iPad maxi or mini?

Posted by: BigH47 on 21 July 2013

Anyone care to share any thoughts of pros and cons of the 2 species of iPad?

 

We are looking for a better( more compact) solution than taking a lap top when travelling, just being able to check e-mails, maps and local facilities in a larger format than an iPhone.

We were looking at a refurbed 16gb from the Apple store at about 220 UKP is it worth the extra £150 for the larger version?

 

TIA

 

Howard

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by tonym

SWMO kept nicking my iPad so I treated her to an iPad Mini, which, if all you want to do is surf the web & manage E-mails, is brilliant and the small screen size isn't a huge disadvantage IMO.

 

For what you want one for Howard I reckon a Min's fine and certainly less unwieldy to use on the move.

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by Mike-B

+1 for the mini if its mainly for travel. 

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by J.N.

Bear in mind Howard that the current Mini does not have the higher resolution 'Retina' display of the iPad 3 and 4. Whether this is an issue on the smaller screen can only be decided by comparison.

 

Our friend Scotty has just changed his Mini to an iPad 4, so you might like to have a chat with him.

 

Best wishes.

 

John.

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by GraemeH

Bear in mind also the mini uses a smaller charging socket akin to the iPhone 5 which is a mite annoying with compatibility to our iPad 2 and iPhone 4. G

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by BigH47

Thanks for that chaps. Guy in iStore did mention the picture quality,but did say the smaller picture on the mini seemed to concentrate the picture so there wasn't a great deal to choose. I certainly didn't notice with a quick look.

Graeme thanks for the socket tips, sounds a bit annoying, is there an adapter do you know?

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by Goon525

Yes, there is an adaptor. The mini has perfectly good image quality, is quite a lot more compact and quite a bit cheaper. Occasionally, the smaller size of type is a slight disadvantage but generally it performs as well as full size and will suit you better for travel.

Posted on: 21 July 2013 by Sloop John B

Typing this on an iPad (maxi?) a present for SWMBO but has turned into a family machine. 

A big use that I would not have thought of before was for what I'll loosely call TV. iplayer and netflix are big favourites with 3 young ins and 2 oldies. I'd imagine the bigger screen is better for these. 

 

I'm thinking of getting a mini for myself but will wait until a new version comes out (September?). 

It's likely to have the retina display and be the same price.

 

 

just some thoughts...............

 

 

Posted on: 22 July 2013 by Tony Lockhart

Like you, Howard, my parents are really, really old. I've just given them a full size Retina iPad each for their 50th anniversary, and they're loving them. My mum's will fit in her handbag no trouble, but I really can't see my dad carrying a 'fanny packet' style bag.......

Posted on: 22 July 2013 by Tony Lockhart
My embarrassing dad using his iPad. For crying out loud.....

Posted on: 22 July 2013 by BigH47

Unfortunately Tony we don't have any parents left so the embarrassment slot has fallen to me.

 

Does your Dad dance as well? Or even worse that fashion faux pas sandals and socks?

Posted on: 22 July 2013 by fixedwheel

Sorry H, but I don't think Tony was thinking of your parents when he said "really, really old." 

 

John

Posted on: 22 July 2013 by BigH47

Deflecting!

Posted on: 26 July 2013 by too old to rock

Purchased IPAD 3 couple of years ago mainly to control HDX and use as kindle substitute (could not justify buying ipad just for running n-Serve. I was hoping the retina display would be good enough to read outside in bright sun and it just about does the job. I do find wearing my polarised specs makes life easier as it cuts glare on the screen. Provided the brightness cranked right up its ok. I use the kindle reader rather then I Books as generally the books are cheaper.

So if you think you might use the ebook facility the larger ipad with better display might be worth considering.

Posted on: 26 July 2013 by SiHancox

Typing this on the Mini which I purchased a few months ago. I consider it is the ideal size for readability versus portability, although the screen is not retina (and was missed at first) you quickly adapt - the upside it has great battery life. Used daily for all but heavy duty work (still have Macbook Pro for those tasks) I have yet to see battery drop below 80% at day end - if left disconnected from the computer think it might just last the week between charges! Yes, the new dock connector can be an issue if you have multi devices but you can buy an adaptor if you want to use the same cable. Another advantage of the size is weight reduction which to me just seems to give the Mini better handling than it's larger relatives. Rumour has it that Apple will introduce Mini 2 either late this year or early next - more likely with retina screen and beefed up processor, if battery usage can be maintained that will be one "killer" tablet.

 

Si.

Posted on: 26 July 2013 by Jasonf
Originally Posted by SiHancox:

Typing this on the Mini which I purchased a few months ago. I consider it is the ideal size for readability versus portability, although the screen is not retina (and was missed at first) you quickly adapt - the upside it has great battery life. Used daily for all but heavy duty work (still have Macbook Pro for those tasks) I have yet to see battery drop below 80% at day end - if left disconnected from the computer think it might just last the week between charges! Yes, the new dock connector can be an issue if you have multi devices but you can buy an adaptor if you want to use the same cable. Another advantage of the size is weight reduction which to me just seems to give the Mini better handling than it's larger relatives. Rumour has it that Apple will introduce Mini 2 either late this year or early next - more likely with retina screen and beefed up processor, if battery usage can be maintained that will be one "killer" tablet.

 

Si.

+ 1 on all these points.

 

If you are really into watching HD on your Pad and desperately want the bigger size then go for it, but I found it unweildly and unnecessarily large and heavy for all tasks compared to the Mini.

 

Jason.

Posted on: 26 July 2013 by GraemeH

With both sizes in the house I automatically always go for the larger iPad to browse, type, add notes, view calendar etc.  It's not a particularly conscious thing - I must prefer it though.

 

G

Posted on: 27 July 2013 by Paper Plane

Does anyone use their 'maxi' or Mini for taking pictures? How does the size difference affect things If at all))?

 

cheers

 

steve (who may be getting an iPad for Crimble)

Posted on: 28 July 2013 by Mike Hughes
The latest iPad (4) and the mini both use the smaller lightning connector. The theory that you don't miss the retina display on the smaller screen is just that. A theory. Some people won't notice and some people will, immediately. I noticed as soon as I started to test email on a mini and zoom up. The blur meant it wasn't quite good enough. Weight is interesting as the 4 is heavier than the 2 for example but also perhaps shadows better for some people. What people don't factor in is what happens when you add a case. I've found using a 2 on my lap to blog on the sofa was tough the first time but lovely by the 3rd time. I suspect that the mini will suit me and my VI much better overall but I need a retina version really. Unlike others I dint expect version number 2 to be that version looking at l the rumours sites and then reading about why it wasn't in the first place. So, may be a mistake to wait. Most likely mini 2 will have a better camera; a different shape; 4G and sd other stuff. It may not be retina as that is likely to increase cost at a point when market share is under threat. I can't really see the point of a Kindle. Sure there are some differences in costs but those are narrowing rapidly and Amazon ordering restructures aren't likely to be confined to the main site orders. Bottom line for me is that the iBooks experience is smoother; more enjoyable and likely to remain so. Basically you need to sit in an Apple store and try both. Importantly, don't try them standing up. Go to the kids bit with the large cushions and sit down with them there. That will tell you much of which differences will matter to you.