Inky blackness...

Posted by: hungryhalibut on 30 March 2016

...is one of those odd terms one reads in Hifi reviews, along with all sorts of claptrap that can be dismissed as having little to do with the enjoyment of music - something for the round earth Hifi lover rather than the flat earthers raised on Linn and Naim in the 80s.

However, since getting my DR amplifier and Super Lumina wires I have come to really appreciate it. The way notes emerge from silence, and music ends with that same silence, is most beguiling. I remember seeing the Hilliard Ensemble and Jan Garbarek in Chichester Cathedral, and being entranced by the way the music emerged from complete stillness, yet at home somehow there was a fug around the music so that it was never quite the same.

Somehow the new Naim stuff seems to be able to do this, and in a way that enhances enjoyment of the music while preserving the involvement and joie de vivre that Naim does so well. 

I never thought I'd say this, but hurrah for inky blackness!

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by The Strat (Fender)
Hungryhalibut posted:

I remember seeing the Hilliard Ensemble and Jan Garbarek in Chichester Cathedral, and being entranced by the way the music emerged from complete stillness, yet at home somehow there was a fug around the music so that it was never quite the same.

Somehow the new Naim stuff seems to be able to do this, and in a way that enhances enjoyment of the music while preserving the involvement and joie de vivre that Naim does so well. 

I never thought I'd say this, but hurrah for inky blackness!

Amen.

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by ken c

may i join you in the "inky blackness" claptrap brigade? 

doesnt matter about round vs flat earth -- just need to make sure its all earthed properly (ooops!)

enjoy..

ken

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Stephen Pritchard

Amen amen ...

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Dr_J

HH, but is it the SL's or the DR.......?

Given my, much less sophisticated, experience with my SU and 200, I, like you, somewhat surprisedly, agree with the 'inky blackness' statement, albeit perhaps a slightly different shade.

The puzzling thing is though that I perceived said inky blackness to become more apparent in a bi-wired configuration........?

KR to all,

J

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Got Hi-Fi?

I have noticed this same "inky blackness" as you call it when switching from my previous gear to my 202/HCDR. It is one of the things I love about my naim set up. 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Harty601

Nigel - scientific studies commissioned and payed for by the EU have shown a direct correlation between the darkness of the ink and the blackness of the black, compared to the amount of movement during a (repeated) head nod, peak distance from toe to floor and the level of approving look on the listeners face.

And people say our money is wasted being part of the EU 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Finkfan

And all at EU recommended safe listening volumes of course! 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by wenger2015

 

EU health and safety regulations require , that you can see clearly through the inky blackness

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by hungryhalibut

When my sons were small, they used to love watching The Blobs on TV. The best Blob was Inky Black, the scary witch...

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Finkfan

Inky blackness sounds like the name of a band.....

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by GraemeH
Hungryhalibut posted:

When my sons were small, they used to love watching The Blobs on TV. The best Blob was Inky Black, the scary witch...

Don't they make Audio Cables...known for their inky blackness?

G

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by wenger2015
Hungryhalibut posted:

When my sons were small, they used to love watching The Blobs on TV. The best Blob was Inky Black, the scary witch...

Where did you get the picture of my mother in law? 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Mayor West

Definitely enhances the enjoyment / involvement for me. Well worth the appreciation! 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Tabby cat

The Inky blackness or lower noise floor must be an important consideration in amp design. Also the timbre of instruments, separation,image,prat.

I suppose it's like baking a cake amp design....but the Inky blackness is an essential ingredient in the bake.Would love to know what journalist first penned those words.Maybe if he visits this forum he will remember with a smile on his face......maybe he's dead and joined the Inky blackness !

Glad the Ink is doing its stuff in your system Hungry Halibet

 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Bert Schurink

So I have to conclude that your set sounded broken before you had dr and sl...., which would require besides a lamp also a safety helmet...

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by ken c

watch out folks, there are in fact different shades of 'inky blackness' 

enjoy

ken

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by George F

Surely the only sonic inky blackness that actually exists is that found in a vacuum?

Every concert venue and recording studio is subject to some ambient noise from heating systems and air conditioning, to traffic noise from aeroplanes, trains, and motor vehicles, and even people walking about in the same building.

I have the idea that there is something wrong with any replay system that produces inly blackness - sonically speaking - between the musical notes.

Best wishes from George

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by ken c
George Fredrik Fiske posted:

....

Every concert venue and recording studio is subject to some ambient noise from heating systems and air conditioning, to traffic noise from aeroplanes, trains, and motor vehicles, and even people walking about in the same building.

 

and "inky blackness" allows this ambient noise to come through and be heard clearly in replay.. 

enjoy...

ken

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by George F

But the normal ambience has been well relayed in recordings and replay for more than fifty years. It is simply called accuracy and is nothing new. 

In fact recordings have captured - at their best - very convincing ambience for the last eighty years since the introduction of the electronic microphone to the recording process.

So if we are discussing low system generated noise we looking at very old news at least from the best recordings and replay.

Best wishes from George

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Belfast Taxman

Anyone watching Horizon on BBC2 this evening (available on catch up) will perhaps reclassify "inky blackness" as a form of "dark energy", not to be confused with "dark matter", that is an integral part of the accelerating expansion of the universe. None of the clever astrophysicists on the programme could actually explain what it was, so I reckon Hungry Halibut could be on the way to a Nobel Prize. Going back to the early 1980's, when I was a Saturday shop boy in Moseley Audio ( Birmingham), the boss of this very fine Linn/Naim dealer, now long gone, used to try and explain that the difference between such a fine system and other hi- fi was " the silence between the notes". Is this the same thing, I wonder.

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Massimo Bertola
George Fredrik Fiske posted:

I have the idea that there is something wrong with any replay system that produces inly blackness - sonically speaking - between the musical notes.

George, it may be so, but I think that the 'culprit' is not the system but, possibly, software employed by the recording company/studio to eliminate that ambient noise.. The same as they eliminate sometimes the 'silent' moments between movements of a symphony. I have a demo CD by Harmonia Mundi where an orchestral piece is digitally muted so abruptly after the last note's very short echo, that it's weird to the ears.

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by MarkJH

Belfast Taxman, would the shop you refer to be Sound Advice/Sound Control? 

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by George F

I agree that some digital transfers have alarmingly short reverberation after the last note, but this not new.

On tape the attenuating slider went down fast to avoid studio noises off at the end of a “take", and on 78s they simply turned the signal off. 

Recording is not always that very naturalistic ...

Even the best of them ...

Best wishes from George

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Belfast Taxman
MarkJH posted:

Belfast Taxman, would the shop you refer to be Sound Advice/Sound Control? 

Mark - I think you might be right, it was in Moseley village on the Alcester Road next door to A well known supermarket. Such a long time ago.

Posted on: 30 March 2016 by Chris Dolan
MarkJH posted:

Belfast Taxman, would the shop you refer to be Sound Advice/Sound Control? 

I bought my first Naim amps from there