Statement has landed

Posted by: Graham Clarke on 09 May 2015

So after three long months of waiting, my Statement preamp finally arrived yesterday.  I managed to do pretty well in being patient until we got down to around the last ten days…  This was the starting point:

 

 

Since my Statement home demo via UHES in January I’ve changed my two main interconnects to Super Lumina ones and have swapped out NAC A5 for Super Lumina, at a somewhat excessive cost, but with brilliant results. 

 

 

To answer a previous question asked on the Forum regarding how these speaker cables are tuned, it is down to the resistor used.  The resistor is soldered across the positive and negative cables and then surrounded in the metal box to protect it.  This provides the correct inductance that the power amps require.  The tuning is the value of the resistor and the type of resistor used (e.g. RS Components, Farnell etc).  Required values were determined for specific lengths via listening and then other lengths were calculated via a computer program.

 

Anyway, onto the day.  The plan was to check the torque settings on the S-600 speakers’ drive unit screws, break down, clean, tighten and reconfigure the Fraim racks, install the six Super Lumina DIN-XLR cables and oh, just add the Statement S-1 pre-amp to the mix, replacing the 552…

 

To complete this task we had four people.  Ian and Norman from UHES of course, plus Jason Gould and Mark Raggett directly from Naim.  It’s always enjoyable spending time with Ian and Norman but also getting to spend around four hours with Jason and Mark was the icing on the cake.

 

 

Ian first checked the speaker torque settings, which turned out to be fine since their last check nearly two years ago.  Given I purchased these as ex-demo speakers from UHES it’s probably no surprise that they had already bedded in and didn’t need further adjustment.

 

I wish I could say the same about the Fraim racks.  These were new a year ago and Ian had told me that I should check the tightness of the spikes after a few months because there is a degree of compression and expansion of the wood from new which will loosen them.  Having assumed that they would just be slightly loose combined with a degree of laziness and a manic work schedule I’m afraid I hadn’t bothered.  Well, when we broke down the power supply Fraim rack and lifted the base off the carpet, one of the spikes remained embedded in the concrete floor, to my embarrassment!  So YES, you really DO need to check these with newly built Fraim racks.

 

During this time break down time, Jason and Mark had man handled the S-1 flight case out of Mark’s car.  At least for the UK, these are delivered direct from the factory to the customer.  “Man handled” is the correct term given the 102Kg shipping weight but this was slightly easier than in January as the case now has detachable wheels.  Direct delivery is done to ensure that the unit turns up in 100% perfect condition both cosmetically and functionally.  This was of course not a problem with mine.

 

While they were busy doing this, I kept myself busy by taking a look at the long awaited DIN-XLR cables.

 

Anyone familiar with Powerlines or Hi-Lines will recognise the packaging.

 

 

 

As you can see, both ends use the Air-PLUG technology that the other Super Lumina cables use via a set of interconnecting metal rings.  The XLR canons are also metal, unlike the original ones.

 

Jumping forward slightly, the only glitch of the day was that when installing these cables into my Snaxo BMR, the far end of the Air-PLUG connectors on the top cable touch the one beneath.  When the system has bedded in I’ll have to see whether this actually makes an audible difference.

 

 

There was another box which was unexpected, this turned out to be the Statement accessory kit, the finish of which was beautiful.

 

 

There were three layers to this box with the top containing the manual and a spirit level.

 

 

The second layer in mine was empty given I had not purchased the Statement power amps.  Apparently I am the first person world wide that Naim have supplied with just the pre-amp, all other purchasers have gone for the complete system.

 

In the bottom layer of the box were a number of tools

 

 

Including some Statement Fraim chips (different from standard ones) and the remote control which is in the bag on the right.  This is constructed of metal and is similar in weight and feel to the NARCOM remote.

 

Given the NARCOM remote is £300, I dread to think how much a replacement one of these would be.  I better not lose it down the back of the sofa.

 

After completing the first Fraim rack, Jason and Mark unpacked the pre-amp.

 

 

Given the size, weight and space constraints this does need to be planned!  With the protective cover removed it finally appeared for the first time.

