?

Jay