Charlotte Gainsbourg - 5:55
Posted by: Rasher on 10 October 2006
I can't decide whether she's good or whether there's nothing in there of substance. Sounds pretty, but is that enough? Any views?
Posted on: 10 October 2006 by SteveGa
quote:Charlotte Gainsbourg - 5:55
It got "interesting" reviews - like this one
What stops 5:55 being a well-meaning pastiche, what makes the album touching rather ghoulish, is the sheer quality of the songwriting. Charlotte Gainsbourg is, it seems, a difficult customer in front of the microphone - she apparently overcame her shyness by singing while hidden under a sheet - but her reticence seems to have forced everyone else involved to the top of their game. Exquisite melodies and heart-stopping choruses abound: there's a particularly thrilling example of the latter on the breathless Everything I Cannot See. As lyricists, Cocker and Hannon are on rare form as anyone who's heard the former's remarkable download single Running the World and A Lady of a Certain Age, the tear-jerking centrepiece of the recent Divine Comedy album, will attest. Accordingly, the best lyrics here are fascinating. The Operation pitches its medical metaphor just right: "Our love goes under the knife/ The heart was rejected by the host." AF607105 examines the ineffable melancholy of air travel, hardly a topic regularly touched on in rock.
It's a genuinely delightful album, but also a puzzling one. Given her discomfort in the studio and reticence regarding her father - she refuses to discuss him in public "for my own sake" - you have to wonder why on earth Charlotte Gainsbourg made the album. An acclaimed and successful actress, she hardly needs a new career. There is no talk of a follow-up. The reason for 5:55's existence remains a mystery, but it's hard not to feel glad it exists.
It's on my wish list still - waiting for a better price!
Seems to be very much in a French tradition. Anyone who is interested can find songs at My Space I actually preferred Guy Chambers/Sophie Hunter "Isis Project" (have a look here). Same kind of singing style though.
Steve
Posted on: 10 October 2006 by hungryhalibut
This is one of those records that you can cast aside as shallow on first listening. Repeated exposure shows far greater depths.
I like it.
Nigel
I like it.
Nigel
Posted on: 12 October 2006 by Richard Dane
quote:Originally posted by SteveGa:
...As lyricists, Cocker and Hannon are on rare form as anyone who's heard the former's remarkable download single Running the World and A Lady of a Certain Age, the tear-jerking centrepiece of the recent Divine Comedy album, will attest... Steve
I heard Divine Comedy's A Lady of a Certain Age on a recent Word cover disc. As you say, wonderful lyrics and I now have this down on my "must buy" list.