why again are Naim streamers not supporting Spotify?

Posted by: Louis-Andre on 25 November 2013

Sorry I know it has been discussed in previous posts, but I cannot find a good reason anywhere... is this a legal issue? or a strategic decision? frankly, considering the costs of Naim streamers I find this quite disapointing....
Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Goon525

And you're not alone. I get round it via iPad and Apple TV, but Naim do seem slow to add functionality. Anyone remember Airplay?

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by heihei

If Naim supported Spotify, I'd buy 2 Unitiqutes tomorrow to replace my Sonos amps.

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Louis-Andre
i spend a good deal of my time listening via Spotify, and I am sure many other Naimees do the same. Seems like Naim is missing an opportunity here...
Posted on: 25 November 2013 by ashrafs

That is the one thing that has stopped me investing in a naim streamer. Poor functionality compared to other products. Sonos is superb

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Magnus Hultstrand
+1. As you might have read in another post, I returned a ND5XS to my dealer today after a home demo over the weekend. I'm not sure if I'm going to buy it yet, and Spotify is one reason for my doubts..
Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Rattlesnaic

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a Low Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by dave4jazz
Originally Posted by Rattlesnaic:

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a (Low) Medium (320kbps) Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

I'm a fan of Spotify but Naim are putting their money on Qobuz (Hi-res) coming to a streamer near you next Mon 2 Dec.

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by ricsimas
Originally Posted by Rattlesnaic:

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a Low Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

Because it's a great way of hearing new music and, in this hobby, I still think that ought to be a major concern of anyone involved. It's functionality that is expected of streamers.

 

It doesn't have to give its best when playing Spotify - just playing it would be great for that usage.

 

I end up getting a Naim streamer because I wanted the digital inputs as well and digital audio is a very secondary source in my system (meaning I didn't want to spend DSM bucks on it), but the fact that I'll have to get an Apple TV irks me.

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Goon525

While I have proved to myself by A/B testing that 320k isn't as good as CD quality, it really isn't that bad, obviously nowhere near high res but perfectly adequate for either checking an album out, or casual listening. Somewhere between 192 and 320, something rather good seems to happen.

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Bart
Originally Posted by Rattlesnaic:

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a Low Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

The streamers and servers already support internet radio -- which is also a Low Fi product.  So that cannot be the answer

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by badlyread
Originally Posted by dave4jazz:
Originally Posted by Rattlesnaic:

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a (Low) Medium (320kbps) Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

I'm a fan of Spotify but Naim are putting their money on Qobuz (Hi-res) coming to a streamer near you next Mon 2 Dec.

And you know this for sure?

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Jan-Erik Nordoen

Naim is listed amongst the companies that will be integrating the Quobuz API into their streamers. 

 

More here (in French)

 

http://blogs.qobuz.com/qobuzbl...-futurs-innovations/

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by Kevin Richardson
Originally Posted by Magnus Hultstrand:
+1. As you might have read in another post, I returned a ND5XS to my dealer today after a home demo over the weekend. I'm not sure if I'm going to buy it yet, and Spotify is one reason for my doubts..

Really?  For what other purpose are those optical digital inputs provided?

 

I just have a problem understanding why people with streamers + iPads + discretionary income problems issue with Naim not providing spotify.  Is the Apple TV solution not reasonable enough?  You can rename the input from Digital 3 to Spotify.  The Spotify ipad app is also very high quality.  There really is not much to be gained through native Naim support.

 

My opinion obviously... But I suspect Naim has a similar view.

Posted on: 25 November 2013 by dave4jazz
Originally Posted by badlyread:
Originally Posted by dave4jazz:
Originally Posted by Rattlesnaic:

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a (Low) Medium (320kbps) Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

I'm a fan of Spotify but Naim are putting their money on Qobuz (Hi-res) coming to a streamer near you next Mon 2 Dec.

And you know this for sure?

That's what it says:

http://www.qobuz.com/uploads/c...ease-20131024-UK.pdf

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by ricsimas
Originally Posted by Kevin Richardson:
Really?  For what other purpose are those optical digital inputs provided?

