Desert Island Al***s '05...

Posted by: bhazen on 22 August 2005

...Yes, it's time to play the game again!

If you were to be exiled to some rock where you'd be cut off from all new music, and your captors only allowed you room for 10 albums in your rucksack, what would you take? (I know, cruel captors...)

Here's mine, if push comes to shove...

1, the Beatles; it's impossible for me to pick any album by them, so this packed with hits compilation will have to suffice.

Elements, Jade Warrior; simultaneously beautiful, meditative and dangerous, like a good samurai movie. This may be cheating: the slim jewel-case contains all four of their (relatively brief) albums from the Island Records era.

Retrospective, the Animals; the toughest of the early British Invasion R'n'B groups. Also, from my hometown's namesake city, in Geordie-land. What does Geordie mean, by the way?

Days of Future Passed, the Moody Blues; when stripped of the Mantovani interludes, a brilliant psychedelic pop album. All hail the mighty Mellotron!

India's Master Musician, Ravi Shankar; like a lot of weekend hippies from the 60's, this is my other way of enjoying Indian culture.

Grand Hotel, Procol Harum; a sophisticated album with memorable melodies, powerful playing and an emotional, world-weary ambiance.

Singles Collection* The London Years, the Rolling Stones; you could substitute disc 1 of Forty Licks for this, but then you'd be losing tracks like "Play With Fire"...

From The Orignal Master Tapes, Buddy Holly; early re-mastering of the Bard of Lubbock's hits, still essential.

Apple Venus Volume I & II, XTC; another cheat (I'm sticking them both in a slim jewel-case). Stunning, emotional, brilliant.

The Ultimate Collection, the Kinks; arguably the only other 60's band whose singles rival the Beatles' in quality.

There it is, honeys; my heart on my sleeve, deca-disc stylee. Let's see yours!
Posted on: 22 August 2005 by Guido Fawkes
Here goes


  • 62-66 - Beatles
  • 67-70 - Beatles
  • Folk Routes, New Routes - Shirley Collins & Davey Graham
  • 5000 Spirits - Incredible String Band
  • Rubble Collection Vols 1 & 2 (Can I count this as one?)
  • Village Green Preservation Society - Kinks
  • ACD - Half Man Half Biscuit
  • Trouble over Bridgewater - Half Man Half Biscuit
  • Piper at the Gates of Dawn - Pink Floyd (Please can I have See Emily Play and Arnold Layne as bonus tracks on it)
  • SF Sorrow - Pretty Things


If the captors stole 9 of 'em then I'd like to keep ACD by HMHB, as I'd need a laugh and a reminder of home (Trumpton).

Presume I've got a CDS3/552/500/DBL to play them on

Rotf
Posted on: 22 August 2005 by bhazen
Rotf - I like your list! I'll have to check out Half Man Half Biscuit (I'm all biscuit myself)...
Posted on: 22 August 2005 by seagull
My list has stood the test of time so nothing remotely new...



  • Disintegration - The Cure. Robert Smith at his best
  • Script of a Bridge - The Chameleons, did I ever say I like the Chameleons? Everyone should!!
  • Godbluff - Van Der Graaf Generator (only 35 minutes long, could I sneak in Still Life as well?) No thinking about it I'll take The Box, 4 CDs of VdGG!!!!
  • Coma Divine - Porcupine Tree. Superb triple live album (on vinyl of course)
  • Porcupine - Echo and the Bunnymen - on the TT now!
  • New Gold Dream - Simple Minds
  • New Boots and Panties - Ian Dury and the Blockheads, the later pressing with Sex'n'Drugs'n'Rock'n'Roll. It has the best use of a synthesiser of any record before or since on Blockheads.
  • Correct Use of Soap - Magazine
  • Unknown Pleasures - Joy Division

    And last and by no means least...

  • Colossal Youth - Young Marble Giants. Something quiet after all the mayhem.


What a bundle of laughs that lot is!

Well I'm home alone this week so that's my play list sorted...
Posted on: 22 August 2005 by NaimDropper
Can I just bring along 10 iPods?
(And a way to charge them, of course!)
David
Posted on: 22 August 2005 by bhazen
quote:
Originally posted by NaimDropper:
Can I just bring along 10 iPods?


Only if you tell us your favourite 10 albums contained therein!
Posted on: 22 August 2005 by Bruce Woodhouse
In no particular order, and without really thinking too hard-which is probably the best way I guess.

Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan: Musst Musst. Captivating, strange, and brilliant.

Jethro Tull: Aqualung (or Stand Up). Discovering 'Tull turned me on to music

Prefab Sprout: Steve McQueen. For 'Bonny', the track that makes me a student again.

Billy Bragg: Don't Try This At Home. Sharp, direct, witty, and in places achingly sad.

