DAC recommendations
Posted by: willie45 on 24 February 2013
HI
I'm sort of settling into my Hard Disk music system now. I still listen to CDs but I'm transferring the music to a mac mini set up plugged into the DAC on my Supernait. I have a Stello U3 between the computer and amp. I will be looking to sell my CD3.5 once my music transfer is complete and at that time I will upgrade to an external DAC. I have to say though, that the difference between my current setup with the mac mini as a source, and the CD3.5 is not an unpleasant one.
I am trying to find out whic are the best DACs to consider. I will of course give the Naim DAC a good listen and I am expecting that to be front runner, however, I fear treading the inevitable upgrade path with an expensive PSU in the future and I am looking at alternatives.
I have heard good things about the Eximus DP1 from April Music ( makers of the Stello ) as well as Bryston, Antelope, and others.( though the other seems to want you to buy a separate PSU too)
Anyway, I wondered if any of you good folks have recommendations as to DACs that should be on my audition list at around the same price as the Naim.
Posted on: 24 February 2013 by CharlieP
willie45,
I have heard (briefly in my system) the Shiit Gungnir, and it sounds very nice; $750 in US.
My favorite, which I use is the Naim DAC. It's best feature is the Burndy jumper on the back which, when replaced by XPS2 or 555PS transforms it performance - even out of proportion to the seemingly high cost of these outboard power supplies. So obviously you don't have to buy it all at once.
Cheers,
Charlie
Posted on: 25 February 2013 by DHT
John Atkinson found the Weiss 202 to be the best measuring piece of equipment in his 25 yearclog career.
H.
Posted on: 25 February 2013 by Eloise
The obvious suggestion (especially you will get here) is the Naim DAC...
Looking away from Naim my favourite DAC currently is the Chord QuteHD - 95%+ of the quality of the "grown up" Chord QBD76 at a 5th of the price (and half the cost of the Naim DAC). There are reports that the QuteHD improves significantly if you replace the basic SMPS with linear PSU.
Eloise
Posted on: 25 February 2013 by willie45
Thank you for your help. It seems apart from the Chord and Weiss options, Naim is looking like a good bet. I would baulk at the cost of the PSU but maybe I will be content with the straight DAC ( Maybe !)
Willie
Posted on: 25 February 2013 by NickSeattle
If you are committed to Naim for amp/pre long term, the synergy the Naim DAC and ND products offer is compelling, and worth paying something extra for. In my system, with modest, very forgiving speakers I happen to love, I do not hear a huge benefit from a separate PS; both with and without the 555PS-DR, to my ears, it tops the Rega DAC, and those onboard the Sonos, Squeezebox Touch, and AirPort Express, which it should for the money. I have not tried any of the other many worthy contenders.
I suspect if I ever find more discerning speakers I actually like, the perceived difference will only increase for the better, based on my own experience at home and in shops, and testimony of many others here. YMMV, of course.
Best of luck,
Nick
Posted on: 25 February 2013 by Bart
If available, a listen to the Berkeley Audio "alpha dac" might be interesting. I believe it's priced slightly higher than the Naim.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by DHT
If a dac is improved by a change of power supply then it is a poor design.
H
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Aleg
Originally Posted by DHT:
If a dac is improved by a change of power supply then it is a poor design.
H
Than everything is poorly designed 
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by PinkHamster
Originally Posted by Aleg:
Originally Posted by DHT:
If a dac is improved by a change of power supply then it is a poor design.
H
Than everything is poorly designed 
Well, let's say it is designed to optimize sales and margins at Naim. It COULD be designed so that a PS upgrade would be senseless.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Aleg
Originally Posted by PinkHamster:
Originally Posted by Aleg:
Originally Posted by DHT:
If a dac is improved by a change of power supply then it is a poor design.
H
Than everything is poorly designed 
Well, let's say it is designed to optimize sales and margins at Naim. It COULD be designed so that a PS upgrade would be senseless.
Everything is a compromise between technical possibilities, saleability and profit margins.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Simon-in-Suffolk
If the design criteria is that the performance can be increased by optional bolt ons so as to give a range of price / performance points, I would say the range of off board PSU 'upgrade' to the DAC/ND? /NAC etc is a good and effective design that means its design requirements.
Simon
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Bill McLean
Hi Simon,
Much prefer your Hood avatar!
Cheers
Bill.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Simon-in-Suffolk
Bill, thanks.. That's one plus for the space hopper and one for the Hood so far... Must admit I think I prefer the Hood as well...
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Jan-Erik Nordoen
Hi Simon,
+1 for the Hood. He just e x u d e s authority
.
Back to the topic :
+1 for the Naim DAC
+1 for the Berkely Designs Alpha DAC (heard one of these fed by iTunes + BitPerfect, fronting a Spectral system. Mmmm, music.
Bill the Cat.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Bart
Originally Posted by Jan-Erik Nordoen:
\+1 for the Berkely Designs Alpha DAC (heard one of these fed by iTunes + BitPerfect, fronting a Spectral system. Mmmm, music.
My local dealer, if you walk in off the street, would want to sell a Berkeley dac + Spectral every day of the week. And Magico speakers. That's their target. They put up with me and Naim
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Pev
Bring back the Hood or the teddy bear gets it!
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Jan-Erik Nordoen
The WWF thanks you Simon.
Nice eyebrows.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Pev
Thanks Simon - the teddy is safe... for now
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by MDS
Willie45
The Naim DAC is very good without an external PSU. I enjoyed mine that way for quite a while. The option of PSU upgrades is just that - an option. The Naim DAC amply justifies itself against the competition at that price point.
Simon-in-S - yes, I like the return of the Hood, too
MDS
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by Simon-in-Suffolk
Chaps, ok by popular demand the Hood returns, space hopper kicked off field. Btw earlier post should have said 'meets it's design requirements'....
Pev I can sleep easy tonight now, you really have quite an evil streak in you.. 
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by totemphile
Looking much better Simon! Hopefully this will entice Mr. Fawkes back as well 
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by naimUnT
None of the other DACS (non-Naim) have Naim's pixie boogie dust! I would stick to the nDac, especially since all your other equipment is Naim. Synergy is important.
Peace of mind too!
I've tried non-Naim DACs with my SU but always felt something missing.
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by willie45
Thanks folks. The Berkley DAC interests me. I looked at their site but can't see any UK dealers. I suppose it would need to be a US import then? Bit of a gamble is the problem there.
Willie
Posted on: 26 February 2013 by pcstockton
Originally Posted by naimUnT:
Synergy is important.
...and all that matters. Ive never been so musically happy.
Posted on: 27 February 2013 by Bill McLean
Hi Simon,
That's better, the Hood definately gives your post a certain authority. Good to know democracy is alive and well.
Cheers
Bill