What are you listening to and WHY might anyone be interested? (Vol.VIII)
Posted by: Richard Dane on 29 December 2011
With 2012 almost upon us, it's time to start a fresh thread. I've gone back to an earlier thread title because often the "why" is the most interesting part of the post.
Anyway, links:
Volume VII: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...6878604287751/page/1
Volume VI: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...ent/1566878604097229
Volume V: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...ent/1566878605140495
Volume IV: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...ent/1566878605795042
Volume III: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...ent/1566878607309474
Volume II: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...ent/1566878606245043
Volume I: https://forums.naimaudio.com/di...ent/1566878607464290
The eight impromptus, played with great sensitivity and simplicity by Brendel. Like Perahia (who recorded his set a few years earlier), Brendel's less is more approach yields great results. Brendel far surpasses himself on earlier recordings, and while he kept on playing Schubert for twenty more years, he never recaptured the magic as he did throughout this cycle recorded in the mid-80s.
Brendel is not universally regarded as a great pianists, but hear him in Haydn or this Schubert to get the spark.
Cheers,
EJ
Originally Posted by Florestan:
This recording would be very trying for someone who is used to a more hyper or muscular Schubert worldview.
Above all, it is that character or willingness to enter into a different sound world which means slowing down, taking more time with the musical aspects/details and letting the beauty of the sound speak in order to hear the contrasts between light and darkness clearly. This alone would knock out the vast majority of listeners who might expect the going norm. For my money, I think this recording offers very compelling thoughts and ideas and is recorded quite well too and so I place it very high in what I need from my Schubert experiences.
Florestan,
It's just a recent that I started to appreciate Schubert's music and it took me many repeated listen by different pianists.
And I now understand that *space* you talk about. I don't think I had a patience for his music before. They can sound like wondering around without a specific destination which used to make me crazy.
Still some of the piecees, like Drei Klavierstücke takes some doing to get through!
I am glad I decided to pick this disc. I usually try a few living pianists for a change.
He's indeed very good and got that sensibility. But for the Impromptus included in this disc, I still prefer Brendel ( '63 Vox not the later Philips ) or Richter's '58 Sophia live performance where they maintain lyricism yet there's a direct quality which appeals.
And that little Allegretto piece is one of my favourite like Beethoven's Les Adieux.
Perianes' sensitive rendition does not give flashy drama but he tries to draw a simple honest picture to express this tune. Unusual for a young pianist who usually needs to prove their virtuosity to the world.
My *reference* so to speak for the Allegretto so far is Schnabel's '39 recording.
He doesn't dwell on each note much but what he delivers have a weight of gold. He packs in many shades of emotional states in such a short piece ranging from sad, happy, angry and a sense of release. Excellent use of 'ma'.
You're right that the recording on this disc actually is better balanced than Lewis' which it sounds a tad too eager in EQ and reverve.
My favourite SRV album
A compilation of some funky grooves from the 70s.
Whomever did the pressing these vinyl records sound great!
Pletnev Live at Carnegie Hall

There's always something animalistic about his style of playing that is appealing.
On vinyl.
This album is now available on CD. It contains much of the material Georgie Fame played live in the mid-60's. From his excellent rendition of John Hendrick's "Yeh Yeh", which became a number 1 hit, through material originally recorded by The Temptations, Lee Dorsey, Joe Hinton, Booker T, James Brown, Marvin Gaye and others, plus "Getaway" - another single release - this is a great record,
Graham,
interesting, typical Belcea playing.
listing from Qobuz
After another long day at work, relaxing with the complete WTC by Andras Schiff. I think this is one of the bolder pianistic versions I have ever heard - as Bach on the piano goes, he utilises good dynamic range and has an exceptional trill. He leaves Perahia's dry barebones renditions far behind, surpasses even Angela Hewitt and I feel approaches Arrau's ultimate relevancy as well as charisma.
Cheers,
EJ
Sounding sublime.
Feeling like some bombast :-
On CD:-
Vinyl

Originally Posted by EJS:
The eight impromptus, played with great sensitivity and simplicity by Brendel. Like Perahia (who recorded his set a few years earlier), Brendel's less is more approach yields great results. Brendel far surpasses himself on earlier recordings, and while he kept on playing Schubert for twenty more years, he never recaptured the magic as he did throughout this cycle recorded in the mid-80s.
EJ,
How is it compare to his Vox cycle?
One of my favourite Schubert Impromptus is his from the 60s. I wasn't too nuts on his Phillips recording of Schubert. ( albeit I haven't listend to the entire catalogue )
Kempff's Goldberg Variations.
Bach indeed has a soothing or clearing effect on mind. ( soft of like a strong wasabi )
It rocks on vinyl.
Originally Posted by EJS:
After another long day at work, relaxing with the complete WTC by Andras Schiff. I think this is one of the bolder pianistic versions I have ever heard - as Bach on the piano goes, he utilises good dynamic range and has an exceptional trill. He leaves Perahia's dry barebones renditions far behind, surpasses even Angela Hewitt and I feel approaches Arrau's ultimate relevancy as well as charisma.
Schiff, might be good but I bet he can't hum as good as Glenn.

Originally Posted by EJS:
The eight impromptus, played with great sensitivity and simplicity by Brendel. Like Perahia (who recorded his set a few years earlier), Brendel's less is more approach yields great results. Brendel far surpasses himself on earlier recordings, and while he kept on playing Schubert for twenty more years, he never recaptured the magic as he did throughout this cycle recorded in the mid-80s.
EJ,
How is it compare to his Vox cycle?
One of my favourite Schubert Impromptus is his from the 60s. I wasn't too nuts on his Phillips recording of Schubert. ( albeit I haven't listend to the entire catalogue )
Kuma,
Don't know his vox recording, sadly. I like him much better in these (1987-88 Philips) than his 70s recordings.
Cheers,
EJ