Wot to do next?

Posted by: Mark430 on 10 September 2016

Hi all, 

I'm not a frequent poster here, but I do keep an eye on what's going on. The last major change to my system was SBL to S400, and I have been fairly settled with the sound over the last couple of years. Recently though, I have started looking for more... Let's say more of everything but in particular, more prat, clarity, more agility and outright extension in the bass. I've done all I can with room treatment and mains. 552 is a little out of my scope financially. Of course I will seek out some demos as and when, but interested to hear where some of you would go from here - swap 52 for 252? DR for SC and 300? Super Lumina? Am I at the limit with the S400?  im assuming active is still not an option for them?

NDS 555DR / 52 / olive SC / 300 / nac a5 / S400 / power lines/ Isoblue / dedicated mains cu/ room treatment 

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by hungryhalibut

If I had your system (I sort of did once, with a CDS3, 555PS, 252, 300) I'd save a little harder, bite the bullet, and get a used 552, which is also what I did. Yes, DRing the 300 would make a difference, yes SL leads would be good, and the 252 might be a little better than than 52, though I doubt you'd really notice, but the 552 will transform everything. Goodness knows whether it will give you all that Hifi stuff you mention, but what it will do is give you a level of communication with the music beyond your dreams. 

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by Adam Zielinski

I will comment on S400s, since HH extensively covered the rest.
You are definitely not at a limit with them... Fantastic speakers, can handle pretty much anything. They are blindingly fast to respond to music changes - it would be difficult to find equally good speakers for the money.

As to SuperLumina: they simply disapear in the system.

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by Ron Brinsdon

Hello Mark,

I was at Midland Audio in Belbroughton last week having some work done on the LP12 and took the opportunity to look around and hear a few tunes.

I was listening (for longer than I realised) to some Boenicke W8 speakers and had I not just spent a considerable amount on having my SL2's repaired then I really would have put them on the home trial list.

John is a Naim dealer so will know how they would fit in with your system - he would probably replicate it in the shop except for the Ovators.

Maybe next weeks show will turn up some suggestions.

Ron

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by MDS
Hungryhalibut posted:

If I had your system (I sort of did once, with a CDS3, 555PS, 252, 300) I'd save a little harder, bite the bullet, and get a used 552, which is also what I did. Yes, DRing the 300 would make a difference, yes SL leads would be good, and the 252 might be a little better than than 52, though I doubt you'd really notice, but the 552 will transform everything. Goodness knows whether it will give you all that Hifi stuff you mention, but what it will do is give you a level of communication with the music beyond your dreams. 

Good advice here.  

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by The Strat (Fender)

Lovely looking system can't comment on the 400s so in reality the only real upgrade is 552.  Don't demo if you ace no intention of buying!

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by elkman70

Great system already. My advice would be a 552. Well worth it.

Regards,

Nick

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by Chris Dolan

I would support the 552 axis but what interconnect are you using on the NDS? If HiLine you could try an alternative here - applying source first logic. 

Posted on: 10 September 2016 by yeti42

The logic is inescapable. 552

 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Mark430

Thanks to all for your feedback, very much appreciated. I never imagined getting as far as I did, so maybe a used 552 should not be discounted. Looks like I need to get saving...

Ron - very interesting indeed, I must pay a visit to MAX soon.

Chris - I am using a hiline on the NDS.

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by u77033103172058601

When I upgraded the 300 to DR in my system (52/SCDR at the time) this was a huge change for the better. Getting a 552 (ex-dem) was about the same level of change, perhaps overall a little better, but not as good value. SL speaker cables and PLs all round then added a level of sonic upgrade similar to that which the DR had contributed, but at a higher cost than the DR bit.

The 300 DR bit is, in my view, the best upgrade of the 3, but not easily . And if you are inclined the 552 and SL cables will not disappoint.

 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by GraemeH

I use S400 and with each upgrade they have stayed the course.

With NDX Hugo TT straight to 250DR the system sounds incredibly transparent and the S400 are revealing it all! (In a good way)

G

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Chris Dolan
Mark430 posted:

I am using a hiline on the NDS.

It's worth trying a home dem - longish term ideally - of a Super Lumina interconnect and (my preference on my CDS3 in my system, but others of course differ) a Chord Sarum Super ARAY (or whatever takes your fancy) and see what you think. 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Allante93
MDS posted:
Hungryhalibut posted:

If I had your system (I sort of did once, with a CDS3, 555PS, 252, 300) I'd save a little harder, bite the bullet, and get a used 552, which is also what I did. Yes, DRing the 300 would make a difference, yes SL leads would be good, and the 252 might be a little better than than 52, though I doubt you'd really notice, but the 552 will transform everything. Goodness knows whether it will give you all that Hifi stuff you mention, but what it will do is give you a level of communication with the music beyond your dreams. 

