Preparing To Stream--Questions:

Posted by: Russ on 28 August 2012

To all those of you who have helped an old codger who remembers when mono records were replaced by new-fangled "stereo"--who have helped me understand digital and in selecting a system--on to the next phase--provided you have not all run out of patience!  I have listened to your advice--and am acting on it.

 

OK, suppose I now have my Guru speakers ready to enclose in their cabinets--to emerge out front onto their stands when I am ready for a listening session.  And suppose further that I have blown all my money on said speakers, stands, and a Superuniti (or, if I can't afford it right now, an interim Unitiqute).

 

In the process of selecting the SU, just as I once gave up my vinyl for those funny little CD s, I have now given up my dependency on them as well.  Henceforth, I will be committed to digital sources, served, streamed, converted to analog, amplified, and routed into my speakers.

 

In the process, I have also listened to the majority who say I do not need the convenience of the Unitiserve--at the very least for now--and in giving that up (again, for now), I might--repeat MIGHT be able to just afford the Superuniti.  So someday, I may want to put everything I have on the SU.  In the meantime, I think I will have to start out with an old PC and peripherals and make the transition, first to a NAS, and then (perhaps) to the Unitiserve.

 

That long introduction leads up to what I am now hatching in my dull brain: I am the proud owner of an old Gateway laptop loaded with Vista, with a 256 Gig hard drive (128 or so currently availa

 

ble), with a Core2 Duo Intel Centino, a wireless connection to a screaming internet connection, and an optical disk drive that doesn't work any more.  Here is my thinking:

 

1.  I buy an external hard drive.

2.  I buy an external optical CD drive.

3.  I plug both into USB ports on the decrepit old Gateway.

4.  I install dbpoweramp (or some such software) for ripping WAV or FLAC files.

5.  I use the external CD drive and the ripping software to rip to the external hard drive.

 

Meanwhile, at some point, the Guru speakers and the Superuniti arrive at my front door.  I place the speakers in their chosen location--and because SWMBO has decreed there will be no visible electronic boxes visible in the same room--the Superuniti will take up residence in a closet (on a sturdy shelf, since I cannot afford a high-dollar rack).  I will not be able to control it through the wall using the remote, so I will load nstream onto my Iphone and make a wifi connection through the very walls.  Magic!!

 

The first fare will be stations such as KING FM Classical in Seattle--great stations.  The second will come when I schlep the external hard drive into the closet and plug it into the USB port on the Superuniti.  I will play music from there--hopefully using nstream--perhaps somewhat clumsily--until I can buy, configure, and figure out how to set up a NAS.

 

I have my music ripped, so it can ultimately be transfered to the NAS (complete with musci serving software) or to the Unitiserve--or whereever.

 

Please let me know what you think of my plan (and be assured as I progress, I will return to whine for more help)--positive--or not so much.  Your help is--as always--so much appreciated.

 

Best regards,

 

Russ

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Cbr600
Sounds like a very complex world you live in? If you really are an old codger you may recall the old advice that "source is king". If you have a poor quality source all other bits upstream are less important. Why mess with cheap optical drives and grad drives etc. this route will only lead to poor initial copies of your music and will negate the benefits of the system further down stream. Accept your destiny and buy a good Naim source Paul
Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Tog

Sounds like a plan....

 

In your position I would use Vortexbox to serve your SU - free (although donations welcome) and rock solid UPnP server that will run on very old hardware and perform all the functions of a UnitiServe and more.

 

Your old kit should work but for minimal outlay a i3 basic PC with 1 Gig drive should suffice. I started out by testing VB on an old Sony netbook and it worked a treat.

 

If the PC has a CD/DVD drive the software will rip your CDs automatically. Install Bliss and file organisation can be farmed out as well.

 

Tog

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Bart
Originally Posted by Russ:

 In the process, I have also listened to the majority who say I do not need the convenience of the Unitiserve--at the very least for now--and in giving that up (again, for now), I might--repeat MIGHT be able to just afford the Superuniti.  So someday, I may want to put everything I have on the SU.  In the meantime, I think I will have to start out with an old PC and peripherals and make the transition, first to a NAS, and then (perhaps) to the Unitiserve.

 

* * * * * * * * *

 

The first fare will be stations such as KING FM Classical in Seattle--great stations.  The second will come when I schlep the external hard drive into the closet and plug it into the USB port on the Superuniti.  I will play music from there--hopefully using nstream--perhaps somewhat clumsily--until I can buy, configure, and figure out how to set up a NAS.

Hi Russ,

 

In past posts you've been quite reluctant to go down the 'home grown' route, but certainly if money is limiting, you may have to.

