Best Female singer of all time

Posted by: NB on 06 October 2002

Madonna has just been voted MTV's all time favorite singer, with Kylie voted second and Celine deon voted third.

Is this a fair reflection of the greatest female singers? or how can you compare modern day favorites with the greatest singers of say the sixties or seventies. Is it possible to compare the likes of Janis Joppelin and Joni Mitchell with Britney and whitney?


Regards

NB confused

[This message was edited by NB on SUNDAY 06 October 2002 at 11:25.]
Posted on: 03 November 2002 by NB
Just come accross an old favorite, the best of Barbara Streisand.

Another one of my favorites I had forgotten about!!

Regards


NB

roll eyes
Posted on: 03 November 2002 by Mekon
in no particular order:

Inell Young
Marva Whitney
Marlena Shaw
Nina Simone
Bjork

I love Harriet Wheeler from The Sundays too, but given the later stuff comes nowhere near (IMHO) Reading..., I've dropped her.
Posted on: 03 November 2002 by Ron Toolsie
JWSzuhay Yes I meant most likely to make you cum in your pants. Listen to the last 2 tracks from Bleed your Cedar and keep the Kleenex handy.

Timbo Linda Rondstat has a balance of poise and beauty that may be unparalled. Heart Like a Wheel is her swansong. All readers must have.

Ron
Dum spiro audio
Dum audio vivo


Posted on: 04 November 2002 by NB
I had a listen to the latest CD release by Ms Krall to see what all the fuss was about and why some people had voted for her. I put the CD in my CDX and pressed play and waited in anticipation of something wonderful. However the bass on the CD was so deep and distorting so badly I couldnt listen to it as I didn't want to damage the speakers. I could hear glimpses of some wonderful music but sadly my listening was ruined.

Thinking that the problem may lie with my CD (god forbid) I tried listening to the CD on my crappy pioneer in car CD. Sadly the problem remained but was even worse due to the age of the speakers in my car. I even tried recording the CD onto tape and reducing the bass that way but no joy!!

Has anyone else experienced this problem or was it just a one off?


Regards



NB

eek
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by Timbo
HI NB

I am a great fan of Diana, got all her CDs, don't have any problems with the bass. Yes there is a lot there but it seems to be clean and the music is very clear.

Tim

CDS2/52/SNAXO2-4/S*CAP/2X250/SBLS
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by steved
I've got the "Love Scenes" and latest "live in Paris" CD's.

I can only echo the previous writer's comments:- the bass is very clear and defined, but not in a distortive way. I've just got some new PMC FB1 speakers, renowned for their bass; the first time I played Diana's "all or nothing at all" track on them made my jaw drop.....

STEVE D
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by NB
My Ruark Equinox's do throw out a lot of bass but as you both say it is normally clear and defined and I have never has a problem. The bass that comes from the faithless Cd is so deep it hits you right in the centre of your chest. Playing it at about 10 o clock on my 82 isn't a problem. But sadly on the Diana Krall CD I can't listen to it any at level!!


Regards



NB

frown
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by man2wolf
Have heard very little of Diana Krall but anyone who is a fan MUST check out "The Chieftains" album "Tears of Stone" on RCA Victor. This is a collection of (mainly) traditional songs in collaboration with leading female singers such as Bonnie Raitt, Sinead O'Connor, Natalie Merchant,Mary Chapin-Carpenter, et al.
Krall does an outstanding version of "Danny Boy", though the standout tracks for me are a reworking of Joni Mitchell's own "The Magdalene Laundries" and The Rankins' "Jimmy Mo Mhile Stor". As always Paddy Moloney's arrangements and production are top notch. Anyone else familiar with this album?
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by john rubberneck
Gladis Pugh
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by John3
There was a problem with the gatefold version of the 'look of love' cd which was released in error very distorted an unlistenable. This was raised some time time ago on this site (try a search) and I think also acknowledged on the official website. If you have got this version take it back to the shop.
Posted on: 05 November 2002 by Clive B
Top three:

Julia Fordham
Karen Carpenter
Sandy Denny

Only one of whom is still with us!
Regards, CB
Posted on: 06 November 2002 by NB
Thanks for the explanation, for a moment there I thought my system was at fault!!


Regards


NB

smile
Posted on: 09 November 2002 by Mike Cole
My all time favorite is someone nobody has ever heard of - Sheila Andrews. She has a voice that could melt cold blue steel. The quote from the LP liner says it all:

"It's a voice that recalls moments of Brenda Lee's moaning cry, the bittersweet pain of Sammi Smith, the volatility of Linda Ronstadt and the intense agony of Janis Joplin. But the style is totally Sheila Andrews."

Mike
Posted on: 09 November 2002 by NB
Sorry Mick, not a singer I am familiar with.

Please enlighten us, as to who she is and tell us more about her.


Regards

NB
Posted on: 12 November 2002 by Mike Cole
She is a country singer that I first saw in the late seventies. I was in the Army and stationed in Germany. I actually saw her on a German music show on TV. I rushed out the next day and bought the LP. I only found her second (and final) LP in a used record store several years later. I never heard anything about her ever again.
Posted on: 18 November 2002 by onlythat
It really comes down to Maria Callas vs. Britney Spears. I mean, both possess incredible vocal talent and it's all personal taste from there on in (in this post-modernist environment, anyway, where The MTV music awards are held at the Met and P. Diddy calls himself the Mozart of the 90's), right?

Sort of like Pavarotti or Jussi Bjorling vs. Justin Timberlake. Again, all have once-in-a-generation talent so, I mean, it's really close-- tough to say. Again, personal preference.

That's why I like this forum-- there's room for everyone.
Posted on: 18 November 2002 by davidf
Just to add one: Natalie Merchant
Her work in 10,000 Maniacs plus her solo efforts show how unique she really is. May not be at the top of the list,but I thought she should be mentioned. Otherwise, Ella, Billie have to be on or near the top. david
Posted on: 19 November 2002 by quincy
Little Jimmy Scott ... he fooled them all!!

AQD
Posted on: 19 November 2002 by NB
One of the best backing singers i have heard is olleta Adams for her backing vocals for Tears for Fears.

Then her solo album and "get there" was fantastic, a voice as sweet as angels!!


Regards

NB

wink
Posted on: 19 November 2002 by Eddie Pugh
Any votes for
Lori Lieberman
Gretchen Peters
Nanci Griffith,
Jennifer Warnes

Surely its all a matter of the mood you are in etc

Eddie
Posted on: 23 November 2002 by ClaudeP
[QUOTE]Originally posted by GrahamP:
"Lara Fabien has to be the greatest"

Actually Graham she's called Lara Fabian, nor Fabien. I don't personally like her (she forces her voice too much for my taste) but sh's got thousands of dedicated fans around, and they can't all be wrong...
Posted on: 28 November 2002 by Madrid
In the jazz category, check out Dee Dee Bridgewater. The poise and control of a Naim preamp with the power of a Krell amp. Possibly the heir to Ella and Sarah in the pantheon of women jazz vocalists (to paraphrase Downbeat). Willing to take risks, on the recent "This is New", where she takes on Kurt Weil.
Posted on: 04 December 2002 by raymond
Mine, is Janet Baker singing in french. Superb.
Regards
Raymond.
Posted on: 21 December 2002 by NB
Any votes for the blonde one from Abba??

Their song "Dancing Queen" has just been voted the best "floorfiller" by the VH1 viewers!

My partner would vote for her being the most tallented female vocalist to come out of sweeden.

Regards



NB
smile
Posted on: 21 December 2002 by seagull
Well, I'd give her one wink