Remmy Ongala: Songs For The Poor Man. Irresistible rhythm from the godfather of Tanzanian music.

Willard Grant Conspiracy: Regard The End. A Southern materpiece of sadness with just enough tongue-in-cheek.

Arvo Part: Te Deum. See Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, somehow.

Yo La Tengo: Prisoners Of Love (3CD compilation!). Raucous, varied, slightly mad.

Leonard Cohen: Ten New Songs. Grumbling old man just manages to hang on for another album. Marvellous.

Lambchop: Is A Woman. Rich and subtle.

There's an eclectic bunch for you. Hope this list and others inspire some people to buy some new music (and at least some of mine are from the last two decades!)

Bruce
Posted on: 23 August 2005 by jezaranski
..... without thinking (too much)

Beatles - Sgt Peppers
Pixies - Surfer Rosa
Nick Drake - Five Leaves Left
Yo La Tengo - and then nothing turned itself inside out
Grandaddy - Sophtware Slump
Stone Roses - Stone Roses
Dismemberment Plan - Emergency & I
Guided By Voices - Bee thousand
Sonic Youth - Daydream Nation
New Order - Substance 87
Posted on: 23 August 2005 by Chris Kelly
Love - Forever Changes
Beatles - Revolver
J.J. Cale - Anyway the wind blows (anthology)
Cream - Wheels of Fire
The Doors - First Album
Bob Seger - Nine Tonight
Bruce Springsteen - Born to Run
Neil Young - After the Goldrush
Pink Floyd - Echoes
Beach Boys - Greatest hits album
Posted on: 23 August 2005 by domfjbrown
quote:
Originally posted by ROTF:
[LIST]
  • 63-66 - Beatles


  • ROTF - that's only nine, as that Beatles album doesn't exist (it's 62-66 Smile)

    Assuming (based on others' postings) that greatest hits comps are OK...

    Forever Changes - Love
    Revolver - Beatles
    L.A. Woman - The Doors
    Various - Reactivate 13 ("beats, chance and liquid trance")
    Sun spot - Dark Soho
    Legend - Bob Marley
    The dreaming - Kate Bush
    Relics - Pink Floyd (ties in most of Piper, AND gets "See Emily play" and "Arnold Layne" Winker)
    The queen is dead - The Smiths
    Substance - Joy Division

    Job's a good 'un!
    Posted on: 23 August 2005 by bhazen
    quote:
    Originally posted by domfjbrown:
    Assuming (based on others' postings) that greatest hits comps are OK...


    Absolutely! Note that 50% of my selections count as such. I also count the Beatles' 1962 - 1966 and 1967 - 1970 (the "red" and "blue" albums) as essentially one album.
    Posted on: 24 August 2005 by John M
    Here are my entries

    Rolling Stones - Dirty Work
    Fleetwood Mac - Time
    Hagar Schon Aaronson and Shrieve - HSAS
    GG Allin - Anti Social Personality Disorder
    Jon Anderson - Olias of Sunhillow
    Ethel Merman - The Disco Album
    Olivia Newton-John - Totally Hot
    Rod Stewart - Tonight I'm Yours
    Billy Squier - Don't Say No
    REO Speedwagon - Essential (?!?!?!) Remastered (#$%!?!?)

    for my desert island in the warm climes of HELL Winker
    Posted on: 27 August 2005 by bhazen
    I'd love to see Howard's (BigH47) ten ...
    Posted on: 27 August 2005 by BigH47
    bhazen your wish is......

    2112 - Rush
    DSOTM - Pink Floyd
    Rumours - Fleetwood Mac
    Fragile - Yes
    Wes Bound - Lee Ritenour
    Minstrel in the Gallery - Jethro Tull
    Amazing Things - Runrig
    Brain Salad Surgery - ELP
    Straight Shooter - Bad Co
    Fear of the Dark - Gordon Giltrap

    Not including Best ofs

    Top 10 as of this instant in time,ask me in few days and I'll probably change some choices.

    Howard
    Posted on: 29 August 2005 by Ian T J
    Right now it would be:
    - Talk Talk; Spirit of Eden
    - Peter Gabriel; Secret World Live
    - Gentle Giant; Playing the Fool, Live
    - Joni Mitchell; Don Juan's Reckless Daughter
    - Marillion; Brave
    - The Cinematic Orchestra; Everyday
    - Stravinksy; The Firebird and The Rite of Spring on Deutshe Gramaphon.
    - Sting; Bring on the Night
    - Thomas Dolby; Aliens ate my Buick
    - Genesis; The Lamb Lies Down on Braodway
    Posted on: 29 August 2005 by u77033103172058601
    Given that a desert island is just another form of hell, with death being the only release, then my choices would be

