Advanced search

What is the worst song ever?

Posted by: woodface on 13 November 2001

My vote goes to the amazingly banal 'Heart' with 'All I wanna do is make love to you'. Heard it on the radio today and was reminded just how bad ,lyrically, a song can be. 'He brought the woman out of me, many times, easily' is just one of the many lowlights!
Posted on: 15 November 2001 by JohnS
Even before seeing the opening scene in "Priscilla, Queen of the Desert" with the "I've Never Been To Me" drag piece, I always believed that this is an unintentionally great comedy track.

My friend Jen, upon hearing "..and I've seen some things, that a woman just ain't s'posed to see", said "What are those things? What are those things that a woman just ain't s'posed to see?". For the life of us, neither of us could think what they might be. Any suggestions? Stallion?

-John

Posted on: 16 November 2001 by Former member
confused
Posted on: 16 November 2001 by Pete
quote:
Originally posted by woodface:
I knew there would be a Heart fan out there. What distresses me most about this particular record is that you can tell that the singer thinks the lyrics are really deep and meaningful.

I wouldn't call myself a fan: just have Dreamboat Annie that I picked up 2nd hand 'cause it had "Crazy On You" on it which I liked. Rest of the album's good too.

"Thinks the lyrics are really deep and meaningul"? Cynic that I am, I'd say Ms. Wilson thought they'd make a shedload of cash. Which is pretty meaningful in its way, I suppose... Compare and contrast "Magic Man" for a rather better shot at a not entirely dissimilar theme.

Pete.

Posted on: 16 November 2001 by David Stewart
Two Little Boys - Rolf Harris
Merry Xmas Everybody - Slade

and anything by Celine Dion or Charlotte Church!!
I wonder - who does buy Celine Dion's stuff?? will anybody on this forum own up to it??

David

Posted on: 16 November 2001 by Former member
Amazing Grace - loathe this song

Whiter Shade of Pale

The first time ever I saw her/his face - heard this on the radio sung by Peggy Seegar ghastly in the extreme.

Yours in naim only

Declan

Posted on: 16 November 2001 by Steve Catterall
Pete

If you like 'Dreamboat Annie', you should try listening to the 'Little Queen' ... much the same sort blend of Zep style rockers with folk influences, but a little better IMO.

Posted on: 22 November 2001 by Shayman
Lots of people may disagree with me but for utter utter rubbish you can't beat 'I Believe I Can Fly' sung by R Kelly. The inscesant 'dramatic' key modulations and piss poor flow of lyric has never ceased to amaze me.

Jonathan

PS Oh and that one about 'You can reach me by .....this that and the other' that became the Gulf War anthem here in the UK was pretty bad too. Cant remember who sang it.

Posted on: 22 November 2001 by Bosh
"I believe I can fly" - was that the song that Keith and Orville did? That was a classic wink
Posted on: 22 November 2001 by Former member
"You can retch me by this that and the other" was by Oleta Adams IIRC.
Posted on: 30 November 2001 by Keith Mattox
But by far the worst ever put out there was released in the States around 1974: "Afternoon Delight" by The Starland Vocal Band. I would hope that it never made it across the Atlantic.

Cheers

Keith.

PS - how can some hate Amazing Grace? My goodness...

Posted on: 03 December 2001 by matthewr
And as wonderful Tanya Headon points out in her fantastic weblog I Hate Music, David Letterman owes his start on TV to The Starland Vocal Band.

However, it has recently come to my attention that the man responsible for the very worst music ever is one Leo Boyle.

I've not heard his music but this picture:

has me convinced.

Matthew

Posted on: 03 December 2001 by John C
I'd recognise those ears anywhere.

John.

Posted on: 03 December 2001 by matthewr
John,

You know you might be right -- that would make this photograph an early Vuksanovic from the period where Vuk had yet to persuade any women to act out his weird FemDom/S&M fantasties and so practised on his college roomates instead. Poor Joe was probably just given a couple of Kraft TV Dinners in return for this humuliation and you do wonder how it may have affected him long term.

Matthew

Posted on: 03 December 2001 by John C
"and you do wonder how it may have affected him long term"

And we've all seen Deliverance.

John

Posted on: 04 December 2001 by Joe Petrik
John,

As you can clearly see in this attachment, moving to Kentucky has had no effect on me.

Oh, and my contibution to the worst songs ever...

