Talk Talk -The Colour of Spring and Spirit of Eden 180g Vinyl

Posted by: badlyread on 23 July 2012

Hi All

 

The above is available and comes with a DVD (96kHz / 24 bit LPCM stereo mix). What is the quality of this DVD recording? Will I be able to transfer it to the Mac Mini in ALAC? I prefer the original CDs to the recent remasters (just LOUDER and a little clipping I believe), so will the DVD enhance my listening pleasure? The vinyl is from the original analogue masters.


Many thanks


Neil

Posted on: 23 July 2012 by Gale 401

Unless  DVDs are Bluray and you can rip the HiRes from them?

Stay with the original CDs.

Stu.

Posted on: 23 July 2012 by King Size

Even though I have the original UK pressing on LP, the original UK pressing on CD and the SACD of "Spirit of Eden" - same for "The Colour of Spring" except for the SACD - I eventually crumbled and bought the new pressing on a whim.  The main reason for doing so was that I plan to move to a streaming set up at some stage and am starting to build a hi res library.

 

The sticker on the cover mentions the hi res audio transfers of the original album masters but it's only when you read the fine print inside that you are told

 

Although the audio on this DVD has been transferred from the original analogue stereo masters at 96khz/24bit, the audio used to create the final mixes was bounced down from analogue 2" 24 track to a Mitsubish Pro Digi 32 track digital recorder which only recorded at a sampling rate of 44.1khz or 48khz.  Where high resolution audio would normally have content up to 40khz plus, the use of the Mitsubishi, with a sampling rate of 44.1khz means there is no content available above 22khz on the original digital recordings and therefore all mixes / copies that followed would also be lacking in content above 22khz.  


No mention of the original bit depth is made.  

 

Both LP and DVD remain unplayed so I can't vouch for how they compare to my other versions yet. I haven't bothered to get "The Colour of Spring" as I assume it will be the same  

Posted on: 23 July 2012 by badlyread

Cheers! £40 saved! I love these albums and will continue to enjoy the original recordings.

 

Neil

Posted on: 23 July 2012 by King Size

My pleasure.  Must be honest when I read the above I felt the basic info should have been on the outside that I had of read it online before buying... so glad to be of service