
First complete spin of a new Simon Boccanegra. It preserves on disc Thomas Hampson in the role that has become one of his calling cards over the last few years. Studio recordings of operas have become rare, and most high profile releases follow the format here: concert performances with an audience, but organised specifically with the recording in mind (and patch-up sessions to correct for mistakes and audience noise). It is not a new concept - Furtwängler's famous RAI Ring was already done this way, as was Bernstein's Tristan in the 80s - but microphone techniques have improved to the point where the whole thing (almost) sounds like a studio recording. Arguably, the benefit of live performances is good for the intensity and flow of the recording; but the catch is, invariably details get lost that would have been captured in the studio, and singers tire.
Back to the performance: Simon Boccanegra (in its revised version, as here) is one of Verdi's most complex and beautiful operas, a mature work on the level of Don Carlos, Aida and Otello. Thomas Hampson has the charisma, the stamina and the voice to do the lead role justice. He has lost some of his earlier smoothness, but the slightly frayed, older voice fits the role well, particularly for the public scenes; and he still has the power and the top notes.
The other singers and the chorus are good to excellent across the board: Joseph Calleja is quite spectacular even, probably the best lyric Verdi tenor on stage today (his slightly tremulous voice is a matter of taste). Kristine Opolais has a big slightly veiled voice with strong top notes; her voice doesn't come across as 'lovely', certainly not as lovely as Calleja, so the love couple isn't ideally matched. Carlo Colombara is a very good Fiesco full of pathos, and he blends well with the others in the ensembles (the Act 3 duet with Hampson in particular outstanding). Massimo Zanetti is a new name to me - on this evidence, he is an excellent conductor.
Sound quality is very good; there is barely a hint that this was recorded live; no audience applause (or otherwise) has been included.
Good modern Verdi recordings have become a rarity, so slightly to my surprise, I'm really enthusiastic about this recording. The Abbado/Scala recording remains untouchable, but this is a good modern runner-up. Top marks for Hampson, Calleja and Decca for making this ambitious project a success.
Cheers,
EJ