A short story which is also a quasi goodbye post

Posted by: Massimo Bertola on 16 November 2017

(Music: the lovely 1984 recording by Arthur Moreira Lima of Ernesto Nazareth's Brazilian waltzes and tangos. A disc I bought in another life at a used CDs' stall and am never ever tired of. Even on hi-fi systems.)

*

One.

Well I had this iPhone 5 given to me by my wife. I never thought of using it for storing music, even though I am what you anglophones call a commuter and spend time on trains and Metros. Instead, I love taking hot baths and trying to stop my mind and go back inside some maternal womb - as Woody Allen said, anyone's womb. So one day, while at the phone with a member here, my iPhone slipped into the hot, soapy water. Nothing could save it. It was lost and I had to think of another one.

Having seen and appreciated an Asus Zenfone 2 ML551 of a friend, my wife was so kind to give me one. It lasted six months until one day it fell face down on the ground and the touch screen was so compromised that it was useless to think about repairing it. It seems I have a bad karma with cellphones, but this is only the beginning of the story. I had bought a similar cellphone for my wife because her iPhone 4 was a) small, b) couldn't be updated or upgraded anymore and some apps already were announced as soon no more working on it. So, to cut a short story shorter, I took her 64 gigabyte Zenfone and bought her a smaller, more agile one.

Now, you find yourself with a cellphone with 64 giga store capacity and what do you do? You start thinking about putting some music in it. At first you think of just something you love specially to listen to while commuting, in the cold morning when you sit in a train and everybody around you is either cladded in black trendy clothes and is sucked into the screen of his/her smartphone or is a flock of faculty youngsters laughing at professors or discussing upcoming exams and talk loud and laugh but at least are not zombie-faced lost in a 5.5" luminous coffin. So I started thinking about how to do it, but my phone is Android and my Mac is a Mac and they will communicate properly much after Israel and Palestine will have found some agreement. But in the end, I did it: with a small app for the phone called Double Twist and its corresponding app for the Mac. I couldn't resist the ease with which I could transfer all my music from iTunes [never ever talk bad of iTunes: it's almost perfection in the absurdity of computer worlds] to Asus, and ended up with all of it in perfect order, with artwork and an absolutely unsuspectedly good pair of earplugs on my trips to the city of Milano which, in spite of Nigel's courteous admiration, is a repellent, anxiogenous rat-hole only devoted to money making and personal exhibition.

All my music on the Asus is either mp3 auto-rips from Amazon, AACs bought from iTunes or AACs rips from my own CDs. Not only we're not talking Hi-Def here, but we're talking that compressed thrash that Michael Fremer, the God of Audio, states he's able to recognize while sleeping in the midst of a metallurgic factory in full activity compared to any non-compressed format. Well, this morning I was listening to some of that thrash (David Chesky's The girl from Guantanamo, a nice musical poem for soprano and small orchestra, a piece I used to hear infinite times when it was trendy at my friend's audio store and he played it on systems costing like apartments [for people that actually lives in apartments costing like stereo systems]) and I realized that I had never heard it so well. The voice was beautiful, true, the stereo perspective wide and realistic, the acoustic instruments (mainly pizzicato strings and woodwinds, plus an occasional hand clap), the bass deep and controlled, the treble clean and airy and believable. I na word, everything I had always hoped to find in a system and have struggled (and spent, the f*uck with it!) to obtain. Even the mp3 of Smoke on the water, that I played on the way back after seven hours of teaching, just to bring back some irreverent fun into that twilight hour of the day, sounded perfect: the riff was rich, the drums was drums, and I could hear the pick work on the bass entry, like if it was not a rough recording of an overrated piece of thrash of 45 years ago but a good, enjoyable and believable piece of irreverent, funny rock, well worth listening.

Two.