 

 

Even unpackaged this weighs 60Kg so moving into position isn’t an easy task.  This is what it looks like inside to help explain (no, this isn't mine!)

 

 

That's a lot of components!

 

Happily (for me) I left the task of moving to Mark.

 

 

No pressure there Mark, I’m sure you loved me taking pictures of you while you were doing this!

 

 

We agree not to put it flush up to the racks so that it could be easily cleaned.  Getting the position right, ensuring it was absolutely level and parallel with the left hand rack easily took 30 minutes such was the perfectionist nature of Ian and Mark. 

 

Installing the second Fraim was relatively straightforward after this, poor Ian was left to do this while everyone else chatted and watched on.  Jason commented that normally with home installs they get involved directly but knew that they could leave this to Ian given his expertise.  High praise indeed for UHES.

 

One added bonus of moving to two racks and separating them slightly is that cable dressing is now much better, with no Burndys touching the wall and all but a few cables off the floor.

 

 

Finally, after over four hours of work, everything was set up and listening was about to begin!

 

 

By now it was about 6:30PM and we had a dinner reservation for 7:30 as we were all hungry, so we only had limited listening time.  I wasn’t too worried about this because the pre-amp is brand new and stone cold, the DIN-XLRs are also new and the rest of the system would have cooled down, so my expectations weren’t too high.

 

From the first track there was a slight degree of harshness around the sound.  This was consistent with the from cold demo in January.  High frequencies were also a little tight and I’d say that the pre-amp and system in generally was probably only at around 50% of its full potential.  Despite that, some of the greatness from the January demo was already apparent: the super low noise floor (if it was any lower it would be sucking noise out of the room) along with the incredible detail and separation of every instrument being played.

 

Unfortunately Saturday obligations mean I won’t get to listen further until later in the afternoon, but both main sources have been left active playing into the system and with further warm up I’m expecting a big jump.  So you’ll have to wait a while longer for the clichés and superlatives.

 

More to follow and thanks for reading if you got this far.

 

 

Posted on: 12 May 2015 by drawtheline55

Yep, please keep the updates coming, system looks great too.

 

Ben

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by NikonAl

Graham,

As a new member to this forum with a very modest system

CD5X

122X

150X

Flatcap 2X

Spendor A5s, I can't really begin to imagine what this set up of yours must sound like.

As someone who enjoys the Naim sound yet knows so little about the technical side of things your write up concerning the installation of the S-1 is a very interesting read.

I hope it gives you many years of listening pleasure, no doubt it will !

Best regards,

Alan.

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by Graham Clarke

Only limited time to listen yesterday and unfortunately the same will be true today. 

 

I can't say I really noticed any further improvements yesterday but my head wasn't really in the right place for a full on listening session, so I wouldn't take that as a definitive update!

 

Hopefully more to come in the next few days.

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by Mortalcoil

Great post ..... Congrats

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by 911gt3r
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

Only limited time to listen yesterday and unfortunately the same will be true today. 

 

I can't say I really noticed any further improvements yesterday but my head wasn't really in the right place for a full on listening session, so I wouldn't take that as a definitive update!

 

Hopefully more to come in the next few days.

Well Graham, I am happy to give it a listen for you!  ATB Peter

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by 911gt3r:
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

Only limited time to listen yesterday and unfortunately the same will be true today. 

 

I can't say I really noticed any further improvements yesterday but my head wasn't really in the right place for a full on listening session, so I wouldn't take that as a definitive update!

 

Hopefully more to come in the next few days.

Well Graham, I am happy to give it a listen for you!  ATB Peter

You've got good hearing if you can hear it from your home...

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by 911gt3r
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:
Originally Posted by 911gt3r:
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

Only limited time to listen yesterday and unfortunately the same will be true today. 

 

I can't say I really noticed any further improvements yesterday but my head wasn't really in the right place for a full on listening session, so I wouldn't take that as a definitive update!

 

Hopefully more to come in the next few days.

Well Graham, I am happy to give it a listen for you!  ATB Peter

You've got good hearing if you can hear it from your home...

