Downsizing continued - Mana & PSUs

Posted by: Alex S. on 11 September 2001

I have been experimenting with Supercap, Hi-Cap and Mana, Base combinations.

Tests were carried out on shelf 2 of a 6 tier standard Base rack and on 2 phases of Mana: Soundframe/Mana Board/Soundframe/Damped Mana Glass (on concrete floor). Other combinations may bring different results but here's what I found. The words I use to describe my impressions are used in relative not absolute terms - so a Matsui might sound more 'glassy' and a NAP500 more 'weighty'.

1. Hi-Cap on Base.

Dull, lifeless, uninspired - felt like getting up and making a cup of coffee.

2. Hi-Cap on Mana.

Detailed, exciting, fun, uncouth, showy.

3. Supercap on Base.

Weighty, authoritative, musical, coherent, transparent.

4. Supercap on Mana.

Glassy, aggressive, fatiguing, disjointed.

In order of preference I would rate them: 3 then 2 with 1 and 4 equal and opposite lasts. 1 would be more livable with, 4 more immediately impressive.

Conclusions

Mana works wonders for some Naim kit eg. 32.5, Hi-Cap, and buggers up the sound of others, eg. CDS2, Supercap (note the expensive stuff). Mana does seem to add something - this can be good news or bad news depending on the equipment.

Base is neutral and provides good isolation. Despite its poor reputation here I would much rather my S-Cap and CDS2 stayed on the Base rack - its seems not to add anything, nor take anything away.

I find it interesting that the Mana seems to elevate 'lesser' equipment - its protagonists make extravagant but probably correct claims in this regard. Expensive kit which is presumably better engineered and isolated seems to reject any further enhancement and just recquires a solid, level, isolating surface.

Alex

Disclaimer: my system, my setup, my room, my ears, my brain.

ps The combined power and musicality of the CDS2 head unit on Base and the CDPS on Mana really nails you to your seat.

Posted on: 13 September 2001 by David Dever
quote:
Base has gone up horribly in price since the release of FRAIM. Coincidence?

Not really--the BASE shelves (esp. the StarBASE range) require similar manufacturing techniques (perhaps more to get the black satin enamel right, witness the quality of early BASE rack shelves...), and economy of scale figures in greatly.

I'm not even sure that Audiophile Furniture has ever put up a website, to be honest.

Dave Dever, NANA

Posted on: 13 September 2001 by Alex S.
A few months ago Standard Base went up in price by about 20%. I call 20% in one shot a horrible price rise.

Alex.