'Lotus' - Santana

Posted by: Peter Stockwell on 13 February 2002

This was a triple LP set was released in 1974, originally as a Japanese Sony release. I have an early CD of this. It was just about Santana's best band ever, corrsponding with his best two albums ever (IMNHO) - Caravanserai, Welcome (OK, so Welcome is flawed) and the record with John McLaughlin.

I've had a look around and the triple set is available on the web from US$10 for a UK set, up to $50 for a japanese original, that of course is the one I really want. Does anybody have any experience of Dutch, German or US pressings of this. I hesitate to spend $50, because while it represents Santana's best period, it also contains some self indulgent crap.

If anybody knows of a well mastered CD version I'd be interested to explore that too.

Peter

Posted on: 14 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
Nick,

Mine is the same as yours, methinks. I bought it about 10 years ago. 'Lotus' was unavailable on CD for a long time. I'll be into my CD store today, maybe, I'll have a look over the santana bins, maybe there's a newer master.

Generally, the earliest CD versions were released with 'perfect (crap) sound' forever in mind, so they EQed out any tape noise, and a load of music with it. FWIW, the most recent columbia legacy reissue of Abraxas has acres of tape hiss, but sounds really engaging and alive. It's still inferior to a mid 80s dutch vinyl pressing I have tho', but it get's the musical message across.

Was it you asking about jazz ? If it was, then go to 'Incident at Neshabur' on disc 2 of Lotus, and wait for the quote from 'My Favourite things', this is not there because Carlos had a secret longing for Julie Andrews, maybe it was come to think of it wink . Carlos does about 2 minutes of his version of Coltrane's 'My Favourite things'. 'Se a Cabo' is also hot on this disc.

Lotus would have been a tremendous statement about that Santana band, and in a way, it's best on CD because you can program out the crap between the really good stuff. I think if it'd be released as a double set with 15mins a side ...

Peter

Posted on: 16 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
Nick,

Try 'Giant Steps', or 'Crescent'. Crescent is very earthy.

Peter

Posted on: 19 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
from these guys. They are in Holland, which is in the €zone, but their prices are in US$ thanks to Gemm.

Playland Records

Peter

Posted on: 20 February 2002 by bdnyc
Peter & co.-

I have an aging Japanese vinyl copy of Lotus, so I can't comment on the CD's. It is music worth seeking out. It was somewhat legendary for many years as "his great missing live album."

It certainly exhibits that 70's expansiveness that some may find self indulgent. As I am a fan of many of the long winded performers from that era, such as Santana's fellow Californian's The Dead and The Airplane, Clapton's Live material as captured on the Crossroads Volume 2 box set, and many of the bands that tried to combine jazz and rock, from Miles Davis, King Crimson, John McLaughlin, etc, I am certainly biased.

What I think sets Lotus apart, certainly from his more overtly commercial live album from that era, "Moonflower", is both the quality of his band, as well as how much of the material that they played was still fresh. If your tastes don't run as far towards fusion jazz as to rock, Moonflower may be a better choice. From that era, of his studio records I also like Santana's "Borboletta", which is more in the jazz rock feel, and his "Amigos", which is closer to rock, but does include his exquistite instrumental "Europa", which is also featured on the more commercial live recording taken from the late 70's, "Moonflower".

He is always a good performer to see live if you get the chance. I have not seen it yet, but there seems to be a DVD of a "Supernatural" era show.

Enjoy.

Posted on: 21 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
quote:
Originally posted by bdnyc:

It certainly exhibits that 70's expansiveness that some may find self indulgent....and many of the bands that tried to combine jazz and rock, from Miles Davis, King Crimson, John McLaughlin, etc, I am certainly biased.

What I think sets Lotus apart, certainly from his more overtly commercial live album from that era, "Moonflower", is both the quality of his band, as well as how much of the material that they played was still fresh. If your tastes don't run as far towards fusion jazz as to rock, Moonflower may be a better choice. From that era, of his studio records I also like Santana's "Borboletta", which is more in the jazz rock feel, and his "Amigos", which is closer to rock, but does include his exquistite instrumental "Europa", which is also featured on the more commercial live recording taken from the late 70's, "Moonflower".

He is always a good performer to see live if you get the chance. I have not seen it yet, but there seems to be a DVD of a "Supernatural" era show.

Enjoy.


Nice analysis. I tend to think of Carlos as a one solo guitar player, but what feeling!, talking of one note players what about Neil Young, but I really like what they do. I was a very passionate fan of Santana until Borboletta, which is a disc that I haven't listened to in decades. For me, that's when santana went wrong. Since then there has been a few discs that I enjoyed, Havana Moon, Shango, Blues for Salvador. I haven't heard supernatural on anything that ressembles a decent system, and when I heard it on a low fi system the music couldn't cut through.