* Cher's "I believe" -- a song which tipped off Buffy that her roommate, Cathy, was a demon, since Cathy played it over and over (something that no mortal could endure apart from Mike H.'s wife... hmmm)

* Styx's "Mr. Roboto" -- a song so bad that it led one reviewer to proclaim, if there previously had been any doubt, that Styx Stynx)

* Billy Ray's "Achy breaky heart" -- country + mullet... nuff said

Joe

Posted on: 04 December 2001 by Duncan Fullerton
quote:
But by far the worst ever put out there was released in the States around 1974: "Afternoon Delight" by The Starland Vocal Band. I would hope that it never made it across the Atlantic.

How dare you defile my memories, Sir! This I remember. It brings back happy memories of really hot summer school holidays.

AFAIR it did quite well over here, but I'd need some of the *really* old Forum Farts to confirm this. My memory's not quite what it used to be ...

Posted on: 04 December 2001 by P
I never could figure out what that song was supposed to be about.

I mean I was around 16 at the time and all I could think of was SEX! If wasn't about that then just well what the hell was it about?

Certainly not about scoffing a bowl of Birds Angel Delight I reckon.

Hmmmmmmmm

Instant Whip anyone?

P.

[This message was edited by P on TUESDAY 04 December 2001 at 22:56.]

Posted on: 04 December 2001 by matthewr
Tanya Headon shared your confusion: "When I was a kid, I didn't need to be told that "Hotel California" was about something epically dreadful, even if I thought it the hotel was supposed to be haunted by actual Universal Classic-style monsters. By contrast, the Starland Vocal Band's country-lite vision of sex was so antiseptic that for the longest time, I thought "Afternoon Delight" referred to nothing more naughty than a dessert made with Jell-O and Cool Whip whipped topping."

Matthew

Posted on: 04 December 2001 by P
Forgive my ignorance but who the hell is she?

Any relation to Topper?

P.

Posted on: 04 December 2001 by matthewr
Writes a very funny (at least I think its funny) weblog called 'I Hate Music'. Unless you are a prissy, head up your backside indie kid in which Tanya Headon is a hate figure who writes a really silly web column and doesn't understand how wonderful and important music is or has never heard somethign really good like <insert favourite obscure band here>.

See the links a few posts up.

Matthew

As a taster here's Tanya on how to write a Talking Heads song:

1) Pick a subject. This should be something very mundane. The television, perhaps, or animals. Hey! We'll pick computers.

2) Write about your topic in a simple style. Say nothing that is not obvious. How about - You can type on computers. Your words appear on screen.

3) HERE IS THE IMPORTANT PART. You now have to turn your kindergarten words into a penetrating reflection of the strangeness of modern life. You do this by singing them in a bug-eyed neurotic voice.

3A) If you don't make the delivery sufficiently nutty you'll have written a Kraftwerk song instead. And that would never do.

4) Embellish your initial lyrics, if you like, with extra ones of even more staggering obviousness. So your song on computers might now run: "You can type! / On computers. / THEY DON'T TYPE BACK! / Your words show up on the screen / People say the screen is black."

5) Play weedy approximation of funk/African/Brazilian music behind devastatingly insightful words.

6) Approach bank. Laugh.

David Byrne applied this technique time and again. He considered cities: each had good points and bad points. What of animals? "They say animals are hairy". Finally his observations reached a stunning peak: on "Once In A Lifetime" (named for how often anyone needs to hear it), he told the world that "There is water at the bottom of the ocean". In other words, David Byrne made Jonathan Richman look like Hegel.

Posted on: 12 December 2001 by Chris Metcalfe
No-one's mentioned the topical creator of 'Una Paloma Blanca' and 'Leap Up and Down and wave' etc etc. Certainly worth a custodial sentence.
Posted on: 12 December 2001 by Former member
Sounds like she's spot on for Talking Heads. Are the rest of her comments equally insightful?

steve

Posted on: 13 December 2001 by Mike Sae
On Tricky's Maxinquaye:

quote:
it also has a second half that takes the dirge out of dirigible and then deflates it

LOL!!!! Brilliant!

P.S. I loved that record.

Posted on: 13 December 2001 by matthewr
>> Are the rest of her comments equally insightful? <<

Absolutely -- She's just given Roger Waters a right old slagging.

Matthew

Posted on: 13 December 2001 by Markus
My nominee for worst song would be anything by Neil Diamond. His overblown, overly-dramatic, plasticky emotion and tackiness are too much for me. Perhaps only tied by Barry Manilow.