 

I just have a problem understanding why people with streamers + iPads + discretionary income problems issue with Naim not providing spotify.  Is the Apple TV solution not reasonable enough?  You can rename the input from Digital 3 to Spotify.  The Spotify ipad app is also very high quality.  There really is not much to be gained through native Naim support.

 

My opinion obviously... But I suspect Naim has a similar view.

I would much rather not have to deal with another box plus its set of cables.

 

The iPad Spotify app is totally fine, and one could just use Naim's Airplay support to stream it directly - if it existed.

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by Louis-Andre
Naim should align to customer  demand, instead of forcing on a specific direction. I use my Naim for all types of listen, not just for hi rez files. And paying that much money for a streamer, and still needing additional boxes to make it work, seems to me a big step in the wrong direction. Even if sound quality will be lesser than eg Qobuz, I would still be happy to run this via Naim streamers. Plus, Qubuz does not have the database Spotify has, does not serve the same purpose and is not available in as many countries. 
Originally Posted by ricsimas:
Originally Posted by Kevin Richardson:
Really?  For what other purpose are those optical digital inputs provided?

 

I just have a problem understanding why people with streamers + iPads + discretionary income problems issue with Naim not providing spotify.  Is the Apple TV solution not reasonable enough?  You can rename the input from Digital 3 to Spotify.  The Spotify ipad app is also very high quality.  There really is not much to be gained through native Naim support.

 

My opinion obviously... But I suspect Naim has a similar view.

I would much rather not have to deal with another box plus its set of cables.

 

The iPad Spotify app is totally fine, and one could just use Naim's Airplay support to stream it directly - if it existed.

 

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by dt3t
Originally Posted by Kevin Richardson:
Originally Posted by Magnus Hultstrand:
+1. As you might have read in another post, I returned a ND5XS to my dealer today after a home demo over the weekend. I'm not sure if I'm going to buy it yet, and Spotify is one reason for my doubts..

Really?  For what other purpose are those optical digital inputs provided?

 

I just have a problem understanding why people with streamers + iPads + discretionary income problems issue with Naim not providing spotify.  Is the Apple TV solution not reasonable enough?  You can rename the input from Digital 3 to Spotify.  The Spotify ipad app is also very high quality.  There really is not much to be gained through native Naim support.

 

My opinion obviously... But I suspect Naim has a similar view.

 

On the discretionary income point, Naim's Managing Director reported to What Hifi that Airplay would be available in Q1 2012 via a simple firmware update.  I (and perhaps others) bought Naim equipment  relying on this statement.  I consider Airplay to be bought, paid for, yet undelivered.  I don't think it is reasonable to require additional equipment to serve as a crutch given that airplay is supposed to be native at this point (according to Naim).  

 

 

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by Magnus Hultstrand
Originally Posted by Kevin Richardson:
Originally Posted by Magnus Hultstrand:
+1. As you might have read in another post, I returned a ND5XS to my dealer today after a home demo over the weekend. I'm not sure if I'm going to buy it yet, and Spotify is one reason for my doubts..

Really?  For what other purpose are those optical digital inputs provided?

 

I just have a problem understanding why people with streamers + iPads + discretionary income problems issue with Naim not providing spotify.  Is the Apple TV solution not reasonable enough?  You can rename the input from Digital 3 to Spotify.  The Spotify ipad app is also very high quality.  There really is not much to be gained through native Naim support.

 

My opinion obviously... But I suspect Naim has a similar view.

Good point Kevin. I think I have to put my doubts aside. During the home demo i just listened to Spotify for maybe 30 minutes and the rest of the time I was rediscovering my CD collection (+600 albums), now in FLAC. For me, Spotify is a way to discover new music and for casual listening. Maybe something like an Arcam bluetooth DAC or an Apple TV is the way to go for integration of Spotify with naim streamers (for me that is..)

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by ricsimas
Originally Posted by dt3t:
 

On the discretionary income point, Naim's Managing Director reported to What Hifi that Airplay would be available in Q1 2012 via a simple firmware update.  I (and perhaps others) bought Naim equipment  relying on this statement.  I consider Airplay to be bought, paid for, yet undelivered.  I don't think it is reasonable to require additional equipment to serve as a crutch given that airplay is supposed to be native at this point (according to Naim).  

