A Firm Recommendation in Bach

Posted by: u5227470736789439 on 11 November 2007

Dear Friends,

Last night I listened for the nth. time to Adolf Busch's estimable recordings of the Bach Orchestral Suites recorded in the thirties for EMI in Abbey Road.

It is always wonderful to come across a recording of favourite music that never fades in its glory. Certainly the case with the musicianship of Adolf Busch, but last night I listened as if I had never had the chance before. Apart from Rudolf Serkin playing the piano continuo [rather then using a harpsichord] and the strings using more vibrato on occasion than is the norm nowadays I was suddenly struck but how wonderful the playing really is! Fresh, and at least as lucid in its musical balance as any modern HIP style performance I know. The thing that suddenly hit was the way the Badinerie [last movement of the Second Suite in B Minor with Solo Flute] is both fleet and filled with glorious tone, let alone being supremely tasteful musically. I then had to listen to the Suite straight off again, simply marveling about how an on old friend of a recording still has secrets to yield!

There is an excellent transfer on Pearl [Pavilion Records] GEMM 9263 - Three CDs containing the Brandenburgs Concertos and the Orchestral Suites. Though I would not generally advise this as the first recomendation, I would say that anyone who enjoys and loves this music should have this recording to run beside a more modern account!

ATB from George
Posted on: 13 November 2007 by u5227470736789439
To open this up a bit, I wonder if any here would care to post about their own old favourite "comfort blanket" recordings which have perhaps suddenly still managed to provide a revelation after long acquaintance?

ATB from George
Posted on: 14 November 2007 by Huwge
Malcolm Arnold's Dances, LPO led by the composer. Always cheers me up
Posted on: 14 November 2007 by naim_nymph
In the 1980's I had a Mozart Requiem on vinyl. Although the version was very good (imho) at the time i took it for granted. I tranferred it on to a TDK AD60 from rega planner to technics tape deck, so i could listern to it in the car... In to the 1990's my lp's were sold and my cd collection of classical music started to grow. However, i missed the mozart requiem i used to play but i had not even noted who conducted it or which orchestra it was. So other versions on cd were enjoyed instead... To my delight, yesterday (while looking in an old box in the loft), i found a old AD 60 tape with some useful information written on it... and i've just played it on my nakamichi, after 18 years without hearing this i can say this version (or interpretation) scratches my itch more than any other Mozart Requiem i've heard... not to say i don't enjoy them all in one way or another : )

Conducters ~<>~ Rafael frubeck de Burgos, and Otto Klemperer

New Philharmonia Orchestra

Sopprano ~<>~ Edith Mathis
Contralto ~<>~ Grace Bumbry
Tenor ~<>~ George Shirley
Bass ~<>~ Marius Rintzler

Record label - Cfp

Amazon have this dated at Nov 2006 - must be when it was put on to cd!

Can anyone tell me the date when this was performed ?

I've just ordered it on cd so i'll find out soon, let's hope the digital transfer hasn't sucked the soul out of it!

Posted on: 14 November 2007 by Earwicker
Probably Bohm's recording of the Pastoral Symphony with the Vienna Philharmonic, although I'm increasingly turning to Parsifal for solace - mainly via Knappertsbusch's various recordings. Must be a redemption thing! ;-)

Generally, it's a striking fact that there's little solace in some of my favourite music, e.g. Hammerklavier Sonata, Missa solemnis, Ein Deutsches Requiem, late Liszt, Bartok etc.

EW
Posted on: 16 November 2007 by naim_nymph
>Can anyone tell me the date when this was performed ?

>I've just ordered it on cd so i'll find out soon, let's hope the digital transfer hasn't sucked >the soul out of it!

Just to anwser my own questions! : )
It was performed and recorded in 1967 @ Kingway Hall London, available on record 1968 and quite nicely digitally remastered in 1989 by EMI Records Ltd...

My order came yesterday and this cd version is truly excellent, plus an extra track...

Masonic Funeral Music K477 - 5 minutes 26 seconds and quite stunning, performed in No 1 studio Abbey Road London 14 nov 1964 and imo the digital remastering @ Abbey Road in 2000 is slightly better than the Requiem. I admit to beleiving this to be a very recent recording until i read the sleeve inlay information!

This takes the ablum to 59'48" of superb listerning. Well recommended, and the amazon price is only £4.97!!