    Gorecki Miserere - just to set the mood
    Gorecki Symphony 3 - getting more morose
    Allegri Miserere - divine music but underlining the whole futility of life
    28 days later the soundtrack - there is no hope
    Warren Zevon The Wind - a great swansong
    Purcell The Complete Funeral Music for Queen Mary - lightening the mood a bit
    Arab Strap Philophobia; the lull before the storm
    Tchaikovsky 6 but movement 2 only; plumbing the depths of despair, going downhill fast now
    Roger Waters Amused to Death - mankind's follies
    Pink Floyd The Final Cut - manind's follies realised
    Posted on: 29 August 2005 by Muttly
    Okay these are my ten:

    Faith No More - The Real Thing
    Led Zeppelin - How The West Was Won
    Primal Scream - Screamadelica
    Talking Heads - Stop Making Sense
    Nine Inch Nails - The Downward Spiral
    Johnny Cash - American IV: The Man Comes Around
    Frankie Goes to Hollywood - Welcome to the Pleasuredome
    Rage Against The Machine - Rage Against the Machine
    Pink Floyd - Wish you were here
    Dire Straits - Brothers In Arms

    edit due to ficklety: dropped Stones Roses, brought on a late sub Winker

    SJH
    Posted on: 30 August 2005 by ClaudeP
    quote:
    Originally posted by John M:

    Olivia Newton-John - Totally Hot


    Huh?

    I am a die-hard ONJ fan, but "Totally Hot" would probably figure dead last on any of my lists...

    Have you ever heard "Don't Stop Believin'"?
    Posted on: 01 September 2005 by bishopla
    Abbey Road
    Led Zeppelin II
    Brain Salad Surgery – ELP
    Hounds of Love – Kate Bush
    SO – Peter Gabriel
    Foxtrot – Genesis
    Close to the Edge – Yes
    Gaucho – Steely Dan
    The Wall – Pink Floyd
    Bitches Brew – Miles Davis
    Posted on: 03 September 2005 by Stevedog
    Then Play On ... Fleetwood Mac
    Physical Graffiti .. Led Zepplin
    Spanners... Black Dog
    Second Toughest in the Infants... Underworld
    Candy Apple Grey... Husker Du
    You......... Gong
    Hounds of Love... Kate Bush
    Boxed Set.... Free
    Tago mago.... Can
    Glee..... Bran Van 3000
    Posted on: 03 September 2005 by Jay
    I'm waiting for someone to do "what albums would have on your iPod is you were on a desert island?" Big Grin
    Posted on: 03 September 2005 by MichaelC
    Hawkwind - Space Ritual
    Hawkwind - Yule Ritual
    Gong - Camembert Electrique
    Psychedelic Warriors - White Zone
    Led Zeppelin - How the West Was Won
    Pink Floyd - Echoes
    Yes - Yes
    Rush - Farewell to Kings
    Neil Young - Decade
    Steely Dan - Aja

    Lots of cheats here!!!
    Posted on: 03 September 2005 by Guido Fawkes
    quote:
    Originally posted by Jay:
    I'm waiting for someone to do "what albums would have on your iPod is you were on a desert island?" Big Grin


    Jay - I started listing them but the posting software won't handle more than 15,000 lines.

    It is difficult to agree an iPod's capacity as although it's advertised as being able to hold 40,000 songs, I found it could only cope with 16 progressive rock tracks.
    Posted on: 04 September 2005 by bhazen
    quote:
    Originally posted by MichaelC:
    Lots of cheats here!!!


    MC: There are no cheats, as long as you don't list more than 10 titles.

    Re: iPod; yes, that would be the ideal way to take your music with, as all you'd have to grab as the guards are hauling you away is one item. If the capacity is as advertised, I could get almost my entire CD collection into one! Amazing.

    I'm liking the high percentage of Space Rock and Prog showing up on these lists; good taste guys! Keep it going!

    BTW, I'm awaiting delivery of Eclipse, a Hawkwind CD anthology. This will be filed alongside my Motorhead one, for listening to when reading Michael Moorcock and Mick Farren books. Yeah baby.
    Posted on: 04 September 2005 by Sloop John B
    Bob Dylan - Blood on the tracks
    Beatles - White album
    Moving Heats Moving Hearts
    Frank Black Teenager of the year
    Rory Gallagher - Live in Europe
    Thin Lizzy - Fighting
    U2 Achtung Baby
    White Stripes - White Blood Cells
    Various - Dave Godins Deep soul treasures vol 1
    Portishead - Dummy
    Posted on: 05 September 2005 by Milan
    Led Zeppelin How The West Was Won
    Free Fire and Water
    Steve Earle Copperhead Road
    Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here
    Del Amitri Change Everything
    Nils Lofgren Live Acoustic
    Jethro Tull Broadsword and the Beast
    Radiohead The Bends
    Rush All the Worlds a Stage
    Eric Clapton Just One Night

    Well, that is todays selection. Tomorrow is another day!