At home, I wanted to play some more music. I was hungry with that same fun and quality enjoyment. But my Royal stereo – Naim's CDX2, SN, two extra PSUs, NAC A5 and Ovator S-400s – couldn't come close to that experience; it was just flat, aggressive, modestly detailed, a zero spatial plastic reproduction. And I knew (what most kind guys here seem to be completely unaware of) that no setup and no tweaking on this unlucky planet could have changed that sound into something listenable, enjoyable. My 16/44.1 CDs sounded like I had some problem in my ears. And the problem in my ears is that it is a stereo system inside a domestic room: something that will never be able to work properly, under any circumstance. To me, this is now a given fact, a plain truth. A system, and a costly one, is HDMI: a hoax, a disappointment and a mission impossible. No responsible, no-one  guilty, nothing I didn't know before; but a simple acknowledgement that all efforts are vain, are money down the toilet: stereo systems will never sound as good as an mp3 inside a good pair of earplugs from a decently designed telephone. Speakers in a domestic environment cannot cope with the infinity of acoustical, unmanageable issues; spatial details get lost in the real space but are preserved in the perfect rendition of two things inside the ears; and, the most humiliating thing of all, although I have tried headphones costing around €1000, no one sounded as good as the free pair of plugs I got with my Asus. And the iPhone4 I was almost tempted to ditch is, perhaps, even better. iTunes is not perfect, but a tad clearer and luminous than double Twist.

Three.

So what am I doing here now? I have no advice to give anyone anymore, I am not interested in upgrading or spending and I know that each day, when I feel a tickling, pleasant itch to buy some new box or cable, it is not anything else than an induced need leading me nowhere. So, with the rock-solid conviction that most of what I wrote until now will sound like drunken bulls*it to most (well, I am not drunk), I have nothing left to say than good night to everybody, not knowing if we'll ever meet again on the congested, delusional, sometimes unreadable pages of this loony bin.

Cheers

M.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Bob the Builder

Well I'm an honest type and I for one will hold my hands up and say I do have 'pride' in ownership of my Naim system and it is a pride I feel all to myself.  I do not know what else you would call it really I have worked very hard to achieve what I have and that includes my possessions and I feel proud of what I have achieved.  Why would I only feel grateful I would probably feel grateful if the things I have achieved were solely down to luck but they are not they are the fruits of very hard work not luck.

Do I feel bad that not everyone who works as hard as me can afford a Naim stereo?  Yes I do it is wrong but that does not mean it is wrong to feel proud.  Maybe I am wrong I know I cannot speak for others and maybe it is only myself who feels proud terrible, shallow person that I am.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by hungryhalibut

Pride does sound rather negative, and of course it’s one of the seven deadly sins. I do like having nice things, like a good hand built sofa, or a Miele fridge freezer. They are good solid things that are well made and built to last. Naim is not well known and hardly anyone who visits us knows what it is and therefore they don’t pass comment, other than to say ‘this sounds nice’ if they get to listen to music. I bought a decent watch last year and was saying to the woman in the shop that I didn’t want anything ostentatious. She told me that there was no need to worry as nobody ever notices them, and having worn it every day for nearly a year nobody has ever made a comment. I bought it because it’s really nice. 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Bob the Builder
Hungryhalibut posted:

Pride does sound rather negative, and of course it’s one of the seven deadly sins. I do like having nice things, like a good hand built sofa, or a Miele fridge freezer. They are good solid things that are well made and built to last. Naim is not well known and hardly anyone who visits us knows what it is and therefore they don’t pass comment, other than to say ‘this sounds nice’ if they get to listen to music. I bought a decent watch last year and was saying to the woman in the shop that I didn’t want anything ostentatious. She told me that there was no need to worry as nobody ever notices them, and having worn it every day for nearly a year nobody has ever made a comment. I bought it because it’s really nice. 

Yes but do you feel proud to own such nice things? Pride born of hard graft and sacrifice is totally different to say pride born from things that were given or were inherited. If I worked very hard from humble beginngs and felt pride at the house I lived in because of my hard work that is fine IMO. If I inherited a lot of money or won the lottery or some other good fortune and were prideful about the watch I wore or the stereo I owned because of that good fortune then that just makes me a Tory! 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Monkadill
Bob the Builder posted:
Hungryhalibut posted:

Pride does sound rather negative, and of course it’s one of the seven deadly sins. I do like having nice things, like a good hand built sofa, or a Miele fridge freezer. They are good solid things that are well made and built to last. Naim is not well known and hardly anyone who visits us knows what it is and therefore they don’t pass comment, other than to say ‘this sounds nice’ if they get to listen to music. I bought a decent watch last year and was saying to the woman in the shop that I didn’t want anything ostentatious. She told me that there was no need to worry as nobody ever notices them, and having worn it every day for nearly a year nobody has ever made a comment. I bought it because it’s really nice. 

