Best pizza on the planet

Posted by: Dan M on 22 October 2003

Following the burger discussion in the supper thread, I'd like to hear suggestions for best pizza. For me it has to be deep dish Chicago style. And it's a two-way tie:

Other's to consider?

cheers

Dan

p.s. sweet corn does not belong on a pizza, ever.
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by Dave J
Unfortunately we'll never get to find out Frown
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by Dan M
Ludwig - sorry, don't think so - this issue is just too big. Wink

Dave - let me know how well those pizzas travel.

re. location/pizza. Some of the most memorable pizzas I've had have been at Miguels in the Red River Gorge, KY. After a hard days climbing, hanging out with other climbers and eating one of Miguels pizza's, topped with whatever he had growing in the garden, and an Ale 81 (local ginger ale). I'll never forget the German climber who was across the table pulling out a bunch of garlic after the meal and eating cloves whole as desert. There's something very satisfying about a good meal and company when you're physcically and mentally exhausted.

Dan
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by Rasher
OK…..at this point I need to retract my statement that US pizzas are all too much yucky dough. You have convinced me that my experience is unrepresentative and I should come out to NY & Chicago (never been) to put things right. It wouldn’t normally matter, but this is too important to remain unchecked. I am obviously wrong. Please forgive me. Frown I will be needing recommendations though.

Strangely, the PE Fiorentina is my fave, even though I am a great believer in, as Ludwig says, too many toppings are a mistake and kill the pizza. It may sound gross Ludwig – but you’ll just have to come here and have one. I’ll buy. There isn’t much on it, just a smattering of spinach. It’s not piled up.

Al Duomo in Brighton has just re-opened after a major refurb, and it is twice the size, modern and a great place to eat. I was there a couple of weeks ago (I had pasta).
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by ErikL
Rasher, we'll have to do a Pizza Swap (but leave the egg out unless you like vomit). Wink
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by Rasher
quote:
Originally posted by Ludwig:
Rasher, we'll have to do a Pizza Swap (but leave the egg out unless you like vomit). Wink


OK...so we are now moving towards favorite toppings. Eek Not a fan of carrots on pizza
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by BigH47
Rasher
Good news about Al Duomo. Sounds like a good excuse to go down and try out the new ambiance.

Howard

No olives or anchovies on mine please
Posted on: 24 October 2003 by maxwellspeed
Here in Seattle they are few and far between. As Ludwig mentioned, Piecoras is one of the better places. It's only 3-4 blocks from me which is nice after a backpack in the mountains on the weekend. Good tap beer by the pitcher too. Another joint, though hidden in Georgetown, which is the 'up and coming' hipsterish neighborhood in south Seattle and near Boeing Field, is a place called Stellar's. But it is very hit or miss on the slices. The best is just their cheese or pepporoni. Sounds simple, but to me that is the litmus test of a good pizza place. Lots of places can throw on 'exotic' ingredients and give them names worthy of the Louvre, but can they master the ancient art of Cheese or Pepperoni slice! With these 2, there are no artichoke hearts, gorgonzola, pesto, brocoli, etc to hide your sauce and crust behind. This is what made New York and Boston pizza the best I have ever had. Their plain 'old cheese slices and pepperoni slices were honed to perfection. They got the basics down first, great sauce, thin crust, before they started throwing on the farmers entire harvest.

(wow. it's 11:30 here on the west coast and boy am I getting hungry...

almost forgot: ESCAPE FROM NEW YORK PIZZA in Portland, Or. is THE BEST I have had since New York-Boston. Need to drive down there soon.
Posted on: 04 November 2003 by Steve Toy
Frankie and Benny's. The pizza here is excellent - thin and tasty base, yummy sauce and not too much cheese. Nice and light.

They shouldn't have ham and pineapple on the menu though - it's not a classic, it's a travesty.



Regards,

Steve.
Posted on: 04 November 2003 by Onthlam
Rasher:

Please tell me where you live...I am sending you some Chicago Pizza..
If you are in England or the U.K. this might be tough to do....

Marc
Posted on: 04 November 2003 by Rasher
Marc - You in Chicago? Check your PT's.
Posted on: 04 November 2003 by Onthlam
Rasher:

Spoke to the fine folks at Lou Malnattis. They have a thing that they will send pizza anywhere in the country. I called and asked if they could send it to England...NO..Can not send a food product across borders. Bastards!!

The next time your in Chicago or Ca., you let me know.
I'm sure there are others within this forum who live in Chicago who would love to show it off.

