Cop show cliches

Posted by: Paper Plane on 30 November 2013

There are number of situations that will always arise in any (usually) North American police procedural series. It doesn't matter how long the series runs for, each one of these will occur, not maybe, they will, sometimes more than once. You can count on it.

1. The lead character, or a significant member of the team (if there is a team), will be charged with murder or some other similar serious offence. They will, of course, be completely innocent. This will eventually be proved and, just in the nick of time just in order to raise the suspense.

2. A member of the lead character's family (partner/child/parent) will be abducted/kidnapped. The missing person will eventually be found alive, leading to a tearful reunion and high minded moralising about the nature of relationships.

3. The lead character will be suspended for some misdemeanour. Usually they are innocent and have been set up or, They Had A Very Good Reason to act as they did. This will inevitably be proved and the character reinstated without a stain on their record.

4. They will acquire a nemesis or an arch-villain who will  pop up from time-to-time throughout the series. Said villain will often be caught and banged up but, as sure night follows day, they will escape to taunt the lead character/team once again. Eventually, often after a Situation 1 or 2 above has occurred, they will be found and, normally, die. Usually in an unusual or exotic manner.

5. At some point in an investigation, a serving prisoner will need to be questioned. This person is usually a serial killer. They will also be creepy, know something about the interrogator's history or family and, on occasion, be the nemesis mentioned in Situation 4. They will also be clearly bonkers.

6. The lead character, if they have a police partner, will fall out with them big time over some minor matter. This will be solved and they will be even closer afterwards.

Feel free to add your own to the list as it is not exhaustive.

As a matter of interest, I can think of one show where very few of these have cliches have occurred and that's Cold Case. Mind you, given the nature of the programme, not many of the relevant circumstances are likely to occur.

steve

Posted on: 30 November 2013 by BigH47

.....and your point is?

 

Are you saying they are formulaic?

I guess that Shakespeare's plays are, Mozart's operas are christmas pantomimes are etc etc.

 

 

Posted on: 30 November 2013 by winkyincanada

It is not just the recurrence of cliches like you list that annoys me about the multitude of cop shows, but rather that they are just plain boring. The same stuff over and over.

 

The other cliche is that the obvious suspect virtually never did it. Except sometimes when they double bluff, by making the obvious suspect so obvious that you think it must be a red herring. And then it isn't. Wow. They're messing with our minds, people. The script writers must be brilliant. Oh no wait, the other thing: imbecilic.

Posted on: 01 December 2013 by GraemeH
A 'back-story' will come back to haunt the main cop - just at the time some decisive action is needed.

G
Posted on: 02 December 2013 by Paper Plane

There is no real point. I wrote merely to amuse, hopefully others as well as myself.

 

There is also the vague hope that amongst the erudite contributors to this Forum, there may have been one with connections to the industry who might be given pause for thought...

 

steve

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by Cbr600

Midsomer

 

Now theres a place you dont want to visit

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by Kevin-W
Originally Posted by Cbr600:

Midsomer

 

Now theres a place you dont want to visit

Is there actually any there left unmurdered Paul?

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by Reginald Halliday
Originally Posted by Char Wallah:

you forgot to mention the car chase.

Which in proper 70s/80s shows would end amidst a pile of killer cardboard boxes.

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by winkyincanada

I always thought "Murder She Wrote" was based on a ridiculous premise. She was an author, not a cop. No reason to associated with crime at all. Unbelievably unlucky to be involved in murder after murder after murder. If I was investigating, I'd put 2 and 2 together after the second or third time and throw her @$$ in jail.

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by Richard S

There are cliche ridden cop sows......and then there was Quincy ME.

 

"You've gone too far this time Quincy! I'm suspending you for straining the bounds of artistic credulity."*

 

(*whilst conveniently ignoring all the other episodes where you were proved correct all along. Again)

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by simon, but not simple

Let us not forgot the essential ingredient in all modern day detective dramas; the "bent" copper", usually in a senior position, "on the make" and "silencing" anyone who suspects him.

 

This scenario certainly does the real life police force public image no favours.

Posted on: 02 December 2013 by joerand

How 'bout the cop having a meth manufacturing and peddling brother-in-law who is actually the primary character of the show? Oh wait, that's not cliche. Sorry.   (Exactly the reason I loved that show)