New SuperUnity - disappointed and unsure what to expect ...

Posted by: René4HiFi on 30 December 2015

Dear all,

two weeks ago I bought a new SU to replace my old HiFi installation. To give you an idea: it was all Luxman with a very good amp and CD-player and in combination with B&W P6 it produced a wonderfull, moving sound.

When buying the SU, the Naim dealer (in Düsseldorf, Germany) already pointed out that it would take some time for the SU to break in. When playing the first CD-rips (FLAC, no compression, via WiFi from a NAS) I was positively surprised by the better spatial distribution (3D) and detailedness of the sound when compared to my previous setup.

However - I was not "moved" by the sound: the bass is too far in the background, voices are less "full", violins are not "warm"...

I am wondering whether in time these "findings" will improve. When the SU in time only will open up more (what I found in this forum, and what I expect is related to the spatial distribution) that would not solve my findings as mentioned above.

What should I do ? Should I wait (for how long ?), should I use the WAVE-format, or should I look for another installation ? I really hope for the SU to gain more "warmth" and bring the "moving sound" ...

I look forward to your comments and recommendations. Thanks !

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Goon525

It's really hard to put oneself in your position. I've owned a SU for three and a half years, and been very happy with it. I don't recognise your criticisms - but that doesn't make them any less valid for you! None of us will be familiar with your old system, so it's hard to make a comparison. After a couple of weeks (assuming kept switched on) it should really be delivering say 95% of its ultimate performance, so maybe it's faulty - or just not for you for some reason. Are you still using the B&W speakers?

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Silence Kills

Try to switch to "Floating Ground" on the back of your SU.

Rethink the position of your speakers. Even after one of the last software updates for the SU, I had the need to re-position my speakers slightly.

Keep the SU switched on.

Try to switch from Wifi to Ethernet.

Speakers cables can make a difference. The most expensive is not necessarily the best. Borrow a NAC-A5 from your dealer if you didn't already try one.

 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by René4HiFi

Hello,

thanks for your quick reply. I will follow-up your tips to see whether it brings an improvement. The B&W speakers are still in use - I do not think that they cause the issue.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by skipper44

I travel a lot and after returning from each trip it takes a day and a half of gradually increasing volume before the whole rig is singing spirited and free, both SuperU and Totem Model One Signature speakers being big on the run-in thing.

For the sake of churning your perceptions, try using decentish USB DAC (maybe you have one, maybe on loan) into a SU analogue input. Another sound altogether - I wouldn't be surprised if you can't say if it's better or worse - different, it is in emphases, and different emphases there definitely are.

Also during this burn in period of half convincedness, you may like to introduce yourself to some of that HD material, sort of distract yourself while serious transformations are underway in the silicon based innards of the beautiful black box. After that you will likely find yourself re-enchanted by some of your existing discs in 16/44.1.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Zipperheadbanjo

I'm not familiar with your old gear, but you moved from separates to a one box solution... depending on the quality of your old gear you may be giving something up in making the switch. Did you demo the SU first and compare it to your other gear first?

Also... as stated above... you definitely want to use a wired connection as opposed to wifi... and burn in can take a month or longer.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by hungryhalibut

I'd suggest, as well as sorting out a wired connection, that you set your upnp server to transcode from FLAC to WAV. Just in case you don't know, this process converts the file to WAV as you play it, and leaves the original as FLAC. You should find that it gives a nicer sound. 

I'm intrigued that you find the SU to lack warmth and bass. If anything, its sound leans in a warm direction and there is certainly plenty of bass. 

This may sound silly, but your speakers are wired in phase, aren't they?

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by hafler3o

It seems to me to be differences in presentation, the Luxman kit (I have owned one of their TTs) might be over-warm and wooly to some ears. The music not moving you is a bit worrying, adjusting to a new presentation (spatially or tonally) can be distracting and remove you from the 'suspension of disbelief'.

 

You do realise your mind will take some time to be 'broken in' so keep it switched on, no 'traumen'!