Yes but do you feel proud to own such nice things? Pride born of hard graft and sacrifice is totally different to say pride born from things that were given or were inherited. If I worked very hard from humble beginngs and felt pride at the house I lived in because of my hard work that is fine IMO. If I inherited a lot of money or won the lottery or some other good fortune and were prideful about the watch I wore or the stereo I owned because of that good fortune then that just makes me a Tory! 

"makes me a Tory!" and there is the agenda..

 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Timmo1341
Hungryhalibut posted:

Pride does sound rather negative, and of course it’s one of the seven deadly sins. I do like having nice things, like a good hand built sofa, or a Miele fridge freezer. They are good solid things that are well made and built to last. Naim is not well known and hardly anyone who visits us knows what it is and therefore they don’t pass comment, other than to say ‘this sounds nice’ if they get to listen to music. I bought a decent watch last year and was saying to the woman in the shop that I didn’t want anything ostentatious. She told me that there was no need to worry as nobody ever notices them, and having worn it every day for nearly a year nobody has ever made a comment. I bought it because it’s really nice. 

Therein lies the difference. My brother-in-law, who could be the person upon whom Harry Enfield based his Tory Boy, was bought a Rolex by his wife last year. We met them for lunch soon after, not knowing of his acquisition. After much ostentatious cuff shuffling and checking the time (which just made me think he'd forgotten to set up to record something at home!), he was eventually forced to ask us what we thought of his watch! The poor bugger was bursting with 'pride', which I found rather sad. 

Maybe it's semantics, but whilst I often feel happy, satisfied, pleased, excited, anticipatory etc...with 'things', I can honestly say pride doesn't enter the equation. Like, I suspect, the majority of us ,I also have worked hard for everything I own. The gratefulness I feel is for the good fortune which has put me in the position of being able to acquire a satisfying, relatively well paid job that has given me all the trappings I enjoy - parents, home, education etc. Not everyone is lucky enough to have a solid life platform upon which to build. Hence grateful.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Bob the Builder
Timmo1341 posted:
Hungryhalibut posted:

Pride does sound rather negative, and of course it’s one of the seven deadly sins. I do like having nice things, like a good hand built sofa, or a Miele fridge freezer. They are good solid things that are well made and built to last. Naim is not well known and hardly anyone who visits us knows what it is and therefore they don’t pass comment, other than to say ‘this sounds nice’ if they get to listen to music. I bought a decent watch last year and was saying to the woman in the shop that I didn’t want anything ostentatious. She told me that there was no need to worry as nobody ever notices them, and having worn it every day for nearly a year nobody has ever made a comment. I bought it because it’s really nice. 

Therein lies the difference. My brother-in-law, who could be the person upon whom Harry Enfield based his Tory Boy, was bought a Rolex by his wife last year. We met them for lunch soon after, not knowing of his acquisition. After much ostentatious cuff shuffling and checking the time (which just made me think he'd forgotten to set up to record something at home!), he was eventually forced to ask us what we thought of his watch! The poor bugger was bursting with 'pride', which I found rather sad. 

Maybe it's semantics, but whilst I often feel happy, satisfied, pleased, excited, anticipatory etc...with 'things', I can honestly say pride doesn't enter the equation. Like, I suspect, the majority of us ,I also have worked hard for everything I own. The gratefulness I feel is for the good fortune which has put me in the position of being able to acquire a satisfying, relatively well paid job that has given me all the trappings I enjoy - parents, home, education etc. Not everyone is lucky enough to have a solid life platform upon which to build. Hence grateful.

Spot on Timmo they are not all so lucky some of us were raised by violent drinkers whose idea of education was a back hander and so left school at 16 to 'work' for a living and pay their way.  This isn't the best foundation and leads to quite a few wasted years and so when you manage to finally pull yourself together to have a reasonable life you do feel a sense of pride at owning things like Naim stereo's you never believed possible but also have the self awareness to own such feelings for what they are because guilt does not come into it.

I sometimes forget when I make statements what forum I'm on.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by DrMark

Interesting turn here on this thread: Timmo's story is at once amusing and in a sense pathetic (not Timmo, but his B-I-L). I have engaged a bit in similar behavior (rarely) in my life, and always afterward I look back and think what a lame display of insecurity it represents. And ironically, I can be impressed by a watch, but a Rolex is never one to do it for me...I don't care about the price, I want it to look good, and of course, function well.

