n-Serve and n-Stream with NDX + Unitiserve

Posted by: KRM on 30 April 2011

I'm sure this is a stupid question but...



If you have a Unitiserve serving an NDX can you control what you're listening to via the n-Serve app? I am aware that n-Stream controls the NDX, buut can either be used?















It seems a pointless question, but I the Serve app is quicker and has greater functionality, including playback of playlists. Frustratingly, neither can create playlists (I think) and it is the 'on-the-fly' playlist creation which is one of the more attractive aspects of the Chorus DS App for Linn streamers. I guess we just have to wait until Naim catch up?















Keith
Posted on: 30 April 2011 by KRM
Ps sorry about the massive gaps between paragraphs, but this is my first attempt at creating a topic and the edit text is a bit mad (on iPad, at least)!
Posted on: 30 April 2011 by BigH47
Originally Posted by KRM:
Ps sorry about the massive gaps between paragraphs, but this is my first attempt at creating a topic and the edit text is a bit mad (on iPad, at least)!

 

Good to see the forum improving slowly NOT.  Good to see it still doesn't work ithings. Also it seems that bold cannot be removed once started.

 

Still only a short time since inception, can't rush these things eh?

Posted on: 30 April 2011 by KRM
Thanks Allen,

You've confirmed what I already suspected.

You're coments on the My proposed solution are interesting. My original intention was to connect the Userve to the NDAC via SPDIF but we have spent two days listening to various combinations and NDX via UPNP into the DAC was best. I'm getting the Unitiserve because I'm lazy/stupid and like the Naim ripping solution. The alternative is to get the laptop, wait for it to boot up and connect to the net (Vista, arrgh!), connect it to an ethernet cable (I'm told wireless won't do, it's cetainly slow), open EAC and rip the CD followed by farting around with Media Monkey for Artwork. Respect to those who are prepared to do this but I like the idea of a reliable, compatable box which is always on. If this is really the end of CD it has to be easy if dullards like me are going to join in!

The Unitiserve definitely sounded inferior to the NDX via SPDIF. My dealer has been told by Naim that the digital out on the Unitiserve is 'not audiophile standard' and it certainly sounded inferior when we heard it. This was not what I had expected, as I had believed that DACs and power supplies where key to sound quality.

Keith
Posted on: 30 April 2011 by Tog
Use a MacBook Pro and ditch Vista - no more waiting. I realise that UPnP can be a pain in the neck but whatever Naim have done to their streamers it certainly sounds good. I love the idea of storing music on a server hidden away from view and keeping the number of boxes to a minimum. Tog
Posted on: 30 April 2011 by Aleg
Or use Windows7 which is also much, much faster than Vista if you don't want to move to Apple products (which I certainly wouldn't).
Posted on: 01 May 2011 by KRM
Hi Allen,



I totally agree. If I had a study with a PC permanently on and wired to the network it might be different. But I don't, I have couple of laptops which are used wirelessly and an iPad which is used for 90% of non-work related duties. I also rather like feeding CDs into the Unitiserve. It's strangely satisfying!



The Unitiserve will be away from the hi fi, but in the same room. At the demo I only noticed the noise when it was ripping. I don't have room on my rack and I'm also a little dubious about having a switch mode power supply right next to the rest of the system. I already a My Book World Nas but I may get the dealer to fit a dedicated Nas as well. I guess I could get it converted later?



The n-Stream is a pain and I suppose we'll just have to be patient. The lack of playlist support is particularly annoying as is the need to lumber up and down the menus, rather than jumping to the screen you want.



Keith
Posted on: 01 May 2011 by Tog
N-Stream is not perfect and  like Allen I've been pretty critical of it in the past but it is still the best UPnP CP out there.



Remote has advantages but the time lag / rescan on my system is not too bad. My main concern is the speed of improvement.



Cached library tree

Playlists

Random play



Come on TJ - a comment?



