AIFF vs AIFF-C

Posted by: DF50 on 27 November 2013

Hi everyone,  I was ripping music to a hard drive the other day, through XLD on my MAC.  i had XLD set to rip in AIFF, but i noticed today, even though the extension is AIFF, the type shows as AIFF-C!  what is this, why would it rip like that and is there a difference, and if there is a difference is the sq different?

 

thanks

Posted on: 28 November 2013 by mrspoon

AIF-C means compressed, and this is a lossy compression, such as mp3 (or one of the a law or u law compressions).

Posted on: 28 November 2013 by Eloise

Actually AIF-C only may contain compressed format data. Usually it is used to create a little-endian file format which is prefered by Mac OS X.

 

Basically don't worry about it - unless you set some form of compression it won't be compressed.

 

eloise

Posted on: 28 November 2013 by DF50

Thanks guys, makes me feel better!  

 

Posted on: 28 November 2013 by Simon-in-Suffolk

Hmm.. AIFF as a standard container is similar to WAV encoded with  (L)PCM (in hifi /consumer circles this is the encoding we associate with WAV, but in industry it supports many more). With AIFF and default WAV the sample bit order is reversed, little endian and big endian. Some of the chunk types are different,  with AIFF having a smaller defined set, and originally AIFF did not support meta data. AIFF-C adds many compressive and lossy data types as well as non compressive data types making it more similar to the capabilities of WAV.

 

However if the PCM is converted and therefore compressed into a non linear uLaw or aLaw encoding, supported in AIFF-C and WAV, from linear PCM (LPCM) there will be a loss of data, as effectively precision is reduced. For most of the world traditional telephony (TDM) and IP telephony have used μLaw and aLaw for decades and we are quite happy with it. Many including myself consider it the benchmark to measure more aggressive IP telephony compression types to.

 

BTW AIFF-C can store samples in the same order as WAV (little endian) , ie the reverse of AIFF

Simon