If there is a "pride of ownership" regarding Naim, for me it doesn't have anything to do with the cost of owning a truly fine audio system. The "pride" (which as Nigel correctly points out, carries a negative connotation) for me is in knowing I have purchased a really excellent, quality product that does really well what I want it to do. My friends do not know Naim (especially being in the USA) and I actually avoid talking about the cost in many cases, unless I am really close to the person.

Indeed, I wish it did NOT cost so dearly to have such. I am an inveterate cheapskate in many areas - when you grow up with 5 kids (including a "special needs" kid, which is probably equal to 2+ regular kids) in a limited income situation you learn such. So none of my "pride" is based on that. Agreeing again with Nigel it comes down to having nice things; albeit for me, limited to the things that are important to me. The only "nice" furniture I have is that which I inherited from my mother when she passed; the rest is just functional, and I figure if I ever marry again that will likely all get changed anyway so why spend a lot? But in audio gear, guitars, and ice hockey equipment I go for the "best"...largely because doing so means I no longer have to worry and wonder about it performing as it should.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Robiwan

The one thing that sounds artificial are such ear phones. Blikkerig like they call it in Holland. 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Innocent Bystander

Of course, the discussion of 'pride' in an object is down to semantics, and we may not all take it to mean exactly the same thing - and BtB's statement regarding himself suggests not pride of ownership of Naim gear per se, but seeing it as a symbol that embodies pride in having made something of his life despite a distinctly unpriviledges start - which Indeed I think is oneplace where pride is well placed (assuming that other more important things are satisfactory first)..

As for lottery wins making one a Tory, I do the lottery occasionally, because that is the only way I could ever afford some of the out-and-out extravagent things that it is nice, occasionally, to dream of before returning to one's reality... as for politics, that is not a subject I readily get into discussing in casual conversation because inevitably someone makes it get unpleasant, but I do like the epithet Edgar Broughton applies to himself: 'I lean to the left, trying to do what's right'.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by TOBYJUG

Hifi heaven is two turntables.  a high quality rotary phono mixer stage. a high quality head amp and high quality phones.    Short of a mega super club sound system - will this be beaten.

And of course a fxxxton load of records and the time to run through them all.  

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by cat345
TOBYJUG posted:

Hifi heaven is two turntables.  a high quality rotary phono mixer stage. a high quality head amp and high quality phones.    Short of a mega super club sound system - will this be beaten.

And of course a fxxxton load of records and the time to run through them all.  

Some old beaten-up Altec A7's and BGW 750 amps could also do the trick with ''smoke on the water'' 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Hook

Life’s too short to worry about audio. Either enjoy music on the kit you have, or if you can afford it, buy the kit you want. Don’t let other people’s opinions - and in particular those expressed (mostly anonymously) here or on other forums - get you down.

Also, absense really does make the heart grow fonder. Have not been able to enjoy music for several days due a bad head cold with blocked up ears. Am just now able to hear clearly again, and can’t wait to spin some records this evening while Mrs. Hook is at a neighborhood ladies gathering. Am sure it will sound wonderful!

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Innocent Bystander
TOBYJUG posted:

Hifi heaven is two turntables.  a high quality rotary phono mixer stage. a high quality head amp and high quality phones.    Short of a mega super club sound system - will this be beaten.

And of course a fxxxton load of records and the time to run through them all.  

I presume you mean that club in London that uses a pair of Tannoy Westminster Royals... 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Clive B

I am bemused whenever I read on here of hifi equipment being referred to as a 'hobby'. Surely, it's all about the music. The only reason we buy this stuff is to enjoy the music. The only reason we upgrade stuff is to get that bit closer to the music. If it doesn't sound more like real instruments played by real people, then we shouldn't bother. It's the music that matters, regardless of what equipment is used for replay.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by MDS

I wouldn't say I have a sense of pride about my system though it pleases me and I certainly enjoy discussing the merits etc with other enthusiasts. Of course, the vast majority of 'normal' people aren't really interested in hi-fi and even those who are won't necessarily know Naim.  I must confess to being a bit sheepish if discussions with other people turn to music and I'm asked about what I use to play it. I'm very much aware that to most people having eight black boxes just to play a CD must seem ridiculous. And I certainly avoid questions about cost because the answer is even more ridiculous!  

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Clemenza

I'm with Hook, I appreciate my system most when I've had an absence from it. When I get home, kick back and turn it on I'm often stunned by how good it sounds. I absolutely agree that what is available now for modest sums can be every bit as engaging and interesting, but I do love the impact of a loudspeaker system. Music is part physical with me, not just mental and with cans I can't share it with others.