Good advice here.  

+2

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by sheffieldgraham

I agree that a 552 is perhaps your best option.

Don't know what sale/trade in you'd get for the 52.

If it's beyond your means I'd go for the 300DR (£1495) conversion and Super Lumina speaker cables.

Super Lumina speaker cables per 3m £1850
Super Lumina speaker cables per 5m £3090
Super Lumina speaker cables per 7m £4330
Super Lumina speaker cables per 9m £5560

 
Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Innocent Bystander

I don't have experience of the S400s, but on the basis of what I've read I suspect that in terms of the desired "outright extension in the bass" a change of speaker may be necessary: regardless of the whether they might be capable of giving more across the board than they do. Whatever improvements better amplification may bring, the speakers will always be limited by their physical capability which at the bass end would seem to be less than some other speakers, though of course it depends on interaction with your room. What effect changing speakers would have in terms of the other improvements sought would depend very much on the speakers chosen. 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by b_lund

Have you been listening to Titan's ?

Maybe a better solution overall, your amp is allready pretty good allthough I would have preferred 135's

552 can allways be added, other cables too, indeed those insane prices shown here, I'd wait untill some shift (back)

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by impy

Hi Mark 430

 

Have you thought about a second 555dr on the NDS?

 

Trev

 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Allante93
Mark430 posted:

Hi all, .......

 Recently though, I have started looking for more... Let's say more of everything but in particular, more prat, clarity, more agility and outright extension in the bass. I've done all I can with room treatment and mains....

NDS 555DR / 52 / olive SC / 300 / nac a5 / S400 / power lines/ Isoblue / dedicated mains cu/ room treatment 

Well, I think you've called it !

Your front end, is by no means weak, the 300 may not be as refined as the 300DR, but the bass should still be there.

Perhaps it's time to demo some Speakers within your environment !

Titans ain't Bad, but I think they're running about 20K !

If I recall, there is a Speaker Manufacturer that is familiar with Naim electronics, Focal !

Maybe you can give them a listen.

Allante93!

 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by The Strat (Fender)

A few weeks ago attended a speaker demo and started the session with 282/SC and after a while swapped in a 252 - more refined, more resolution - and then having settled in with the Sopra 1s in went the 552 - complete and utter game changer.  A couple of guys that had dropped by to pick up some stuff just hung around. Breathtaking. 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by hungryhalibut

Let's be sensible - no speaker will make the difference that a 552 will make. 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Chris Dolan

I am not a massive Ovators fan but I have heard the 400s with NDS/555PS into 552/500 and they really did sing. I don't think different speakers would achieve what you would get with a 552. 

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Allante93
 
Mark430 posted:

Hi all, .......

 Recently though, I have started looking for more... Let's say more of everything but in particular, more prat, clarity, more agility and outright extension in the bass. I've done all I can with room treatment and mains....

NDS 555DR / 52 / olive SC / 300 / nac a5 / S400 / power lines/ Isoblue / dedicated mains cu/ room treatment 

Gentleman, no-one is disputing that the 552 wouldn't be a game changer, but the OP is in the market for PRAT, Clearity, and agility.

Sounds like he has out growned his S400s, it would be a shame to spend 552 type of Cash, and still want more Bass!

NDS 555DR / 52 / olive SC / 300 / nac a5 / S400 / 

That's right, the OP is looking for more PRAT, Clarity, agility, an outright extension of Bass, out of the above System!!!

Now add an 552, and Titans, or any other Speakers in the 20K neighborhood, problem solved.

 But that's 40K!

0ne thing I learned from you gents, when spending that type of Cash, always demo, in house, if possible.

Dealer won't mind, beit the 20k 552, or 10K Speakers, I don't think the OP has both in Mind.

Just looked at a multitude of 552 profiles, not to many 400s.

800,/30K, Titans/20K, 

600/7K, 400/4K

Doesn't cost the OP, one cent, to Demo some Speakers in the 10K range, in his treated Room!

Just my perspective!

Allante93!

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by Adam Zielinski

Well summarised Allante!

Posted on: 11 September 2016 by hungryhalibut

One can spend as much time as one likes summarising what others have said but with no practical experience of one's own, and it adds virtually nothing. It's the experience of those who have, and have had, 552s that is actually useful. 

What we need now is for the OP to try some options.

Posted on: 12 September 2016 by sjbabbey
Hungryhalibut posted:

One can spend as much time as one likes summarising what others have said but with no practical experience of one's own, and it adds virtually nothing.

+1 (although he does add lots of exclamation points !)