Backup plans if UPnP for Mac+iTunes is a failure on a new Naim streamer?

Posted by: Disposable hero on 30 October 2012

As each week passes with a new Nait XS amp running in, I'm beginning to realise the true value and investment as it/ the Naim sound starts to blossom. To complement and complete the system I'd like to add an ND5 XS, there is a bit of apprehension though when reading some of the horror stories of Uniti- based or other streamer and UPnP servers for Mac & iTunes users. There appears to be a lot of trial-and-error- ness about establishing a reliable UPnP server for Mac computers, various names are coming up including Playback, eLyric, Twonky and Asset. Some require additional faffing around to crossover from Windows to Mac (e.g. Asset).

My only option is wi-fi and so ethernet is totally out of the question. Wi-fi often has the finger pointed at it for being the problem in most network problems, however lots of consumer devices (e.g. budget Panasonic DVD players or Sony televisions) all have quite stable connections to wi-fi where I am so this shouldn't be a major problem.

 

This may seem like being overly risk-averse but I'd like to have in place as many solutions and contingency plans as possible to any potential problems, since any more Naim equipment, new/ ex-demo or second-hand will be a major investment. The UPnP for a Mac for iTunes Library playback, appears to be the main one, followed by wi-fi connectivity issues.

 

Last resort would be to have a handful of USB flash sticks or a hard drive loaded with albums to play back through the front socket. The formats are a mixture of mp3, AAC, ALAC and over time higher quality WAV.

Posted on: 30 October 2012 by Guido Fawkes

> Is it possible to narrow down to a shortlist of the "best of the best" UPnP server options for Mac users?

 

Yes - Playback no faffing required - just tell it where your library is. 

 

 

Maybe Asset when the full version is ported and Minim Server works, but PB works for sure. 

 

Vortexbox is superb if you cannot come to terms with the Apple solution. 

 

Mac Mini + Naim DAC/555PS is perhaps shaded by NDS + 2 x 555PS, but is still a mighty fine little system nonetheless

Posted on: 01 November 2012 by Disposable hero

Great, Playback looks faffless and hopefully it will work well.

Posted on: 01 November 2012 by jobseeker
If you only have wifi then I would recommend upgrading to the high gain aerial unless you're in the same room as the router/access point
Posted on: 02 November 2012 by scott_man
Elyric uPNP server from PS Audio runs on the Mac. Transcoding isn't working but with 'qute upgrade playing ALAC without problems from iTunes library. Can mount multiple libraries. Most ITunes cover art seems to come across. Reasonably fast with connection and browsing. Price: free! Pretty happy right now
Posted on: 03 November 2012 by james n

I've used playback for the last year or so since moving back to a Naim front end. It works very well. I had one issue with it, where some albums appeared as individual tracks in the album listing. Nothing much to worry about but a little niggle. I posted a message on the Playback forum, one of the developers got in touch and I sent them some debug info when playing the rogue albums. A few days later they issue an update which sorted out the bug. Great service and great product.

Posted on: 05 November 2012 by Disposable hero
Originally Posted by jobseeker:
If you only have wifi then I would recommend upgrading to the high gain aerial unless you're in the same room as the router/access point

Okay will bear that in mind, the unit would be located away from the router.

 

eLyric being free is a bonus, looks like it will be first on the list for the moment, followed by Playback.