Thoughts on UPnP after a year with the Uniti

Posted by: Martin Sixsmith on 01 February 2011

  1. Windows. Asset UPnP works very well with great functionality, including album artwork, Apple Lossless (converted to WAV on the fly ?). Tried others such as Twonky, Allegro but no Lossless support. Asset also functions smoothly via iPhone Apps such as Plug Player or PS Audio Tag n’ Play
  2. Apple Mac. Only Eye Connect works well for me. Great at streaming direct to the Uniti where Album / track details are shown on the Uniti display. Also streams Apple Lossless. However, if I want to use PlugPlayer or PS Audio Tag n’ Play then I cannot stream Apple Lossless or WAV– the Uniti tells me the "file format is unsupported". No album artwork either.
  3. Uniti – I found it be very router sensitive. The higher spec Thomson router that I upgraded to with O2 had continual dropouts (also with iRadio  but only on BBC stations !) and whenever I switched from UPnP to another input and then back to UPnP, it was unable to find the server. Only solution was to reboot. Switching to the bog standard POS router that came with my original O2 package solved all the problems. Strange !
  4. Conclusion. Windows users are well served (!) with Asset UpNp. Apple users are also OK with Eye Connect although it is a pity there is no album artwork support and I still don’t understand why it won’t play my Apple Lossless / WAV files via Plug Player.

Overall, I believe that UPnP still has a “work in progress” label attached to it.

For sheer user convenience and hassle free operation my current preference is the Apple Remote /iTunes / Airport Express combo. Works every time with Mac or PC, marvellous convenience & functionality and, to my ears at least, no discernible difference in sound quality.

Posted on: 18 March 2011 by JeanChris
Originally Posted by Martin Sixsmith:

For sheer user convenience and hassle free operation my current preference is the Apple Remote /iTunes / Airport Express combo. Works every time with Mac or PC, marvellous convenience & functionality and, to my ears at least, no discernible difference in sound quality.


On my side, even if I use Asset UPnP through CrossOver Mac, my best experience still remain using a SqueezeBox Duet connected to a SPDIF entry of the Uniti.

It is in the same "spirit" of your "AirPlay" approach

In my opinion, 2 things to conclude :
- UPnP is not well handled yet... a work in progress
- it will be a great enhancement if Naim provide, free or not, a UPnP server software (for both Windows, Mac & Linux) specifically studied to work with our Uniti.
Posted on: 19 March 2011 by Tog
It is about business models
If Naim gave you the software would you buy their hardware. Since they are predominantly a hardware company they are focused on selling that hardware on the traditional strengths of quality and bullet proof engineering that defines the Naim brand.
The software is subordinate to the heavy black hardware with the green logo.
The alternatives are to either use the software to encourage hardware sales or in the case of one fruit branded computer company use the qualities of both to drive purchasing.
It is interesting how much of the discussions in the Naim forums are about software these days.
The question is ... Do you buy the UnitiServe for the hardware or the software? I would suggest that unless you have a Naim black box fetish - the software is what clinches the deal.
In which case why would Naim want to sell you the software on it's own?

Tog

Tog just got rid of lots of spaces helps with the topic flow, hope you dont mind, paul