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by David Hendon

HH's last question seems to me particularly relevant because, as he no doubt also thinks, your description does sound rather like your speakers are out of phase.

i have a SuperUniti in my study and it sounds wonderful.....

best

David

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by blythe

I'm a SuperUniti user here and it certainly moves me.
However, I've been used to the "Naim sound" for many years and the speed & tightness of the bass might be perceived as "lacking" if you're more used to a fuller (usually slower & woolier) presentation.
However, vocals on Naim are one thing that always excel, often giving the impression that the singer is right there in the room, very realistic, so I'm surprised to read that observation.
I'm currently using Neat Elite SX loudspeakers connected using Naim NACA5 cables.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Adam Zielinski

My SU took about 1 month of normal use to break in.

Some tips on sound improvements after 1 year with my SU

* Power cable - it does make a difference. Experiment there I ended up with MIT Magnum. Enerr Violet works well too.

* Speaker cables - less critical, but important

* Glass shelf - far superior than anything else for placement. It opens up the sound.

* Speaker positioning - critical. NAIMs have a specifc way of presenting a sound stage and you need to get there.

Also what you may percieve as a lack of bass, is that suddenly you actually have a lot of mid-range like vocals that suddenly jumped into focus. Bass is there - trust me I play a bass guitar and that is the first thing I listen for / to.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Silence Kills

Glass shelf? Interesting. Currently my SU resides on a metal shelf. Should I try to change the shelf? Does it really make a difference in sound?

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Adam Zielinski

As with anything - do experiment.

I had my local specialist hi-fi rack builder make me some glass shelves, in the exact  size and thicknes as the Fraim shelves. If you have a look at the pic in my profile you will understand what I mean. 

I then put the shelves on some VibraPods. Once I heard what it did to my main system, I tested one of the shelves under my Super Uniti - a transformation ))

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Borders Nick

I've had my SU since Oct - although it was an ex-demo , I don't believe it had many hours of usage.  It sounded wonderful straight away (upgrade from Unitilite) with ample but not overpowering bass.  I'm using B&W 683S2 with inexpensive Chord Odyssey cables.  Its currently connected through wifi as opposed to Ethernet (I did experiment with cable but couldn't discern any difference).  It sits on a wooden shelf unit  (but this thread has got me thinking).  

Transcoding to WAV made it sound even better.  

Apart from transcoding I'm doing everything else "wrong" and it still sounds great, with plenty of warmth.

Maybe you should continue the burn-in for another couple of weeks and if still not happy seek advice from your dealer.

 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Adam Zielinski
Borders Nick posted:

Its currently connected through wifi as opposed to Ethernet (I did experiment with cable but couldn't discern any difference).

 

Did you manage to stream high-res (above 96kHz / 24 bit) via WiFi?

Mine was too unstable so a cable was an only option for me.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Borders Nick

Coincidentally, I tried a 96kHz / 24 bit file for the first time tonight out of curiosity (A free download from Naim Label site - Neil Cowley Trio - Wallflower). It plays perfectly.  I'm just using the  ISP supplied modem/router with a TP-link booster.  I may experiment with more files.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Adam Zielinski

Neil Cowley Trio - have few of their albums. Good stuff!

Posted on: 31 December 2015 by René4HiFi

First of all - thank you all for your quick and well thought tips and advice - it is highly appreciated !

After some minor changes to power- and speaker cable routing (taking them away from each other as far as possible) I found the "culprit": switching the selector to "Floating Ground" did the trick ! I could not believe the difference - natural sounding voices, beautiful warm violins, clearer bass were the result. The first 5 minutes I had goose bumps on my arms, tremors running down my spine and a smile from ear to ear. Man, what a SOUND !

I will continue optimizing the setting: the suggestion regarding speaker position, power cable and glass shelves are interesting options to pursue. The change of sound to a more transparent "picture" logically results in a less "woolly" character of the sound, however that is something that is more related to what you are used to instead, and definitely is a result of a higher quality system.

Thanks again to all - I wish you a happy and euphonious 2016 !

Posted on: 31 December 2015 by Adam Zielinski

Welcome to THE sound

Happy 2016!

Posted on: 31 December 2015 by blythe

Fantastic outcome! Happy New Year 

Posted on: 01 January 2016 by hungryhalibut

Who would have thought that the ground switch would make so much difference? I'm so pleased that the sound is now so much better.  Well done. 

Posted on: 01 January 2016 by René4HiFi

Just for the record: my power socket does not have any grounding. That might be of influence when switching the selector at the back of the SU: in case you use a power socket with grounding already, the significant sound improvement I mentioned above might not be effectuated at all.