Recently, I saw Carlos with Rob Thomas at an Imax theatre. Now that did get me enthusiastic, but not enough to go buy the record. I saw Carlos in 1990, and thought he was still pretty good live. I'd go again, but here in France you have to take a gas mask to most rock concert people smoke so much it's unbearable. If some one would give me a copy I'll listen to Borboletta again
big grin

Peter

Posted on: 21 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
quote:
Originally posted by Nick Lees:

It wasn't helped by the fact that shazbut had just previously introduced me to the "Live At The Fillmore '68" set, which blew me away (alright, there's a bit too much bongoing on disc two, but the rest more than makes up for it!)

wassat?

Peter

Posted on: 21 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
Thanks Nick,

On an unrelated note, I went looking for CDs at the nearest CD emporium this lunch time, I tried a quick listen to some of the Indie Stuff, like 'Lotus Eaters', I almost liked that, but I was pressed for time so didn't buy.

I came a way with the latest from Chuck E. Weiss's (the one that Rickie lee Jones sang about) latest album "Old Souls & Wolf Tickets", the blurb claims it's a tew of "Beefheart,Tom Waits & Taj Mahal" and a Jazz CD by a guy Bill Carrothers "The Electric Bill", I bought that one becaue it seemed like the drummer liked to bang the kit hard. I like jazz like that big grin .

Peter

Posted on: 22 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
Looks like like there's a slumbering secret Carlos Santana appreciation society out there. I have to agree that Carlos does have a tone that can make you want to cry sometimes. The more I listen to jazz and especially Coltrane, the more I hear those jazz influences in his earlier, most creative, work.

My Favourite Albums are:

Caravanserai, this is his best ever studio effort,
and the Lotus set, which sadly contains some fluff but the best stuff is magic.

Peter

Posted on: 23 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
That's where I am now with the 2nd disc of the the 3LP set, I'd forgotten how good the music, at it's best, is on the record. I have to say that I don't regret the US$20 that I paid for the dutch pressing I'm listening to. The austrian made CD is bright and brittle in comparison and doesn't transmit the energy of the concert so well.

Happy Camper!

Peter

Posted on: 23 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
quote:
Originally posted by Mr Tibbs.:
Peter,
The first time I played 'Lotus', my gear was as follows:

LP12 / Grace / Supex 900 super - Still got the thing, but it's out on long term loan to my best mate.


Wanted one of them, but I had a Thorens TD165 then.

quote:
Meridian 101 pre-amp - A great little box of tricks, very musical and light footed.

Had one of them once, worked a treat!

quote:
Michaelson and Austen TVA 1 Power amp - 40W Valve powerhouse - the extra lashings of second order distortion inherent in valve amplification was just perfect for adding extra atmosphere to the proceedings. Carlos himself would have approved.

I thoght that Pushpulls cancelled even order harmonics ?

quote:
Gale 401's - The ultimate speaker for doing justice to live Santana? - Very probably!

Black Magic Woman.. Let it rip..

Mr Tibbs

Bold FT - Nice one.

Re. Incident - Something weird and hair-raising happens halfway through, as if Carlos says lets just slow this down a bit boys. Do I remember correctly?



I agree about BFT, I stopped at side three yesterday, I have to say it's way better than I remember it from the 70s, but I have taken on Michael Shrieves drum solo yet :-)

Peter

Posted on: 26 February 2002 by Tim Williams
quote:
Originally posted by Peter Stockwell:

If anybody knows of a well mastered CD version I'd be interested to explore that too.

Peter


I have a Japanese CD remaster. Probably about 8 years old - It's a facsimile of the original vinyl edition (Fold out sleeve, inserts etc.). It sounds great to my ears. I'm at work at the moment, so I don't have it to hand. I can dig out some more details if anyone's remotely interested...

Posted on: 26 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
Hi Tim,

I'm quite surprised this thread is staying alive. I finally cracked for the LP version I found a Dutch pressing for $20. The japanese remaster could be interesting, but over here in France seems as if only the austrian CD from 1992 is available.

welcome to the Forum.

Peter

Posted on: 28 February 2002 by Peter Stockwell
quote:
Originally posted by Mr Tibbs.:

Maybe I'll get the hell out of here now, before I end up making a further fool of myself romanticising over Carlos's use of sustain and feedback…


It's OK, you're allowed. I have a few recent Hooker albums, notably the one with Van Morrison, "Dimples" I think they called it. I have decided to let "The Healer" go, because I was given the compilation "Friends" which satisfies me more, I can't remember if there is one of the other Carlos cuts on it, but there's some good stuff with Cooder .... Ah now there's another secret pleasure, hands up those that love his "Paradise and Lunch", "Into the Purple Valley", etc. period. I love his version of Jim Reeves' "He'll have to go".

Peter