Advanced search

Beyond Mana

Posted by: Chris Metcalfe on 10 August 2000

Martin Colloms in HiFi News this month reviews a stand by Finite Elemente of Germany called the Pagode (HD, in this case). The interesting part is that he's used Mana as his primary supports for several years and feels that the Pagode stands(to precis crudely) are notably better in a number of key areas.

Many have criticised the Mana sound without living with it; here is the UK's premier technical reviewer, having used it for a considerable time, finding something potentially better. It doesn't look gothic, either. But it's very expensive.

[This message was edited by Chris Metcalfe on FRIDAY 11 August 2000 at 08:16.]

Posted on: 10 August 2000 by Mark Dunn
Hi all:

Hartmut, isn't that what you use?

Best Regards,
Mark Dunnp

Posted on: 11 August 2000 by Willem van Gemert
Finite Elemente have several racks. The Pagode HD range is the biggest and most expensive range. A "normal" Pagode Rack, which should be enough for Naim components, is more reasonably priced and should not be more expensive than the equivalent in Hutter or Mana. Their finish is simply superb! For me, they are the best looking stands currently available, but I have no idea how they combine with Naim. Currently I'm trying a Mana Mini Table at home and it's effect on my NAT 01 is absolutely stunning! I didn't try my other components yet on it. In the mean time the local Finite Elemente dealer promised me I can try his Pagode Rack once at home. I will, after my trip to Greece in September. Maybe I could arrange to get some Hutter as well by then. Will let you know my impressions if it works out.

Ciao!

Willem

P.S. For more info on the Pagode Racks, check out: www.finite-elemente.de

Posted on: 11 August 2000 by Former member
I am curious if anyone has tried the stand made by the people who make the Townshend Seismic Sink and how it compares with Mana, Hutter or the Pagode? Best regards, Dave
Posted on: 11 August 2000 by Former member
quote:
I am curious if anyone has tried the stand made by the people who make the Townshend Seismic Sink and how it compares with Mana,

A couple of months ago I had one of Townshend's isolation supports on loan and found that it had a very positive effect on my Quadraspire rack (except with the CDS II, which seems to want rigid stands).

It had a very powerful and highly resolved sound, with great delicacy and dynamics. It also played a pretty good tune and knew how to swing. It's a pretty sexy, potent sound.

I then visited a friend who had a Hutter rack, which I found to be immensely musical and involving. I took the Townshend platform with me and we put it on the Hutter. It immediately got more detailed and dynamic and powerful, but I felt that the music didn't hang together so well. Every note sounded better, but it didn't join the notes up into music like raw Hutter. [Music is not just sounds, music is the relationship between sounds.]

A song played with the seismic sink was like a lesser band in a better recording studio. Patti Smith was more obviously the great she-devil and true heir to Janis on the Hutter than on the Townshend.

Since then I've bought some Hutter and started experimenting (I'll post the whole story when I finish). I found that using the extra isolating base, but with spikes on the bottom instead of the usual decoupling feet, brings it a lot closer to the Townshend so far as dynamics, detail and bass extension are concerned. I'm starting to get the best of both worlds.

Compared to Townshend (or Hutter or Quadraspire), Mana is a completely different approach to making music. It injects thrill-factor by the bucket load. The question is whether this suits your tastes (and your system, and your acoustics, and your floor).

Joel

Born to groove

Posted on: 15 August 2000 by Tomas Östlund
I got some tax refounds and am planning to spend some of it on supports. In my ears (reading this forum) the Hutter racks seems to be a very good alternative. I'm not to keen on the looks though and on Naims sight the new 5-series is displayed in another stand manufactured by Hutter. Has anyone compared this to the rest of their range ?

/Tomas

[This message was edited by Tomas Östlund on TUESDAY 15 August 2000 at 23:18.]