Originally Posted by Florestan:

A little cross-section of many of the who's who in the piano world. I did have the opportunity to buy these one by one when they were coming out. One of the biggest mistakes I've made in not buying these.
Cheer up, Doug. This collection consists of a truly staggering amount of great recordings by many fine pianists (many no longer well known), but the producers made a couple of doubtful decisions, which for me at least significantly downgrades the value of this set. Is André Previn really one of the 20th century greatest pianists? Why were Tatiana Nikolaeva, Annie Fischer and Ivo Pogorelich excluded? (actually, apparently Pogorelich is said to have blocked his inclusion as he insisted to be represented by Chopin, who the producers felt was already overrepresented - good reason?).
Cheers,
EJ
EJ: Of course, I probably have the complete recordings of at least 70 or 80% of the artists that are in the series anyway but I somehow still wish I still had these. They make a nice little recital when I want a break from concentrated listening to complete sets. The other reason is that the 10 or 20% of the artists unbelievably are absent from my library or there is the odd gem here that cannot be had elsewhere with the recordings being long gone. By listening to this I realize how many pianists I need to still investigate further and find recordings. This sampler contains the only recordings I have of Josef Lhévinne, Robert Casadesus, Shura Cherkassky, Ignaz Friedmann, Grigory Ginsburg, Myra Hess, Josef Hoffmann, William Kapell, Nikita Magaloff, Benno Moiseiwitsch, Ignacy Jan Paderewski, Maria Yudina, Leopold Godowsky. All names that I know well but I just haven't had the opportunity to really get to know them.
You may be right about some major exclusions and definite mistakes in hindsight. I don't know this for fact but I've always assumed that most of the artists included were part of the Universal Group of artists? That is, anyone who had any involvement with Philips, Decca, DGG etc. and of course they most definitely had to play on a Steinway & Sons ! This might explain the Annie Fisher and Tatiana Nikolayeva? It was unfortunate about Pogorelich though...