Indeed - just for reference, one of the mentions of Airplay support: http://www.whathifi.com/news/m...reaming-player-range

 

If there is any one reason why AirPlay ought to be integrated, it's the fact that it was promised.

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by Kevin Richardson
Originally Posted by Magnus Hultstrand:
Originally Posted by Kevin Richardson:
Originally Posted by Magnus Hultstrand:
+1. As you might have read in another post, I returned a ND5XS to my dealer today after a home demo over the weekend. I'm not sure if I'm going to buy it yet, and Spotify is one reason for my doubts..

Really?  For what other purpose are those optical digital inputs provided?

 

I just have a problem understanding why people with streamers + iPads + discretionary income problems issue with Naim not providing spotify.  Is the Apple TV solution not reasonable enough?  You can rename the input from Digital 3 to Spotify.  The Spotify ipad app is also very high quality.  There really is not much to be gained through native Naim support.

 

My opinion obviously... But I suspect Naim has a similar view.

Good point Kevin. I think I have to put my doubts aside. During the home demo i just listened to Spotify for maybe 30 minutes and the rest of the time I was rediscovering my CD collection (+600 albums), now in FLAC. For me, Spotify is a way to discover new music and for casual listening. Maybe something like an Arcam bluetooth DAC or an Apple TV is the way to go for integration of Spotify with naim streamers (for me that is..)

The Apple TV / Airport Express sounds Excellent.  Yes you need to send it from your iPad or a computer but it works very well.  The Spotify App is better than anything Naim would include in n-Stream.  The ND5 is great for what it offers.

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by Goon525
Originally Posted by ricsimas:
Originally Posted by dt3t:
 

On the discretionary income point, Naim's Managing Director reported to What Hifi that Airplay would be available in Q1 2012 via a simple firmware update.  I (and perhaps others) bought Naim equipment  relying on this statement.  I consider Airplay to be bought, paid for, yet undelivered.  I don't think it is reasonable to require additional equipment to serve as a crutch given that airplay is supposed to be native at this point (according to Naim).  

Indeed - just for reference, one of the mentions of Airplay support: http://www.whathifi.com/news/m...reaming-player-range

 

If there is any one reason why AirPlay ought to be integrated, it's the fact that it was promised.

Exactly so.

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by KRM

For me, there's a sizeable gap between Spotify via Airplay (Apple TV) and the USB on the front of the DAC. Presumably, Bluetooth from the iPad is worse as it's limited to 128kb/s. I'm upgrading to the NDS, but the USB input doesn't work with Apple products so it's the drDock for me unless/until Naim address whatever it is that makes developing their software so painfully slow.

 

Keith

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by Kevin Richardson
Originally Posted by KRM:

For me, there's a sizeable gap between Spotify via Airplay (Apple TV) and the USB on the front of the DAC. Presumably, Bluetooth from the iPad is worse as it's limited to 128kb/s. I'm upgrading to the NDS, but the USB input doesn't work with Apple products so it's the drDock for me unless/until Naim address whatever it is that makes developing their software so painfully slow.

 

Keith

The Apple solution does not rely on BlueTooth.  It uses WiFi.  You can stream full quality Spotify from iPad to Apple TV / Airport Express.

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by KRM

Hi Kevin,

 

I know and I do, but it doesn't sound as good as when directly connected to the DAC.

 

If the streamer had Spotify embedded it's the same and better than direct connection. There's Spotify Connect now too.

 

Keith

Posted on: 26 November 2013 by totemphile
Originally Posted by Rattlesnaic:

Why should a Premium Hi-Fi product like Naim Streamers support a Low Fi product like Spotify ?

Naim streamers only really give their best when fed High Res Music

That's a bit of an overstatement. I think they sound exceptionally good with standard CD rips as well and make some 320 kbps streams sound rather good too. As to hires, well some will sound very good other hires files will not automatically sound better than their original CD file counterpart. Any streamer will sound its best with a good hires file, not just Naim.

 

As to Spotify, why then do they enable Internet radio at all and rave so much about Radio Paradise? They stream at 320kbps.

 

It would be interesting to know whether Linn support Spotify? It's a great service and there's no apparent reason why Naim should not support it, even if they planed to go with Qobuz.