Does Naim NDS run out in time?

Posted by: DutchNaim on 02 June 2018

Hi there,

I sold my Naim 272 2016 and bought a NDS 2014 from a custumor wich bought the Nd555. I have to wait a few months until the Customer will receive his Nd555. I have a very good feeling about the Nds upgrade to the 272. But one feeling is bordering me. The Nds is now an archieved product as the 272 is still running. What will happen with the older streamers? Will they not be compatible in the  future with newer software? Will Naim come with a hardware upgrade like the 24 bit streaming board a few years ago? I heard also that the Uniti Qute 1 isn’t possible to upgrade to the newer software. If somebody plays with spotify than the person Will have problems with spotify because Naim uses the newer spotify in the update. So keeping it on the older software it will have problems with Spotify. I also had the spotify and Tidal problem on my 172. After the the update then no more. Maybe i am worried to early. But i believe that there are people wich bought a streamer NDS for almost €10k ex ps who like too play 20 years with it for example. What will it be does somebody have any thoughts about it?

Br,

 

Posted on: 02 June 2018 by MangoMonkey

I wouldn't worry about these things too much. The nds will shine as a upnp source as well as a Dac. You could always get a cheapo streamer and use it's digital out into the nds. 

Roon support is an example.

I use the Allo DigiOne for roon into the nds.

 

Posted on: 02 June 2018 by ChrisSU

The old streaming platform was developed before web streaming services existed, and was intended really for local UPnP use with iRadio thrown in. Hoping for ongoing support for new developments in web streaming services may be a bit much to expect, although it would be disappointing for many if Tidal integration could not be sustained. 

There are usually workaround solutions to add new functionality, often quite cheaply, while you save up for an ND555.

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by Simon-in-Suffolk

I think in true Naim style the streamers will be compatible with software for a few decades to come... in the limit one can use other software to drive the Naim streamers. However it is the automation and loading the direct streamer playlist buffer that is unique to Naim software. If Naim went out of business or decided to abandon support (which as I say is exceedingly unlikely) then one can use non Naim software that pushed media from the server ... and from a SQ perspective that works as well, even with gapless. The DLNA UPnP bass standard would come to the rescue if this was an eventuality.

When the classic streamers were initially invented, it was  I believe  only Spotify that was on the design to be integrated.. then later came Tidal, as at the time (and now ironically) it was seen as more commercially future proofed than Qobuz... however the integration approach required much effort... and in talking to Naim these integrations are only really globally relevant for a subset of their market..in Asia they have they tend to have their own streaming services.... so there was a change of integration approach with the newer streamers to support Google Cast ... this moves the streamer into a Google Cast endpoint that can be controlled by other software.. very popular in Asia I understand... meaning future service integration is not reliant on Naim... it is this that we will miss out on with the older streamers... However these older Naim streamer, and new alike  are an established UPnP end point, and as Chris says there are also many options out there to integrate  new services with our older Naim streamers such as Qobuz for example.

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by Adam Zielinski

A different analogy - NDS is an efficient petrol car, in the day and age when hybrid cars are starting to appear. I suspect  we will still use both for many years to come 

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by French Rooster

it would be interesting to know how the nds can be upgrade or even updated with new and modern dacs to come or existing already.  A lot of members here have experimented outboards dacs like chord hugo or even naim dacs on the lower range of streamers, like nd5x or ndx.  But no one have tried to connect a dac like chord dave or dcs on the nds.  Can the nds be upgrade in this way?   is connecting an mqa dac to the nds can allow the nds to stream mqa files from tidal?   

Personnaly i am more interested in upgraded performance and sound quality than having access to more services like roon for example.

If naim could have adopted the linn strategy, the possibility to upgrade from linn ds1 to 2 , 3, ...without selling all the unit,  there would be no problem or questions like this thread.

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by Simon-in-Suffolk

FR, do as I do and use the SPDIF output... the Naim streamers create a top class stable transport feed when you run them in only transport mode as opposed to DAC mode in the settings menu... the better the streamer, the better the stream, albeit it is serious diminishing returns.

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by Nick Lees

Another one who feeds a DAC (Hugo, then Dave) from an NDX. Excellent results. WHen funds allow I may try an Auralic streamer bridge.

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by French Rooster
Nick Lees posted:

Another one who feeds a DAC (Hugo, then Dave) from an NDX. Excellent results. WHen funds allow I may try an Auralic streamer bridge.

you have a dave connected to the ndx?    do you still use the naim app?   is the dave connected to your preamp or only to the ndx?   thanks 

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by French Rooster
Simon-in-Suffolk posted:

FR, do as I do and use the SPDIF output... the Naim streamers create a top class stable transport feed when you run them in only transport mode as opposed to DAC mode in the settings menu... the better the streamer, the better the stream, albeit it is serious diminishing returns.

i have no outboard dac on hand.  If one day i connect a dac to the nds, in spdif, will i still use the naim app?

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by French Rooster
Nick Lees posted:

Another one who feeds a DAC (Hugo, then Dave) from an NDX. Excellent results. WHen funds allow I may try an Auralic streamer bridge.

Hey Nick, a last question:  you choose ndx/ dave vs nds.  Have you heard the nds, and how are the differences in sound vs your combo?

Posted on: 03 June 2018 by Nick Lees
French Rooster posted:
Nick Lees posted:

Another one who feeds a DAC (Hugo, then Dave) from an NDX. Excellent results. WHen funds allow I may try an Auralic streamer bridge.

Hey Nick, a last question:  you choose ndx/ dave vs nds.  Have you heard the nds, and how are the differences in sound vs your combo?

The NDX is connected by SPDIF (Chord Signature TA) to Dave which uses a Chord Sarum T RCA-DIN connect to the 552. The NDX uses system automation so I use the Naim App for everything except Qobuz (for which I use BubbleUPNP Server/ Kazoo).

I bought the NDX originally as a toy to play the odd download I had, but the sound was way behind the rest of my system. I could have spent a load on upgrading to the NDS but was intrigued by the fuss about Hugo - which proved to be true. Dave was an inevitable temptation. I didn't try an NDS as it would have been way more expensive. As I mentioned, potential upgrades are the streamer head (which would mean I'd lose system automation) or the Chord Blu2 (though I have no real need of the CD player I already have and that part would be unnecessary).