 

Two things I've highlighted.  (1) The SuperUniti has no internal storage.  You can't "put" files on it; it always needs to be connected to a server or player, and (2) Naim do not recommend using an external hard drive as a source of music files.  Depending on the external drive, it might not even work as the SU's usb port may not provide sufficient power to run it.  You may need to substitute usb sticks instead, but these are relatively cheap.  You can put a lot of music on a 64 gig usb stick.

 

Hey maybe setting all this up will be fun and a learning experience

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Pev

My understanding is that Russ is intending to connect the drives to his old pc and then connect that to the SU, essentially using the pc as a Unitiserve equivalent - that would provide fine sound quality. If the PC doesn't have Spdif optical out then he may have to use a usb to spdif converter such as a hiface.

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Russ

cbr600: Pev is correct.  I have been lured away from my old, comfortable reliance on outmoded technology such as CD drives as source, just when I was getting used to them.  Shows you how far behind the times I am--Glenn Miller died before I was born, but I've always preferred his music to that of Elvis. 

 

Bart: Completely understood.  I realize the SU and the UQ both have no storage (or access to source, for that matter, other than i radio).  As to your doubts about the ability of the SU to handle larger USB "drives", I had thought of that--but not in terms of their need for more power (which of course is true, but the fact had escaped me until now) but rather in terms of whether (1) the SU could handle the greater capacity, and (2) whether the SU could "see" the file structure or whether you would have to plug the damned thing in and play its contents sequentially--like an old reel-to-reel tape.  I even emailed that question about a week ago to Naim, and received the following reply (which I think indirectly answered my question about capacity--but not your point about power):

 

"The USB port is not designed for large USB hard drives, they take too long to initialise.  The latest 2TB models of UnitiServe have a download folder where music can be stored and replayed."

 

Now that you have brought up the issue of power, I wonder if Naim was talking only about spinning disks taking too long to initialize--and not flash storage--in which case, one might get away with a much larger flash "drive". 

 

In any case, I think the largest "stick" anyone has mentioned they had in use so far was 64 gig--which is pretty substantial. 

 

Thanks,

 

Russ

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Geoff P
Originally Posted by Russ:

 

That long introduction leads up to what I am now hatching in my dull brain: I am the proud owner of an old Gateway laptop loaded with Vista, with a 256 Gig hard drive (128 or so currently availa

 

ble), with a Core2 Duo Intel Centino, a wireless connection to a screaming internet connection, and an optical disk drive that doesn't work any more.  Here is my thinking:

 

1.  I buy an external hard drive.

2.  I buy an external optical CD drive.

3.  I plug both into USB ports on the decrepit old Gateway.

4.  I install dbpoweramp (or some such software) for ripping WAV or FLAC files.

5.  I use the external CD drive and the ripping software to rip to the external hard drive.

  

I have my music ripped, so it can ultimately be transfered to the NAS (complete with musci serving software) or to the Unitiserve--or whereever.

 

Please let me know what you think of my plan (and be assured as I progress, I will return to whine for more help)--positive--or not so much.  Your help is--as always--so much appreciated.

 

Best regards,

 

Russ

Hi Russ

 

I think 1) to 5) will work fine especially if they will ultimately be replaced by a NAS os some variety.

I wouldn't worry about the quality of the CD/DVD ROM USB drive. Any reasonably priced make will do. dB Poweramp will calibrate it for optimum ripping and will let you know right away if there are any ripping errors which I have never experienced with my USB drive ( crap or damaged CDs is a different concern).

 

Since you are talking about a PC attached to the internet I am assuming you have a WiFi router which hopefuly would have at least two wired ports. For best results you should consider a wired connection for both the SU and the PC. Wireless streaming of audio is a little suspect and can experience audio dropouts due to fluctuations in the WiFi 'connection'.

 

You can also consider using Asset UPnP ( from the dB Poweramp people) as a media server. It can be loaded onto the PC and set to scan the USB drive with all your music on. You can then talk to Asset to serve music to the SU (or US) using the n-stream app on an i-device via wifi.

 

Regards

Geoff

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by mutterback

Russ - I think you'll be totally miserable trying to work through the old laptop as a source, let alone ripping CDs with it. You can get a vortexbox "appliance" from for about $400 with 1TB of storage. It will both rip your CDs, then serve as a UPNP server for the SU.

 

By the time you get an optical drive ($100?) a decent USB Hard drive ($100 - 200?) and endless hassle (priceless) you'll have spent $400 ish I think.

 

I love my vortexbox appliance.

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Russ

Geoff: Yes, I have an excellent wifi connection, (which I will make use of until I move out of this postage stamp of an apartment into a house that is under construction.  At that time, I intend to have Cat6 cable strung from the office, where the ISP combination modem/router will be, and do everything via wire.