Yeah Graham, at least my hearing is better than my back. Just a thought sat here under my umbrella outside, I would be able to hear it in MY lounge,  ATB Peter

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by 911gt3r:
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:
Originally Posted by 911gt3r:
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

Only limited time to listen yesterday and unfortunately the same will be true today. 

 

I can't say I really noticed any further improvements yesterday but my head wasn't really in the right place for a full on listening session, so I wouldn't take that as a definitive update!

 

Hopefully more to come in the next few days.

Well Graham, I am happy to give it a listen for you!  ATB Peter

You've got good hearing if you can hear it from your home...

Yeah Graham, at least my hearing is better than my back. Just a thought sat here under my umbrella outside, I would be able to hear it in MY lounge,  ATB Peter

Once it's nicely run in, maybe you should come and hear it in MY lounge

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by 911gt3r

Well Graham, would really love to thank you. You know where I am!  ATB Peter 

Posted on: 13 May 2015 by rackkit
Originally Posted by John Willmott:

 Purely to satisfy my curiosity what is the service interval on the S-1 ?  

 

John

 

Statement is able to service itself.

 

To be honest, i'm surprised that these amps aren't able to be monitored from HQ to make sure they're running at peak performance at all times and any adjustments needed to be done remotely by Naim techs. 

 

 

 

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Focalist
Originally Posted by rackkit:
Originally Posted by John Willmott:

 Purely to satisfy my curiosity what is the service interval on the S-1 ?  

 

John

 

Statement is able to service itself.

 

To be honest, i'm surprised that these amps aren't able to be monitored from HQ to make sure they're running at peak performance at all times and any adjustments needed to be done remotely by Naim techs. 

 

 

 

Don't be daft, they cant even upgrade firmware over the web let alone service kit!

 

I am interested in the thought process behind purchasing a £50k pre-amp to partner with modest equipment, surely a mullet of the highest order? Would similar improvements been gained from investing that money in better speakers / power amps etc instead? Or is the long term goal to have a full statement system then get some better speakers?

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by AussieSteve

Hi Graham, you have an incredible system. I have been a Naimee for just over 12 months now, and went from a small ND5XS/172XS/200 with Chord Chorus/NACA5. I now have CD5XS/NDX/282+2HiCaps/ and bi-amp 200/250.2 with Hi-lines and Chord Signature Tuned Aray, and still NACA5. I use Chord Evo3 Optimum and Voodoo Black Diamond power cords on a dedicated line with Chord Syncro and Sirius powerboard.  JBL S4700 speakers. I didn't realize at first how important high quality cabling was until I splashed out. I get the blackest background and silent running without amp hum (thanks to Syncro). My point to all this is I bought a test mic and program and found my room had many modes and frequency irregularities. I took several months and a HELL of a lot of hard work to build full trapping and resonance gear and now I have a room that allows me to hear every 5Hz increment from 30Hz to 1000Hz without standing waves distorting the sound! Have you considered treating your room? I am lucky I have a spare bedroom that I could use which allowed me to, however if I may suggest you get your room tested and treated, you will hear even More nuances and definition than you would think possible. Have it done professionally though! It is a very difficult and time consuming job, and considering your investment you'll find it worth every penny. All the best mate, again love your passion and system, Steve

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by Focalist:
Originally Posted by rackkit:
Originally Posted by John Willmott:

 Purely to satisfy my curiosity what is the service interval on the S-1 ?  

 

John

 

Statement is able to service itself.

 

To be honest, i'm surprised that these amps aren't able to be monitored from HQ to make sure they're running at peak performance at all times and any adjustments needed to be done remotely by Naim techs. 

 

 

 

Don't be daft, they cant even upgrade firmware over the web let alone service kit!

 

I am interested in the thought process behind purchasing a £50k pre-amp to partner with modest equipment, surely a mullet of the highest order? Would similar improvements been gained from investing that money in better speakers / power amps etc instead? Or is the long term goal to have a full statement system then get some better speakers?

That's a good question... 

 

I've heard an active S800 system powered by 3 NAP500s vs my active S600 system powered by 3 NAP300s.  Both systems used 552 although the S800 system used CD555 with two 555PSes vs NDS with one 555PS for mine.  Clearly the S800 system was better and was very very good. 

