Ive made the HARD CHOICE

Posted by: naimless! on 06 November 2001

Thanks all for advice past couple of weeks...I have taken the plunge and traded in my cd3,nait and kef q55 speakers for....brand a new CDX! 102! and 180! Pre and Power...still running in at the moment with a pair of split new B& W 603 series 3( circa £600? ) which I have borrowed from my dealer for a demo. System is getting better and better with each listen but I really dont know what speakers to go for with a budget of around £1200? I also dont like the support feet of the cdx as it slides all over the place and I really dont want to use a stand? SO FAR I AM IN ABSOLUTE HEAVEN....Cant wait for my XPS!!!! thanks PEDRO
Posted on: 06 November 2001 by Mike Sae
quote:
speakers to go for with a budget of around £1200?

what has your dealer recommended? Have a listen to Naim, Royd, Neat, Rega, Epos- The speakers from these companies in your price band all all excellent, just different. Should be something there you'll like.

quote:
I also dont like the support feet of the cdx as it slides all over the place and I really dont want to use a stand?

What are you doing now that make the CDX slide around? Those metal feet are part of its design, so it best to leave them alone.
However some here may recommend Nordost Pulsar Points.

Good luck and enjoy!

If you're anything like me, I suspect you'll be burning your credit card right now...
Don't forget to let us know how you get on with speakers.

[This message was edited by Mike Sae on TUESDAY 06 November 2001 at 15:21.]

Posted on: 06 November 2001 by Steve Toy
I have heard the new 602.5 S3s and I'm not at all impressed with them. The timing is so disjointed as to divert my attention onto the pattern on the walls...., they can't play the tune propely, and the bass is the one-note, wet-fish-slapped-on-the-table variety.
All in all, I can't fault these speakers because they do nothing wrong. wink
Try Rega Naos, JM Lab 816s, or Credos - all these speakers will play you the tune, and give you the PR&T that your system deserves.
You need a decent rack, BTW - it'll make as big a difference as that XPS you are after.

It's always a nice day for it wink Have a good one! smile
Steve.
It's good to get back to normal. wink

[This message was edited by Steven Toy on TUESDAY 06 November 2001 at 15:53.]

Posted on: 06 November 2001 by naimless!
new Credos? no bass! really I wasn't impressed! Epos sounded old fashioned, very dull? alleas...due shortly but too expensive? Royd/JM lab mmm? thanx! I need to audition...my cdx sits on a solid bookcase next to my amps. Perhaps I could lay a sheet of polished edge glass over the top of the case? I forgot to mention that i also got the PSC digital supply for the pre-amp which seems to clean everything up.....PR & T steve? thanx Pedro
Posted on: 06 November 2001 by garyi
Ah you must be one of those bass freaks I have heard about if the credos don't have any for you!

I suggest nordest points for the CDX as well, they not only look good but stop all that there movement. Seems to make the sound go deeper as well, but that may be placebo as they cost 50 quid you would want an improvement eh?

Posted on: 06 November 2001 by count.d
Have you heard the Shahinian Compass's?
They give you a taste of what the rest of the Shahinian range do. They have plenty of bass, but it's not the most defined bass.
Overall they did sound very enjoyable.
Posted on: 06 November 2001 by Jez Quigley
The compass is a very fine speaker - listen to it yourself, but if you are a 'bass freak' I don't think it will float your boat.
Posted on: 06 November 2001 by Alex S.
Everyone seems to agree to disagree about speakers but the PMC FB1s should be worth a listen.

Alex

Posted on: 06 November 2001 by Frank Abela
I am surprised at your results with Credos. They're quite a big sounding speaker when placed near the rear wall and square to the listening position (i.e not toed-in).

Another alternative would be the Dynaudio Audience 72 (£1100). Tall floorstander with a lot of presence and big sound.

Regards,
Frank.
All opinions are my own and do not reflect the opinion of any organisations I work for, except where this is stated explicitly.

Posted on: 06 November 2001 by Top Cat
Neat Petite

TC '..'
"Girl, you thought he was a man, but he was a Muffin..."