 

mutterback: Good point.  Am I correct that the vortexbox (should have done more research, but have rejected that solution prior to this) has an optical disk drive to do the ripping AND internal software already installed to set it up as a UPnP server?

 

Thanks,

 

Russ 

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by nudgerwilliams

Russ

 

Not wishing to complicate things further, but if you want to go down the route of external hard drive plugged into SU and are concerned about the issues Naim have flagged, an option could be to use an iPod Classic.  160GB of storage, fully supported by Naim, plugs into front panel of SU (which keeps the iPod battery charged as well). You would probably put iTunes on your old laptop and rip / import to that.  It's an expensive way to buy 160GB of storage and iTunes does not support all file formats (eg FLAC) that you might come across, but it would be an easy way to manage music and sync to the iPod.  And has some nice features like Genius playlists if you are into that sort of thing.

 

David

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by GregU

Well.  Naim's reply sounds a bit disingenuous. My local dealer included this as an option.   Sure. You can buy a Uniti Serve. If the spinning hard drive is an issue you can just use a SSD external hard drive. Not as cheap as drives that spin but cheaper than the unitiserve. Maybe I'm missing something

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Bart
Originally Posted by GregU:

Well.  Naim's reply sounds a bit disingenuous. My local dealer included this as an option.   Sure. You can buy a Uniti Serve. If the spinning hard drive is an issue you can just use a SSD external hard drive. Not as cheap as drives that spin but cheaper than the unitiserve. Maybe I'm missing something

64 GB usb sticks, per gig, are a ton cheaper than external ssd drives when I've shopped them.

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by KitH

Can I add my praise for the Vortexbox Appliance. Mine presently hold 1200 ripped CDs which it feeds in Flac to a Uniti Mk1 and a Sonos system. It just works, providing excellent quality sound. Just plug into your router, the Uniti picks it up immediately. N-stream on iPad controls it all. 

 

The pricing model for downloads is a complete conspiracy against the consumer, so I buy CDs, rip them and store? When disaster strikes, as it will to any HD storage setup, I can restore with no fuss. Having worked in IT for a long time, I'm afraid I have no trust in large cloud providers looking after you in the long-term. With the Vortexbox I know I can replace the disk myself if it fails and I own the source data.

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by GregU
Originally Posted by Bart:
Originally Posted by GregU:

Well.  Naim's reply sounds a bit disingenuous. My local dealer included this as an option.   Sure. You can buy a Uniti Serve. If the spinning hard drive is an issue you can just use a SSD external hard drive. Not as cheap as drives that spin but cheaper than the unitiserve. Maybe I'm missing something

64 GB usb sticks, per gig, are a ton cheaper than external ssd drives when I've shopped them.

That's true.  I guess the downside is you just gotta change flash drives once in a while.   In a year or so large SSD will drop in price like everything else

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by mutterback

Hi Russ,

 

Yes, the VortexBox Appliance that you can buy from Small Green Computer through their web site or on Amazon includes an optical drive to rip CDs and DVDs. Don't think I can post a direct link to buy it, but you can find it easily.

 

You can also download the vortexbox software for free and turn any pc or mac into a VortexBox. However, this deletes everything on the computer, and you'd still need to add an optical drive and adequate storage to what you have now it seems.

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Russ

mutterback: I went out to the Small Green Computer site and looked at the various appliances--from one to four terrabytes--and they look really good for the money.  They emphasize that they work well with Sonos, but I assume they would support Naim streamers equally well--especially since so many Naim fans on this forum have a great deal of confidence in them.  What I THINK must be included is UPnP capability, although I did not see that mentioned, and I could not see the back of the appliances to determine whether there is plug for CAT cable.  I did see that they are DLNA compliant, so I assume that the UPnP is there.  This looks like a good solution for the storage.  I might go the USB stick route until I could justify the expenditure.  Thanks again.

 

Russ

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Bart

Russ, I'm pretty sure that when you see "DLNA" in the description of the VortexBox, that's the same as "UPnP."

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D...ing_Network_Alliance

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by mutterback

Russ - Sorry, didn't give you a complete answer before.

 

Yes, the VortexBox includes a UPNP server. That's what the Naim boxes need. I haven't tested it personally with Naim streamer, but others have reported it works great. (I've used a lot of other streaming options, and hope to get a Naim streamer in the near future.) 

 

It also includes a SqueezeBox server, which can "play" music over the network or directly out the back of the VortexBox from its sound card.  You won't need this for your Naim stream, but if you expand to other devices around the house, its great.

