Standing In The Shadows Of Motown

Posted by: Mike Hughes on 03 February 2004

What prompts me to write this is the separate thread on outstanding drummers. I won't bore you with my views as a drummer or music fan but I will say the following simply because no-one else has and it would be a tragedy if this passes you by:

1) If you are a music fan of any description
then you simply have to see this film. It
tells the story of The Funk Brothers.
Essentially, approximately thirteen musicians
who, in various combinations, played on
everything Motown produced between '58
and '71. It is important, funny and moving
and seems likely to remain the only film I
have seen in a cinema that received a
standing ovation at the end. It's out on DVD
and even the extras are superb. The
soundtrack ain't bad either!!!

2) The last six of The Funk Brothers are
currently touring the world with backing from
a variety of excellent musicians and are
being fronted by some equally excellent
vocalists. Two and a quarter hours of
awesome, life-affirming music. Eddie Willis
is the youngest at 68 and is placed in a
wheelchair as soon as he comes off stage. As
the film says "they played on more no1.
records than The Beatles, The Stones, Elvis
and The Beach Boys combined, which makes
them the greatest hit making machine of all
time.". They are also wonderful, wonderful
musicians and characters to a man. Not many
of you will have the chance to see them but
if you do then please take the chance. You
won't see their like again.

3) If you can stop the tears from welling in
your eyes at the moment the drums start on
"Reach Out, I'll Be There" or the key change
in "Ain't No Mountain High Enough" then
you're a better person than I.

Anyway, enough gushing. Just see the film and pray they gig near you.
Posted on: 10 February 2004 by ErikL
FWIW the Funk Brothers were honored last night at the Grammy Awards for lifetime achievement.

I'd now like to see the film.

(If you like this sort of thing, you might also enjoy the documentary on the Chi-Lites, Isaac Hayes, and a few other legends- "Only The Strong Survive")
Posted on: 10 February 2004 by Sir Crispin Cupcake
You can get the special 2 disk edition of this on CDWOW for the princely sum of £9.99 inc postage. I've just ordered it.
Posted on: 11 February 2004 by Mike Hughes
Ludwig,

They announced the Grammy at the Manchester gig.

I have seen Only The Strong Survive (finally) on BBC4s classic soul weekend. Good but also embarassing in places. Doesn't touch Standing In The Shadows IMHO.

Mike

PS:Richard - are you referring to OTSS or SITSOM on DVD? The DVD
of the latter has exactly the same extras whether on Euro
single DVD or American double DVD.
Posted on: 11 February 2004 by JohanR
Agree on everything, except maybe:

quote:
3) If you can stop the tears from welling in your eyes at the moment the drums start on "Reach Out, I'll Be There" or the key change in "Ain't No Mountain High Enough" then
you're a better person than I.


Actually, it's the bass playing here (James Jamerson style) that moves me.

There is an interesting part where James Jamerson's son (who is a bass player to) confesses that he for most part of his life didn't know that it was his father that invented the modern style of bass playing! They where that unknown to the public.

JohanR
Posted on: 12 February 2004 by Mike Hughes
JohanR,

Glad someone else in the world has seen the film.

I'll sort of concede your point. Whichever aspect of those intros. produces the tingle down the spine or the lump in the throat the fact remains that they do so - every time. Jamerson was simply awe inspiring (a look at the baselines in the book that long preceded the film tells it's own story. Entirely familiar songs where every bar of the baseline is different.) The bit in the film where his son showed the differences in how his Dad played was very enlightening too.

What sums up their tragic obscurity for me was the start of the film in the Detroit record shop when they asked the punters who played the music on the records and got such great answers as "The Pips"!!!

Nuff said.
Posted on: 17 February 2004 by Sir Crispin Cupcake
PS:Richard - are you referring to OTSS or SITSOM on DVD? The DVD
of the latter has exactly the same extras whether on Euro
single DVD or American double DVD.

Sorry Mike - took a while to see your reply. I'm talking about the SITSOM DVD. Should arrive soon CDWOW were temporarily out of stock.

Rich