Posted on: 06 November 2001 by David Quigley
Billsue
--------------------------------------------------
Having listened to them a few times, I have my heart set on some ProAc Response 1s... Even the Tablet series sound excellent IMHO.
--------------------------------------------------

I spent a lot of time last summer listening to every monitor I rated and like you ended up liking the 1SC the best. If you want lots of bass it is not the speaker for you, but it does make music. Only problem, did I hear a rumour that Target have gone bust. If so that could be problematic as the Target stands were a very happy match for the 1SC's. BTW filling stands with sand makes a big difference.

David

Posted on: 07 November 2001 by Scott Mckenzie
If you want a bit more bass and an equally stunning sound, I can highly, highly recommend the Dynaudio Contour Range, either the 1.1, 1.3 or 1.8mkII.

The 1.8's need a big room to work or the bass takes over, the 1.3's are good but the bass driver is apparantly again a bit over powerful - its the same one from the 1.8's but in a much smaller box.

My personal favourites are the 1.1's and with some decent stands (Dynaudio Masterstands should work well enough...) you will be well under your budget. They may look small..but don't be put off by the size they are amazing and drop down low, yet never lose their punchiness.

Scott

Posted on: 07 November 2001 by Steve Toy
When you are ready for it, may I suggest that you get yourself an 82 pre and a Hi-cap?
The difference that this will make to sonic refinement, image focus, and detail retrieval will be simply sublime. smile

It's always a nice day for it wink Have a good one! smile
Steve.
It's good to get back to normal. wink

Posted on: 08 November 2001 by Will_Dias
Naimless,

I have the same electronics as you, excellent chioce, it seems to be the year of the CDX (so many people buying them). This setup has caused much marital angst in our house, as my missus & I fight over who gets to choose the next CD to go on the CDX, but as our musical tastes overlap so much there's rarely any problem. The other week my sister & neices came to stay. The eldest brought a selection of CDs, telling me that she could always hear them at their best at our house.

As for installing glass for the CDX support, it's worth trying (make sure it's strengthened though!), as it's so cheap, and your CDX is currently sitting directly on a solid bookcase - *not* optimal. Place the glass on 4X ball bearings which sit on suitable size nuts ((TM) Vuk). Make sure the CDX is level. I have no space for a dedicated stand in my little shack, so I have cobbled together an MDF support with adjustable spikes that is positioned below the glass (on a fitted shelf), this allows me to level everything and gives extra isolation.

Hope this makes sense,

Will.

Posted on: 08 November 2001 by Chris L
quote:

Only problem, did I hear a rumour that Target have gone bust

Yes, Target have gone bust. But, many of their products are still available, as they had a fair amount of parts stock.

For example, just a few weeks ago got a set of the Target stands that ProAc recommend for my old Super Tablette speakers - hell of an improvement, too!

Also, the Target product range has been bought by an engineering company called Sonus (not Faber!). They're not making all the Target items yet, they are in the process of ramping up production as demand warrants.

I can probably get contact telephone numbers for both the old stock and Sonus if folks are interested.

Chris L

Posted on: 08 November 2001 by Steve Toy
Thes are fine all-rounders indeed.
Their only drawback is that they are a tad insensitive at 87 dB/W/m, so you'll need lots of Wattage power to drive them.

It's always a nice day for it wink Have a good one! smile
Steve.
It's good to get back to normal. wink

Posted on: 21 November 2001 by naimless!
Hi all! again! Naim just seems to be so forward...I need the volume at 9 o'clock just to drive the bass properly...sometimes higher but the mid and treble just pierce me ear drums...okay at weekend when you've had a few beers and fancy a rock-out but really for an engaging listen the system is not giving me what I need. I'm now on B&W 9nt £1800 worth of speaker! and I'm still unhappy! I want that dynamic effect, with solid punch. I get all the clarity I require, but i just can't seem to get serious low end, kidney vibrating, RUMBLE. Surely my Cdx,102,180,PSC should be working wonders by now? ps. does the Pcs power the cdx or the pre-amp as I have it just now? thanx Pedro
Posted on: 21 November 2001 by Scott Mckenzie
I cannot recommend these enough....they have bags of talent and loads of bass...where required obviously.