 

However, I would say that the sound of my system with Statement pre replacing 552 currently beats the S800 system.  Yes, that is debatable and not everyone would agree, but that is my opinion. 

 

This makes me think that in the really top end systems, the 552 is holding them back, in much the same way that many people are now learning that NAC A5 and Hi-Line was holding their systems back vs Super Lumina.  Source first still applies here!

 

There are other issues too.  While I loved the S800s they would just be too big in my lounge.  Similarly, space constraints would likely prevent me going from NAP300s to NAP500s.

 

 

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by AussieSteve:

Hi Graham, you have an incredible system. I have been a Naimee for just over 12 months now, and went from a small ND5XS/172XS/200 with Chord Chorus/NACA5. I now have CD5XS/NDX/282+2HiCaps/ and bi-amp 200/250.2 with Hi-lines and Chord Signature Tuned Aray, and still NACA5. I use Chord Evo3 Optimum and Voodoo Black Diamond power cords on a dedicated line with Chord Syncro and Sirius powerboard.  JBL S4700 speakers. I didn't realize at first how important high quality cabling was until I splashed out. I get the blackest background and silent running without amp hum (thanks to Syncro). My point to all this is I bought a test mic and program and found my room had many modes and frequency irregularities. I took several months and a HELL of a lot of hard work to build full trapping and resonance gear and now I have a room that allows me to hear every 5Hz increment from 30Hz to 1000Hz without standing waves distorting the sound! Have you considered treating your room? I am lucky I have a spare bedroom that I could use which allowed me to, however if I may suggest you get your room tested and treated, you will hear even More nuances and definition than you would think possible. Have it done professionally though! It is a very difficult and time consuming job, and considering your investment you'll find it worth every penny. All the best mate, again love your passion and system, Steve

Thanks Steve, and looks like you've been enjoying the upgrade trail.

 

If the room containing my hifi was a dedicated room, I would certainly consider that and I suspect you are right that there would be improvements.  But the room's our lounge!  So I do have to consider the sensibilities of such an arrangement.  Also while I must say that my wife is very tolerant to my hifi habit (and she enjoys listening to music too) I think that one might be a step too far

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by The Strat (Fender)
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

Once it's nicely run in, maybe you should come and hear it in MY lounge


Are you going to sell tickets Graham?!!

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Christopher_M
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

There are other issues too.  While I loved the S800s they would just be too big in my lounge.  Similarly, space constraints would likely prevent me going from NAP300s to NAP500s.

Couple of Statement monoblocks look ideal though, ditch the active palava, and think of the cable savings 

 

Chris

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by The Strat (Fender):
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

Once it's nicely run in, maybe you should come and hear it in MY lounge


Are you going to sell tickets Graham?!!

How much do you think I should charge?

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by Christopher_M:
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:

There are other issues too.  While I loved the S800s they would just be too big in my lounge.  Similarly, space constraints would likely prevent me going from NAP300s to NAP500s.

Couple of Statement monoblocks look ideal though, ditch the active palava, and think of the cable savings 

 

Chris

Hmm, so save £15K on cables by spending £98K on power amps.  Let me check but I think there might be a slight flaw there

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by JonR

Congratulations on the acquisition of your new Statement preamp, Graham. You must be very pleased, and I'd certainly hope so after what must have been some considerable raids on the ol' piggy bank... 

 

Your re-arranged system looks very fine in the photo you have posted, though I must admit the singular vertically-aligned Statement unit looks a little incongruous positioned as it is between two weighty Fraim racks of Reference series boxes. I wonder whether Naim have got a matching Statement CD or network player in the works (not to mention the matching power amps which no doubt you will purchase in the fullness of time, I'm sure..........).

 

I do have a little bit of a concern, however...

 

What if the day should come when Naim decides to release a "Statement 2" successor, or somesuch. Might this lead to another post from the likes of Mr Rodborough saying it makes the existing Statement gear sound broken............? 

 

/* Dons flak jacket and hastily exits stage left */

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Focalist
Originally Posted by JonR:

Congratulations on the acquisition of your new Statement preamp, Graham. You must be very pleased, and I'd certainly hope so after what must have been some considerable raids on the ol' piggy bank... 