Max, take a break from the high end, but please not from the forum. Yours is one of the most interesting voices on here. You have a unique mind and unique use of language that I admire.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Haim Ronen
Clive B posted:

I am bemused whenever I read on here of hifi equipment being referred to as a 'hobby'. Surely, it's all about the music. The only reason we buy this stuff is to enjoy the music. The only reason we upgrade stuff is to get that bit closer to the music. If it doesn't sound more like real instruments played by real people, then we shouldn't bother. It's the music that matters, regardless of what equipment is used for replay.

Clive,

You are completely wrong, otherwise all the wise guys (ryhms?) here who are so busy splitting audiophile hairs would bother to post on the Music Room to share and learn something about the music.  Max is one of the very few here who gives us from time to time a reality check.

Haim

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by DrMark

And to add to Haim's comment, when I worked in the audio store (a Naim dealer), there were definitely those who were only hi-fi enthusiasts; I swear they never played more than a minute of a song (or so it seemed). "Listen to that cymbal there..." And undoubtedly there are more than a few on the forum that to one degree or another are in that group. It doesn't make it wrong, it is simply a different way of approaching hi-fi, although not one I really comprehend.

As someone posted here a while back the quote attributed to Alan Parsons: "Audiophiles don't use their equipment to listen to your music. Audiophiles use your music to listen to their equipment."

And to swing full oval back to Max's original post, Parsons himself feels that room interactions are more important than equipment. And as the owner of the said store where I worked told me, his general formula in audio gear was that a doubling of price gets you about a ten percent improvement, everything else being equal...just an off the cuff formula, but his point is that it is a law of diminishing returns.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by The Strat (Fender)

I think the OP should do 3 things.  

First, look after himself.  

Second, in the short term forget about the hi-fi just mothball it     

Third, in the longer term try some different speakers.

But most hang around Max. The Forum needs a diversity of contributions.

Regards,

LindsayI

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by SongStream

Pride and Naim...hmm, I don't think so.  To any normal gadget wielding individual born in the last 30 years, the classic Naim boxes look like garbage.  What those ugly boxes do is something rarely experienced, or appreciated, by most people.  I'm not poor enough to buy Miele products, but I know where to put my money to get the best end result pound for pound, and when it comes to music that has become Naim.  I too believe that the supplied i-phone ear-buds are pretty good as such things go, but they don't do what my Naim system does.  And not even close.

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by Massimo Bertola
Hungryhalibut posted:

Pride does sound rather negative, and of course it’s one of the seven deadly sins. I do like having nice things, like a good hand built sofa, or a Miele fridge freezer. They are good solid things that are well made and built to last. Naim is not well known and hardly anyone who visits us knows what it is and therefore they don’t pass comment, other than to say ‘this sounds nice’ if they get to listen to music. I bought a decent watch last year and was saying to the woman in the shop that I didn’t want anything ostentatious. She told me that there was no need to worry as nobody ever notices them, and having worn it every day for nearly a year nobody has ever made a comment. I bought it because it’s really nice. 

I did notice your watch in Milano! Haven't I told you?

M

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by hungryhalibut

No, you didn’t mention it, you are far too discreet for that. But whilst you noticed it, did you know what it was?

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by hungryhalibut
SongStream posted:

  I'm not poor enough to buy Miele products, 

Ooh, get you, Mr. Swanky!

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by SongStream
Hungryhalibut posted:
SongStream posted:

  I'm not poor enough to buy Miele products, 

Ooh, get you, Mr. Swanky!

At least I didn't reply with quote......Whoops. 

Posted on: 18 November 2017 by quickben

Having added the Audioquest Dragonfly Black DAC to my phone I found myself hearing things through my Bose in-ear buds that surprised and delighted me, so I can identify with much of what Max has said - and consequently I enjoy my music on the move far more than I ever did. I do find I cannot comfortably wear these for hours and of course I cannot share the listening experience with others. Having recently added the XPSDR to my 272 and 200DR I am at last hearing something where the SQ is delivering all I would like to hear and I am hearing so much more - at the end of the day it is not the logo on the front but what it delivers to the ears and how it makes you feel. The positive thing I took from your post Max was how much you are enjoying your music - and you can always go back to your box system if the muse takes you. Keep enjoying the music and life.

Peter