If you want a floorstander, try the Audience 62, 72 or 82. If you hunt around (Audio Excellence have them) you can even get the older Audience 60 and 70's, which IMHO are almost as good, but cost a whole load less...

If you have more cash to spend try the Contour series, either the 1.3 or 1.8's, both stunning speakers...but as I said my faves are the 1.1's, they look little but sound really big.

I have never been a fan of B&W speakers, so I cannot advocate enough how much you should listen to the Dyn's. You will not be disappointed...

Scott

Posted on: 21 November 2001 by Martin Payne
quote:
Originally posted by naimless!:
Hi all! again! Naim just seems to be so forward...I need the volume at 9 o'clock just to drive the bass properly...sometimes higher but the mid and treble just pierce me ear drums...okay at weekend when you've had a few beers and fancy a rock-out but really for an engaging listen the system is not giving me what I need. I'm now on B&W 9nt £1800 worth of speaker! and I'm still unhappy! I want that dynamic effect, with solid punch. I get all the clarity I require, but i just can't seem to get serious low end, kidney vibrating, RUMBLE. Surely my Cdx,102,180,PSC should be working wonders by now? ps. does the Pcs power the cdx or the pre-amp as I have it just now? thanx Pedro

Do you have just the CDX plugged into the pre-amp? If you've got anything else, unplug the cables from the back of the pre & try it again.


However, back at the top you said

quote:
I also dont like the support feet of the cdx as it slides all over the place and I really dont want to use a stand

and I suspect you'll continue to rant about how bad every speaker is until you recant and do something about this issue, even if it's just a Base01 platform or something under the CDX.

cheers, Martin

Posted on: 21 November 2001 by Matthew T
Pedro,

I am also on the CDX/102/180 combination. When it was initially installed it was harsh, this improved but it takes quite a long time, suggest it want be at it's best until it has been on and in use for 2-3 months, maybe more, the harshness really does diminish. You might also want to look at mains quality, I haven't got a dedicated spur and sometimes the system is really on song (last night) and sometimes seems relatively harsh and dull. Need to get the NAPSC and hicap, maybe XPS too...

Napsc should be plugged into the back of the pre-amp, it powers the digital circuitry.

CDX really is support sensitive, it must be level, get the spirit level out. You may find putting it on glass makes it seem brighter, you could try a seperate isolated layer of mdf instead, this is a cheap upgrade.

I am running BW804, bit over your budget. Think you will find that speakers are something that really does come down to personal preference, so listen to lots.

cheers

Matthew

Posted on: 21 November 2001 by Scott Mckenzie
quote:
Originally posted by tof2001:
Scott,

are there dedicated stands for dynaudio (1.1 or 1.3)?

Jean-Christophe


Yes...and no....

Dynaudio do make their own stands, IIRC, they are called the Masterstands (made by Target), unfortunately the 1.1 is too small for the stand and doesn't sit properly on the top, the 1.3 however sits perfectly..

I have no idea where you could get some from in "Eure-zone" however Audio Excellence in Worcester have a pair...and they may be willing to ship them over...goto www.audio-excellence.co.uk and drop them an e-mail, they will be able to say yes or no to shipping them, but possibly recommend some altermatives.

Scott

Posted on: 25 November 2001 by Eric Barry
Get a hicap. This is a no brainer. Will give loads more bass, detail, control, smoothness.

A 250 might also have a tonal balance more to your liking than the 180.

Speakers also take time to break in--the suspension on the cones loosens and the sound opens up, esp. in the bass. Don't buy any speakers for two months.

Make sure you leave the equipment on all the time. Use the Naim cables. Don't biwire the B&Ws.

--Eric

Posted on: 26 November 2001 by kuba
I don't know better value for many than Canadian Paradigm Reference Series.
Don't know if available in Britain but worth to try.
kuba