Cryogenic revisited
Posted by: Stevea on 06 November 2003
Some time ago I followed a topic that discussed cryogenic treatment of NACA5 (can't find topic now though). I was interested in this after trying an experimentally treated version of my CDP interconnect (silver wire, air dielectric) - which I was not able to buy unfortunately.
The previous thread seemed to contain a lot of opinion but very little, if any, actual experience. When I had the chance to get it done on the back of a bunch of car audio cables I therefore decided to "give it a go". For good measure I had the speaker cables, CDP interconnect and the SNAIC done (total cost NZ$60).
The end result was WOW - so much for so little. To be honest, it actually took about a week from the time I re-installed the cables (had kept the gear on line with temporary cables) for the full benefit to be apparent. When I first put them in the reaction was 'That's not very exciting, maybe sounds a bit scratchy'.
I have promised to take the speaker cable down to the local Naim dealer since he was interested in hearing the results but I can't quite bring myself to take them back out of the system at present.
I have been following various threads on dedicated spurs and plan on doing this since I have very easy access and an electrician for a soon to be brother in law. Based on my experience with the NACA5 etc I now plan on having all the cable and parts for the spurs similarly treated prior to installation.
Just thought I would pass this on in case anyone had been thinking about the subject.
Steve
Posted on: 06 November 2003 by Manu
It would be a free upgrade for us here: just leaving the cable outside for a few days in february. Or does it works in the freezer.

Emmanuel
All opinions are my own, and reflect those of the organisation i work for, even if not stipulated.
Posted on: 06 November 2003 by undertone
Go to this website
Empirical AudioClick on the "Technical Papers" button.
Choose "Direct-Imersion LNO2 Study" and have a good read.
Posted on: 09 November 2003 by Stevea
quote:
Originally posted by undertone:
Go to this website
http://www.empiricalaudio.com
Click on the "Technical Papers" button.
Choose "Direct-Imersion LNO2 Study" and have a good read.
Interesting. Their assessment of the sound of a treated wire would probably agree with what I heard when I fist plugged everything back together (I was not overly happy at that point as you might imagine), however it certainly would not describe things after a few days, or even a few hours. If I were to simply describe the ultimate effect of the cryogenic treatment I would say it made the sound seem pure and effortless.
I have heard/read these ‘don’t do it’ opinions before and I have also read articles more or less completely the opposite to this. This lack of a definitive answer is one of the reasons why I decided to see (or should I say hear) for myself.
I had been pondering doing it when I heard the experimentally treated version of my Slinkylinks interconnects. Being made of .25mm silver wire (4 wires per cable) the untreated ones had the silver characteristic of improvement in high-end detail and clarity and the tightened but reduced bottom end. The treated versions did not lose any high-end quality but did add noticeably more weight lower down without any loss of control. The words that came to me at the time were “more powerful”.
The demo was actually conduced by the cable manufacturer using treated cables he had removed from his own system, so they were well run in. While trying to convince him to sell them we came to a compromise where I could tag my cables (all my cables) on the back of their next experimental batch. In the event, an opportunity came earlier and I took it. The treatment process takes 4 days (not including shipping) and is apparently done in a computer-controlled environment, which gives a very slow temperature descent and a similarly slow rise.
So, on the basis of personal experience, i.e. from actually having had my own cables professionally treated, I would say that the effect was well worth while and I would not hesitate to do it again. As a final note, with NACA5 being so cheap, as some have noted, it would be a relatively inexpensive recovery should an experiment along these lines prove a failure.
Regards
Steve
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by Frank Abela
It's interesting that although Townshend reckons his cables don't need running in, he does reckon that they need a significant settling time of about a week. Perhaps this is due to the cryogenic treatment, which would account for your similar settling in period. This could mean your dealer would have to leave the cables undisturbed for a few days to get the benefit.
Regards,
Frank.
All opinions are my own and do not reflect the opinion of any organisations I work for, except where this is stated explicitly.
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by Mr_Sukebe
I tried a cryogenically treated interconnect cable with my system quite recently. Some interesting results.
For the last six months I've been using a custom made cable built for me by a friend for all of £15. It completely walked all over my old Cobra 2.
So when another chap I knew offered to let me try out a cryogenically treated custom built cable (using bullets and probably some rather tasty wire), I jumped a the chance.
Like the initial poster, I found the treated stuff, more accurate, more natural, cleaner and having better frequency extremes.
The only downside I found was that it lost it's edge on musical notes, so losing some of the vitality, snap and excitement that exists in my system.
I guess it really comes down to personal preference. For me, I wanted the drive and excitement. If however, you're more inclined to maybe classical pieces and a more sedate/natural pace, the cryo method seemed very worthwhile.
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by Stevea
quote:
Originally posted by Mr_Sukebe:
I guess it really comes down to personal preference. For me, I wanted the drive and excitement. If however, you're more inclined to maybe classical pieces and a more sedate/natural pace, the cryo method seemed very worthwhile.
Very much so. But in my case the music seems far more alive now than it ever has.
I have gone from a Cobra (don't know which one - about 1994 vintage) to a silver interconnect to having all the cables between my CDP and speakers cryogenically treated, all in the space of 3 months. At the same time I have introduced a number of vibration control/isolation modifications for my front end and equipment and acquired some concrete paving slabs for my speakers. I have certainly not noticed any drop in musicality but perhaps the improvements from all the other changes have buried any such effect.
Steve
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by garyi
Steve it also works on CDs, store them in a freezer prior to playing, just make sure there is no condensation on them
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by Minky
It actually works on every part of the system, from the CD to the speakers. For this reason I have had my music room converted into a giant lock-up commercial freezer. You have to dress up like a Sherpa before each session (careful with the face and feet - I lost the tip of my nose and three toes to frostbite in the early days) but the results are well worth the trouble. I have my CD collection hanging from a replica killing chain on wee meat hooks.
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by bec143
Minky,
This echos my experience completely. The only thing I can add is a cautionary note- after a heavy session of salsa music, I found that it tooks weeks for the system to adequately cool down again to the point of maximizing the cryogenic effect.
BEC
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by Martin Payne
Hey, there ain't nuthin' colder than a
BEC - "a new form of matter at the coldest temperatures in the universe".
cheers, Martin
E-mail:- MartinPayne (at) Dial.Pipex.com. Put "Naim" in the title.
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by undertone
quote:
Originally posted by Minky:
It actually works on every part of the system, from the CD to the speakers. For this reason I have had my music room converted into a giant lock-up commercial freezer. You have to dress up like a Sherpa before each session (careful with the face and feet - I lost the tip of my nose and three toes to frostbite in the early days) but the results are well worth the trouble. I have my CD collection hanging from a replica killing chain on wee meat hooks.
And your new nick-naim among the girls down at the pub is "ski-doo dick".
Posted on: 10 November 2003 by undertone
quote:
Originally posted by Martin Payne:
Hey, there ain't nuthin' colder than a http://www.colorado.edu/physics/2000/bec/ - "a new form of matter at the coldest temperatures in the universe".
cheers, Martin
E-mail:- MartinPayne (at) Dial.Pipex.com. Put "Naim" in the title.
Bose-Einstein, were they a team? Now that would explain why Bose speakers sound so good.