 

the connections it has are: ethernet, basic sound card analog out (which you probably won't use), several USB connections, and a headphone and mic jack in front, VGA/DVI video, HDMI, and an old fashioned keyboard connector.

Posted on: 29 August 2012 by Tog

Vorboxboard  works perfectly with Naim streamers and has an excellent backup facility - simply plug in a USB drive before you go to bed - press a button on the web based control software (works brilliantly on iOS devices - or Android for that matter) 

 

You can buy Vortexbox gear now and upgrade it with standard PC bits - or build your own HQ silent server with audiophile grade components for a bit of fun (sotm make excellent power filters and usb interfaces)

 

Tog

Posted on: 30 August 2012 by Russ

Tog,

 

Do you plug the USB external drive into the appliance itself or do you have to do it through a computer?

 

Russ

Posted on: 30 August 2012 by mutterback

Re: USB, think you may be asking two questions:

 

Yes, you connect the USB drive directly to the VortexBox. Note this requires a dedicated USB hard drive that you can't use for anything else (and it will erase anything else you had on it). Very simple - plug in your dedicated USB drive, go to the control panel, click Backup. 

 

You do need another computer to access the VB control panel web page. Again, simple, just open a web browser and type in http://vortexbox/

 

You can use a monitor and keyboard connected directly to the VB appliance, but this gives you access using the Linux command line. Its completely unnecessary to do this. You just need a PC, Mac, iPad, etc with a web browser connected to your home network.

Posted on: 30 August 2012 by Russ

Thanks, mutterback--very clearl explanation.  The education you all have provided on these forums has been outstanding.

 

Russ

Posted on: 30 August 2012 by revmis
Originally Posted by Bart:
Originally Posted by Russ:

 In the process, I have also listened to the majority who say I do not need the convenience of the Unitiserve--at the very least for now--and in giving that up (again, for now), I might--repeat MIGHT be able to just afford the Superuniti.  So someday, I may want to put everything I have on the SU.  In the meantime, I think I will have to start out with an old PC and peripherals and make the transition, first to a NAS, and then (perhaps) to the Unitiserve.

 

* * * * * * * * *

 

The first fare will be stations such as KING FM Classical in Seattle--great stations.  The second will come when I schlep the external hard drive into the closet and plug it into the USB port on the Superuniti.  I will play music from there--hopefully using nstream--perhaps somewhat clumsily--until I can buy, configure, and figure out how to set up a NAS.

Hi Russ,

 

In past posts you've been quite reluctant to go down the 'home grown' route, but certainly if money is limiting, you may have to.

 

Two things I've highlighted.  (1) The SuperUniti has no internal storage.  You can't "put" files on it; it always needs to be connected to a server or player, and (2) Naim do not recommend using an external hard drive as a source of music files.  Depending on the external drive, it might not even work as the SU's usb port may not provide sufficient power to run it.  You may need to substitute usb sticks instead, but these are relatively cheap.  You can put a lot of music on a 64 gig usb stick.

 

Hey maybe setting all this up will be fun and a learning experience

Guys,

 

I also have the SuperUniti with Proac D18. I can connect my Lacie 250gb (almost full of flac) and browse folder structure, play flac/wav directly from it. However, no album art, no way to queue or add playlist and some album cannot be seen. I also plug in kingston 8gb and Sandisk 16gb, all are fine.

 

 

Posted on: 30 August 2012 by Bart
Originally Posted by revmis:

Guys, I also have the SuperUniti with Proac D18. I can connect my Lacie 250gb (almost full of flac) and browse folder structure, play flac/wav directly from it. However, no album art, no way to queue or add playlist and some album cannot be seen.

 

 

This sounds to me why Naim do not recommend attaching usb hard drives.  That does not sound like a satisfying user experience!

Posted on: 31 August 2012 by revmis
Originally Posted by Bart:
Originally Posted by revmis:

Guys, I also have the SuperUniti with Proac D18. I can connect my Lacie 250gb (almost full of flac) and browse folder structure, play flac/wav directly from it. However, no album art, no way to queue or add playlist and some album cannot be seen.

 

 

This sounds to me why Naim do not recommend attaching usb hard drives.  That does not sound like a satisfying user experience!

@Bart: please show me where Naim recommend not to attach usb drive? I do not see anywhere on the website. Thanks

Basically I am using USB drive just to test and burn-in the SuperUniti (which is only 3 wks old).

If Naim can modify or enhance the user experience using Usb drive, I much prefer this, very convenience and simple, and save the cash off buying NAS or music server. And some others mention it sounds better compared to streaming.

Posted on: 31 August 2012 by revmis

@Bart: since you mention using usb stick, do you experience the same thing I describe here (no cover art, no queue or playlist), or just me the only one having this problem.