Expert advice or gut feeling on my two rack dilemma.

Posted by: boom on 21 July 2018

Ok....I have decided to upgrade my old Apollo rack. It has come down to two options, neither are ideal...... but that’s what you get for living in an inperfect world. Below are my two option. The reasoning for Opt 1&2, is keeping the SWBO happy(as usual). When costing the two options they come in pretty close  to one another. IYHO, Which would give best SQ advantage over the other?  Your thoughts and advice would be much appreciated 

My current setting is

 

Option 1 - Fraim from friendly local dealer - wife doesn’t like the look of it twin stacked as an entertainment unit under TV, so....

 

Option 2 - Isoblue imported from the UK,

 

This is an impossible AB comparison, so just looking for everyone’s opinions and gut feelings on this one. Also your thoughts of the US sitting on the rack considering it is not recommended.

Thanks in advance for your input.

Boom

 

Posted on: 21 July 2018 by feeling_zen

I think you'll find that rack stability greatly falls off after 6 shelves. So based on that I'd not entertain the 10 shelf option.

I think FraimLite is overlooked too often. It's still a fantastic racking sokution fit for any level of eqipment and I mention it because you migyt find it more aesthetically pkeasing than Farim (I certainly do).

There's also Quadrapire options which may be preferred visually but again (and I say this from experience), do not exceed 6 levels. We have identical systems and I use the Quadraspire 4 evo with 6 shelves and nothing on the top shelf except an ornamental bowl. 100mm spacers beteen all level except the bottom level at 140mm for the 250DR and 2nd from top level for the NDX so that 282 at 1st from top and 250 on the bottom are the most separate from each other. 

I'd actually like Fraim/Lite but it just isn't safe in earthquake prone locations.

Posted on: 21 July 2018 by boom

Thanks, sorry didn’t explain that too well. The 10 rack option would be split into brain and brawn, so max 5 levels on each stack only.

I showed the SWBO the QS, it didn’t get the thumbs up unfortunately.

yea I’m in earthquake prone NZ, so that is always in the back of my mind.

cheers

Posted on: 21 July 2018 by feeling_zen

Ahh I see.

Safety issues first. Only you can decide. On independently isolated levels, a 250 can easily become a pointy cannonball. That might be an okay risk if there are no kids around.

How about a single rack of Fraim/Lite just for the hifi and an extra top shelf for SWMBO to decorate with whatver she wants?

Posted on: 21 July 2018 by boom

No kids luckily. 

I,m pretty set on the two options, ’m really trying to work out which is the lesser of two evils.

Fraim single stack standing on the same wall, 300mm away from the speaker 

or

Isoblue brain-brawn stacked to the side wall, away from the speakers with a unitiserve on the rack.

 

Posted on: 22 July 2018 by yeti42

Full Fraim but bear in mnd my earthquake experience is limited to a few minor ones in the UK. The building I was in could be felt swaying gently duiring the first one but it was built on clay, there was no damage, anywhere. For the second I was on a canal boat near the epicentre, possibly in the Netherton tunnel, and didn’t even notice it until I heard about it on the news.

Posted on: 22 July 2018 by boom

Fraim 1 Isoblue 0

I don’t think either rack will have issues with earthquakes.......unless its the big one, then the system would be the last of my concerns.

Yes its a strange feeling when the building is swaying. It’s totally mad when the building starts moving in all directions, left, right, back, forwards, up and down.....you sit down under a door frame and hope like hell it goes away.

 

 

Posted on: 22 July 2018 by Bob the Builder

Hutter?

Posted on: 22 July 2018 by feeling_zen
boom posted:

I don’t think either rack will have issues with earthquakes.

Pfff. I've had things in my home substantially heavier than a 250 or a Fraim rack fly across the room during a quake before. A fully decoupled rack is asking for trouble. I've decided that a Fraim will have to wait until I move somewhere where M3.5 is strongest quake to have hit the area in recent history. To underestimate what even a lower magnitude quake can do if the waves hit your building the wrong way or wavelength happens to match the height of the building is, frankly, a position taken by those who have not been in quakes that have resulted in serious damage or who have but have short memories.

I remember once, the room I was in just had some wine glasses tipped off shelves but the next room just meters away, my entire chest of drawers with a very low centre of gravity just flew 3m across the room.

Most quake related deaths are in fact related to room objects falling on people. 

Posted on: 23 July 2018 by boom
feeling_zen posted:
boom posted:

I don’t think either rack will have issues with earthquakes.

Pfff. I've had things in my home substantially heavier than a 250 or a Fraim rack fly across the room during a quake before. A fully decoupled rack is asking for trouble. . 

Mmm, I hadn’t really thought that one through, glass on ball bearings...in an earthquake. Good point

 

Posted on: 23 July 2018 by boom
Bob the Builder posted:

Hutter?

Never liked the look of Hutter.