 

Your re-arranged system looks very fine in the photo you have posted, though I must admit the singular vertically-aligned Statement unit looks a little incongruous positioned as it is between two weighty Fraim racks of Reference series boxes. I wonder whether Naim have got a matching Statement CD or network player in the works (not to mention the matching power amps which no doubt you will purchase in the fullness of time, I'm sure..........).

 

I do have a little bit of a concern, however...

 

What if the day should come when Naim decides to release a "Statement 2" successor, or somesuch. Might this lead to another post from the likes of Mr Rodborough saying it makes the existing Statement gear sound broken............? 

 

/* Dons flak jacket and hastily exits stage left */

That's what I find most amusing / interesting - everything is the best until something else comes along and yet another veil is lifted and more inky blackness discovered. It makes me wonder how anybody can possibly listen to a modest set up it being so veiled and contaminated with noise.......I think far too many superlatives are used when describing the improvements gained with the law of diminishing return.

 

Graham, interesting assessment. I am not sure I would agree but I could not comment until I heard both back to back (unlikely!).

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by AussieSteve
Originally Posted by Graham Clarke:
Originally Posted by AussieSteve:

Hi Graham, you have an incredible system. I have been a Naimee for just over 12 months now, and went from a small ND5XS/172XS/200 with Chord Chorus/NACA5. I now have CD5XS/NDX/282+2HiCaps/ and bi-amp 200/250.2 with Hi-lines and Chord Signature Tuned Aray, and still NACA5. I use Chord Evo3 Optimum and Voodoo Black Diamond power cords on a dedicated line with Chord Syncro and Sirius powerboard.  JBL S4700 speakers. I didn't realize at first how important high quality cabling was until I splashed out. I get the blackest background and silent running without amp hum (thanks to Syncro). My point to all this is I bought a test mic and program and found my room had many modes and frequency irregularities. I took several months and a HELL of a lot of hard work to build full trapping and resonance gear and now I have a room that allows me to hear every 5Hz increment from 30Hz to 1000Hz without standing waves distorting the sound! Have you considered treating your room? I am lucky I have a spare bedroom that I could use which allowed me to, however if I may suggest you get your room tested and treated, you will hear even More nuances and definition than you would think possible. Have it done professionally though! It is a very difficult and time consuming job, and considering your investment you'll find it worth every penny. All the best mate, again love your passion and system, Steve

Thanks Steve, and looks like you've been enjoying the upgrade trail.

 

If the room containing my hifi was a dedicated room, I would certainly consider that and I suspect you are right that there would be improvements.  But the room's our lounge!  So I do have to consider the sensibilities of such an arrangement.  Also while I must say that my wife is very tolerant to my hifi habit (and she enjoys listening to music too) I think that one might be a step too far

No worries mate, your awesome system will deliver the goods regardless. I love reading about someone like you expressing your passion and joy and sharing it with us, thanks mate. Sadly, I have found on every website I have been to that allows a forum like this, little immature boys love to disrespect and challenge the opinions and decisions of others. I have discovered it is usually those types of people who will never actually get to own gear like yours, and they burn inside knowing that is a fact of their lives. Ignore it mate, I read constant comments by fools about Magico or Wilson speakers ect, knowing by their admissions they own $200 speakers and will never attain or appreciate the very best available. You are to be applauded and I am very excited for you. Cheers mate, Steve

Posted on: 14 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by JonR:

Congratulations on the acquisition of your new Statement preamp, Graham. You must be very pleased, and I'd certainly hope so after what must have been some considerable raids on the ol' piggy bank... 

 

Your re-arranged system looks very fine in the photo you have posted, though I must admit the singular vertically-aligned Statement unit looks a little incongruous positioned as it is between two weighty Fraim racks of Reference series boxes. I wonder whether Naim have got a matching Statement CD or network player in the works (not to mention the matching power amps which no doubt you will purchase in the fullness of time, I'm sure..........).

 

I do have a little bit of a concern, however...

 

What if the day should come when Naim decides to release a "Statement 2" successor, or somesuch. Might this lead to another post from the likes of Mr Rodborough saying it makes the existing Statement gear sound broken............? 