Pizza in Chi...
Genos East
unos
Chicago Pizza factory(Ok pizza/different). Which happens to be directly across the street from where the St. Valentines day murders to place. And for your listening pleasure, 2 blocks from Pro Musica.
Lou Malnattis

Wish I could have done this for you. It would have been a kick to hear your response.....

Marc
Posted on: 04 November 2003 by Not For Me
The most memorable pizza I have ever had was the Christmas Dinner pizza from Safeway.

It had Turkey (natch), bacon, sausage, cranberry, stuffing, carrots, potatoes, peas, sprouts, if fact everything ou would expect apart from Christmas pudding and mince pies.

It tasted unbelievably bad.

As said, too much topping often = bad pizza.

DS
Posted on: 05 November 2003 by Rasher
Marc - Well that was the most memorable pizza I never had. Great idea though and I am touched by your efforts.
I will be getting myself over there soon - probably Chicago just before Chistmas, and I will check out your recommendations. If you could join us, I'll buy you a pizza.
Posted on: 05 November 2003 by Onthlam
Rasher:
Being in Ca. in Dec. is a wee bit more to my likeing these days...December/Chicago=dress warm.Real warm!
If you are out here some time we can kick it and get some sent to us....Not a problem..

Just let me know......

Regards,

Marc
Posted on: 05 November 2003 by Dan M
Marc,

Nice offer - let's hope Rasher will see the light and become a deep dish convert! If you're wintering over in N.Cal be sure to visit Zachary's in Berkeley.

cheers,

Dan
Posted on: 05 November 2003 by Rasher
No way I'll become a deep pizza convert. Thin & crispy for me please guys Razz
Posted on: 05 November 2003 by Onthlam
Rasher:
When you get to Chicago head to UNOS. Its on Ontario or Ohio St. The Best Thin and crisp your likely to have anywhere........

D Marsh:
I Live north of Sac...I see the sierra range out my back windows...
Zachary's it is then!!

Regards to all,

Marc
Posted on: 06 November 2003 by Steve Toy
Menilmontant,

As I said, Frankie and Benny's - the best this side of Rome, imho.



Regards,

Steve.
Posted on: 18 April 2004 by ErikL
Dan M:

I'm exposing you for secretly sharing with me that you liked the thin-crust pizzas in Brazil! Razz

However, in maintaining your bad taste you did state that you liked them topped with hearts of palm. I bet you also loved them topped with hardboiled eggs, huh? Roll Eyes
Posted on: 18 April 2004 by ErikL
Sir Alex:

I'm a dedicated thin cruster. It's Mr. M who expressed his love for gooey thick messes throughout this thread, but recently told me that he woofed down a thin-crust pie within the past few weeks in a moment of weakness and rather enjoyed it.

Perhaps he's converted; I don't know. What I do know is he's a sneaky little pie muncher and this riddle must be solved... Wink
Posted on: 18 April 2004 by Dan M
Ludwig,
Egg?!! You've got confused with Alex. From page 1:
AG:I am a fan of the egg on pizza. Eek
Deep dish still holds the title of best pizza, but I must admit to enjoying that Brazillian thin crust. I'd like to know if Rasher tried Gino's or if Marc got to Zachs. One by one we will convert the world...

Dan
Posted on: 19 April 2004 by Madrid
Dear Sirs,

Italy aside, the world´s best pizza can be found at Sallys in New Haven, Connecticut, USA.

Unfortunately, there is little reason to visit New Haven, except for a small university there.

Cheers,

Steven
Posted on: 19 April 2004 by Berlin Fritz
After good quality Mexican, African, or Thai weed, every Pizza on earth tastes as wonderful as you wish it to taste, it's as simple as that, obvious, innit Tom ?

Fritz Von Fitnessregimestartstoday Big Grin
Posted on: 19 April 2004 by Berlin Fritz
I did experience the chigaco pizza pie factory in hannover square when it first opened many moons ago, that was good, my girl paid too, even better.

Fritz Von Tighterthanaswindonpensioner
Posted on: 21 April 2004 by Tim Danaher
Anyone already put in a word for Eco in Brixton Market? Always packed, and only open from 12:00-5:00pm. Also, Pangaea further up on Atlantic Road under the railway arches does some great Pizza. Both do proper Italian, thin-crust. I think Pangaea is 'forno a la legna' as well.

Cheers,

Tim
_____________________________

Os nid Campagnolo yw hi, dyw hi ddim yn werth ei marcho...