Just for the Record

Posted by: Don Atkinson on 30 December 2015

Just for the Record

"Just for the Record".....I'm sure there is a Pun in there somewhere

Has anybody figured out how this ranking system actually works ?

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Minh Nguyen

Forum rank is based on quantitative metrics and does not necessarily provide an indication of the qualitative aspects

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
Minh Nguyen posted:

Forum rank is based on quantitative metrics and does not necessarily provide an indication of the qualitative aspects

I'm devastated !

But what might those quantitative metric be ? Does anybody know ?

And are we sure they're not subjective ?

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Minh Nguyen

The more a member posts, the higher their rank

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by sheffieldgraham

And what's the point of it?  Just asking.

Is it a ploy to massage one's ego (I'm top man) in order to generate activity?

I'm not criticising the forum contributors, but questioning the people who instigated it.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson

That's a good question Graham. Might encourage undesirables to leave or even sell up and move on ?

Richard wasn't able to explain how it worked when it first came on board with Hoopla. And it seems even he can't switch it off, even though it doesn't seem to serve any known purpose!

We used to have "Karma" levels when Adam was around, so the concept of "Ranking" has been with us for some time.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Mike-B
It seems a load of dangly bits with not much math or logic involved,  no wonder Richard can't work it out  
..........   Just a quick check shows  
Don with 73,558 points with a community rank @  #12.  
Hook has 72,481 points & rank @ #8
I have 71,019 points & rank @ #10
Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Richard Dane

Still haven't figured it out...

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
Richard Dane posted:

Still haven't figured it out...

You looked rather hansom way back then Richard

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by hungryhalibut

Like a cab. 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by MDS

Just guessing, but I suspect the calculation gives a higher weighting to more recent activity so some 'old' activity points don't count as heavily as 'newer' activity points.

Mike

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by MDS
Hungryhalibut posted:

Like a cab. 

BTW is that a sneaky picture of a prototype 'Statement' streamer?

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by hungryhalibut

That white thing could be the new MegaLumina interconnect, with massaging by hand rather than being entrusted to the Snaic Shaker. 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
Hungryhalibut posted:

Like a cab. 

At first glance I mis-read your "cab"

The forum's spell-checker isn't very good today..........but I'll leave the goof in place, otherwise your comment won't mean much.............

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by hungryhalibut

Few of my comments mean much, so I doubt anyone would notice. 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
MDS posted:

Just guessing, but I suspect the calculation gives a higher weighting to more recent activity so some 'old' activity points don't count as heavily as 'newer' activity points.

Mike

I think it gives higher weighting to posts by newer members but doesn't reflect this in the Points Score.

I think it also takes account of "Likes" and "Followers" etc again, without this being reflected in the Points

I also think you get Mega-points for saying just how TERRIFIC Hoopla is

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by rjstaines

This looks a lot like the first computer I worked with all those years ago.

Mind you, this one is more advanced - its program is entered by reading the Super Lumia loop (aka punched tape), whereas mine was programmed using wires plugged into a board. 

It makes me wonder how many living rooms the electronics in my Naim server would have taken up back then.  Kinda glad no-one had figured out how to digitise sound yet... life was so simple... all I aspired to was a tin of good quality needles for my phonograph. 

 

PS - I think Hoopla is TERRIFIC

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
rjstaines posted:

This looks a lot like the first computer I worked with all those years ago.

Mind you, this one is more advanced - its program is entered by reading the Super Lumia loop (aka punched tape), whereas mine was programmed using wires plugged into a board. 

It makes me wonder how many living rooms the electronics in my Naim server would have taken up back then.  Kinda glad no-one had figured out how to digitise sound yet... life was so simple... all I aspired to was a tin of good quality needles for my phonograph. 

 

PS - I think Hoopla is TERRIFIC

We used punched cards to start with. Punching each rectangle with a prodder. Punched tape followed and seemed a luxury ! We (Nottingham University) shared a KDF9 ? computer with Manchester running a code called Fortran ? No Microsoft or Word or Excel or internet - just write your own program.............

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
sheffieldgraham posted:

And what's the point of it?  Just asking.

Is it a ploy to massage one's ego (I'm top man) in order to generate activity?

I'm not criticising the forum contributors, but questioning the people who instigated it.

What did you have to do Graham, to get your avatar to appear at the top of the "Current Visitors" gallery ?

Mine used to be somewhere on the gallery, but unless there are fewer than about 50 visitors, it can't be detected. Even then, it's at the end of the list !

I am really upset .......................

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Don Atkinson
Mike-B posted:
It seems a load of dangly bits with not much math or logic involved,  no wonder Richard can't work it out  
..........   Just a quick check shows  
Don with 73,558 points with a community rank @  #12.  
Hook has 72,481 points & rank @ #8
I have 71,019 points & rank @ #10

It just doesn't seem fair, does it Mike

...with many thanks to our feathered friend...........

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Romi

I was looking down the list and the name Naim Nymph stands out.  Is the person behind the name Naim Nymph  actually a female?  I hope so, its nice to have a female amongst us in this sad male oriented hobby.  

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Steve J

Naim nymph is indeed female, a lovely lady called Debs. 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Hook

72,480 points for sale to the highest bidder!  No reserve!  Free shipping!  

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Tony2011

Oh, dear. This just gets sadder and sadder year after year.

...and where is me CBE, OBE, BBC, ITV?

Does anybody really care? 

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by Loki

Mornington Crescent.

Posted on: 30 December 2015 by TOBYJUG

OBE = Oozing with Bovine Energy.