Room treatment using plants.

Posted by: CharlieP on 10 November 2015

I posted this on HH's "socks" thread, but thought it worthy of a tangent discussion.  I am curious to know if others have tried this.

 

Spurred by one of Huge's room treatment threads, and a discussion with joerand, I got to thinking about acoustic room treatment to address an issue with the sound of my system.  In this thread I am not talking about bass issues or room modes, but higher frequencies where midrange and treble reflections can compete with first arrival sound.  My speakers sit out in the room, 63 inches (1.6m) from the back wall and 54 inches (0.61m) from the fireplace.  The first reflection off the fireplace is delayed about 7 to 8 m-sec.  (close to Haas effect limit).  I felt I needed to absorb or diffuse the first reflection from the speakers off the brick fireplace behind.

 

As a quick experiment, I grabbed three bed pillows and hung them from the mantel.  This did not look so good, but my wonderful wife tolerated them temporarily as an experiment.  The improvement in sound was not profound, but it was significant enough that i did not want to remove the pillows.  They remained for a few weeks, and were in place when I hosted a local forum gathering.  Finally, I had to replace them with something more aesthetically pleasing, but what?

 

I placed tall plants between each speaker and the fireplace, so as to diffuse the sound which would otherwise reflect towards the listener, as you can see in the photo:

 

P1070461 

  

To my delight, the plants were even more effective than the pillows.  These were quickly relocated from elsewhere in the room, so I plan to replace the one on the right with another palm to approach symmetry.  But I consider this to be a very affordable "acoustic room treatment" which noticeably improves the sound field.  I hear notes decay into the recorded venue more clearly, as if some muddling "noise" were removed.  I recommend this approach as an affordable and domestically acceptable approach to room treatment for taming mid-to-treble reflections.

 

Charlie

Posted on: 12 November 2015 by Jan-Erik Nordoen
Originally Posted by likesmusic:

Fair enough CharlieP,  I didn't know about the backwards facing tweeter! 

It's not just the backwards facing tweeter, there is also refraction of sound waves from the front of the speaker baffle that are reflected off the wall behind the speakers.

Posted on: 12 November 2015 by CharlieP
Originally Posted by Naim Gary:

Charlie, as always I love your takes on things and your "old engineering chops" brought to bear on this thing we love so much - home reproduction of music. It is amazing to see that you have already changed some things in your listening room just since we had our Seattle Naim Forum meet up.

 

Along with doing some system upgrades I am now looking at redoing our small living room and all these thoughts and ideas are really helpful as I start to think about how to improve my room both acoustically as well as aesthetically.

 

Keep the good experimentation and reporting of results coming.

 

Gary

Thanks, Gary.  

 

These plants work so well, I am amazed that this has not long been standard practice, and a feature of every dealer's showroom.

 

I actually made some other improvements as well.  I hope you have the vinyl spinning again.  Will catch up later.

 

Charlie