 

/* Dons flak jacket and hastily exits stage left */

Bit early for me to be taking about upgrades when my new preamp is only 6 days old

 

I think a Statement CD player is about as likely as me becoming a super model.

 

Posted on: 16 May 2015 by Graham Clarke

So, I'm just over a week in now.  What have I learnt?  Well, primarily that to say Statement is better than <x> piece of kit in one area would be wholly simplistic.

 

It betters lesser pre-amps (yes 552, I'm looking at you) in all areas: detail, sound stage, low distortion even at high volumes (no longer tiring or a reason to generate a grimace) and fuller bodied.

 

While listening last night a few thoughts came to me.  "Why use one note when three will do?".  On certain electronic instruments you can hear that a note isn't at a constant tone, there is often a degree of frequency oscillation which is accurately captured by S1 and missed by others.  Never noticed that before.

 

Another thought was of comparing S1/552 to fine red wines.  People sometimes describe red wines as being "full bodied" or "heavier" than others.  That analogy applies here too, with a richness to music that makes 552 sound lean, or dare Ieven say it, thin? 

 

Pick out an instrument and follow it all the way through the piece, regardless of what else is going on, nothing phases it.  Follow the delicacy of a triangle despite an onslaught of a powerful bass guitar or the heavy duty thump of a large drum, never losing track of it.

 

Immerse yourself in the soundstage of the room, being able to spatially place each instrument and gain an insight into the room size. 

 

Hear the emotion put into lyrics which I think is aided by the BMRs not having a cross over right in this frequency range.  Really understand the story that the artist is portraying through their words.

 

All of these things allow you to connect to the music in a way that just wasn't possible previously.

 

One thing that I have noticed is that as time progresses, my memory of the 552 sound fades, replaced by that of S1.  That's bitter sweet to me, as this means that the Statement performance is becoming the norm and might eventually even be taken for granted.  Experiencing the wonder of hearing a new perspective on a well known piece of music and getting goose bumps from it is part of the upgrade experience and probably is part of the reason we all get drawn into upgrade-itis. 

 

I know that this transition over time is inevitable and that I am incredibly lucky to be able to own this pre amp but do wish the feeling could be more enduring, less fleeting.  However, despite being one week in I'm sure that the burn in is still far from complete and it is yet to yield more of its secrets.  I'm also sure I'll enjoy witnessing the reaction of other enthusiasts who hear it for the first time.

 

Work commitments mean I'll be out of the country for six days so likely little more in the way of progress updates for a while.  However that does mean that my wife gets to play with it during my absence!  Upon return it will be fun to understand how much it has changed in those few days.

 

Posted on: 16 May 2015 by Darke Bear

Interesting Graham. I find as we upgrade and improve our systems I personally recalibrate to the new presentation over a period of a few days or so of use and it then becomes 'normal'.

 

I remember many decades ago a friend tried a NAP160 instead of his NAD3020; he said there was not a large difference, then went back to the NAD and was shocked at how poor it was and then acquired his own Naim very shortly after. It can be difficult to go back once we even subliminally begin to experience something better. Intellect will say 'not a lot of difference' whist the inner-person is screaming 'yes there is' - he usually wins if he can divert the money from the grasp on the intellectual man.

 

DB.

Posted on: 16 May 2015 by Graham Clarke
Originally Posted by Darke Bear:

Interesting Graham. I find as we upgrade and improve our systems I personally recalibrate to the new presentation over a period of a few days or so of use and it then becomes 'normal'.

 

I remember many decades ago a friend tried a NAP160 instead of his NAD3020; he said there was not a large difference, then went back to the NAD and was shocked at how poor it was and then acquired his own Naim very shortly after. It can be difficult to go back once we even subliminally begin to experience something better. Intellect will say 'not a lot of difference' whist the inner-person is screaming 'yes there is' - he usually wins if he can divert the money from the grasp on the intellectual man.

 

DB.

Apparently people often fall into one of two groups.  Those who notice the improvement when a clearly better piece of equipment is used and those who notice the "loss" when the old piece is reinstalled.

 

Both were dead obvious going 552 -> S1 -> 552!