Tog

Posted on: 01 May 2011 by KRM
I'm afraid it's true. I got to play with it when I was comparing the NDX to the Akurate. The Chorus DS is much better. I ignored this as I assume Naim will catch up.



Keith
Posted on: 01 May 2011 by Tog
Should have said "for Naim owners"  .... Haven't had any luck so far with Chorus.





Tog
Posted on: 01 May 2011 by DQ

Allen,

 

Just to join in on your bandwagon. The n-stream is a disgrace. Clunky, ugly and lacking in basic information.Never mind the issues with playlist creation.

 

The only good things that I can say for it is that it is free and the volume control works just fine. Better than itunes remote.

 

I have to believe this is 101 version software!

 

Cheers, David

 

Posted on: 01 May 2011 by KRM
I've just re-read the n-Stream/Serve web-chat to see what was actually said about n-Stream. It's a bit tricky as the two apps tend to get mixed up. However, I think that Tom said:

-  They are ' working towards' plalists on the fly and have 'taken note' that people want it and agree that it would be valuable, but it's tricky with UPNP;

-   They are looking into speeding up UPNP and a home button might creep in (in response to Allen's comment that it's annoying that you have to go through numerous screns to perform frequently used functions;

-   The 'visual flair' issue was not conceded.

It is worrying that they are so non-commital about n-Stream when they are promising playlists and metadata editing in the next release of n-Serve. Why is it so difficult if the Chorus DS was put together on by one person? Are there problems with Naims's streaming architectecture which make it difficult to achieve basic functions that most would regard as essential? Or am I over reacting?



Keith
Posted on: 01 May 2011 by Tog
Chorus DS is developed outside of Linn and so the developer doesn't have to share the company mindset. Linn have developed Kinsky but choose UPnP so that they could avoid software development and concentrate on the hardware. Naim want Stream/Serve to share the company's obsessive focus on brand image and are far more controlling. As a result Naim becomes part software developer and the development times are stupidly long.



Tog
Posted on: 01 May 2011 by KRM
Is there anything to stop Chorus creating a Naim app? I know Songbook have had a go, but I understand it's rubbish. I assume this is still the case?



I don't mind waiting if Naim eventually come up with something tasty, or at least fit for purpose.



Keith
Posted on: 02 May 2011 by Tog

Still waiting for a comment Naim - anything?

 

Tog

Posted on: 02 May 2011 by KRM
I have emailed my dealer asking them to ask Naim. I will call them during the week for an update. I've ordered the NDX, but it's not too late for second thoughts if Naim can't provide any reassurance. I'll keep the CDX2 (and the money) until these products are genuinely ready. I'm sure it'll be fine though!



Keith
Posted on: 02 May 2011 by Peter_RN

Hi Chaps

 

I have been following the thread with interest although I do not use wireless, so use neither app.

 

However, whilst not wishing to divert the thread thought it might be of interest to you to know that it is equally problematic in trying to use a computer based CP to send music to the Qute.

 

Having tried both Kinsky and Asset CP’s over several months now, they have proved to be totally unreliable in operation, working for a while before locking up, usually after 2 – 3 tracks. Foobar has also been tried. All have been pointed at the DNLA server on my NAS.

 

I don’t think that Naim will be doing anything to address this problem.

 

Sorry for the diversion pure frustration. Now where’s that remote, Kinsky has just stopped AGAIN!

 

Peter

 

PS Thanks to Linn for attempting to make Kinsky compatible, there was no commercial reason I can think of why they should have.    

Posted on: 04 February 2012 by Pterodactyl

I have very recently bought an HDX and find the n-serve app very useful. Even more recently, I have been looking at the NDX, but like many others submitting here, find the n-stream nowhere near as good. I do not want to lose the user friendliness of n-serve. Would Naim develop a hybrid perhaps?

Posted on: 04 February 2012 by luka
Yep I'm very happy with SQ of my recent HDX & find the n-serve app excellent & yes can also access stuff on my computer !!