The greatest single composition of the 20th century

Posted by: mikeeschman on 28 February 2009

i would like to nominate Messiaen's "Quartet for the End of Time" as the most profound, complete and musically satisfying work written in the 20th century.

here are some program notes for this work, courtesy of University of Southern California :

MESSIAEN: Quartet for the End of Time

Program Notes

In 1940, Olivier Messiaen (1908-92) was interned in a German prison camp, where he discovered among his fellow prisoners a clarinettist, a violinist and a violoncellist. The success of a short trio which he wrote for them led him to add seven more movements to this Interlude, and a piano to the ensemble, to create the Quartet for the End of Time. Messiaen and his friends first performed it for their 5000 fellow prisoners on January 15, 1941.

If the plain facts of the work's origins are simple, the spiritual facts are far more complex. Messiaen's religious mysticism found a point of departure for the Quartet in the passage in the Book of Revelation (chapter 10) about the descent of the seventh angel, at the sound of whose trumpet the mystery of God will be consummated, and who announces "that there should be time no longer."

According to the composer, the Quartet was intended not to be a commentary on the Apocalypse, nor to refer to his own captivity, but to be a kind of musical extension of the Biblical account, and of the concept of the end of Time as the end of past and future and the beginning of eternity. For Messiaen there was also a musical sense to the angel's announcement. His development of a varied and flexible rhythmic system, based in part on ancient Hindu rhythms, came to fruition in the Quartet, where more or less literally Messiaen put an end to the equally measured "time" of western classical music.

The architecture of the Quartet is both musical and mystical. There are eight movements because God rested on the seventh day after creation, a day which extended into the eighth day of timeless eternity. There are intricate thematic relationships, as for example between movements two and seven, both of which are about the angel; and stylistic and theological relationships, as between movements five and eight.

In a preface to the score, Messiaen commented on each of the movements:

1.

Liturgy of crystal. Between three and four o'clock in the morning, the awakening of the birds: a blackbird or a solo nightingale improvises, surrounded by efflorescent sound, by a halo of trills lost high in the trees...

2.

Vocalise, for the Angel who announces the end of Time. The first and third parts (very short) evoke the power of this mighty angel, a rainbow upon his head and clothed with a cloud, who sets one foot on the sea and one foot on the earth. In the middle section are the impalpable harmonies of heaven. In the piano, sweet cascades of blue-orange chords, enclosing in their distant chimes the almost plainchant song of the violin and violoncello.

3.

Abyss of the birds. Clarinet alone. The abyss is Time with its sadness, its weariness. The birds are the opposite to Time; they are our desire for light, for stars, for rainbows, and for jubilant songs.

4.

Interlude. Scherzo, of a more individual character than the other movements, but linked to them nevertheless by certain melodic recollections.

5.

Praise to the Eternity of Jesus. Jesus is considered here as the Word. A broad phrase, infinitely slow, on the violoncello, magnifies with love and reverence the eternity of the Word, powerful and gentle, ... "In the beginning was the Word, and Word was with God, and the Word was God."

6.

Dance of fury, for the seven trumpets. Rhythmically, the most characteristic piece in the series. The four instruments in unison take on the aspect of gongs and trumpets (the first six trumpets of the Apocalypse were followed by various catastrophes, the trumpet of the seventh angel announced the consummation of the mystery of God). Use of added [rhythmic] values, rhythms augmented or diminished... Music of stone, of formidable, sonorous granite...

7.

A mingling of rainbows for the Angel who announces the end of Time. Certain passages from the second movement recur here. The powerful angel appears, above all the rainbow that covers him... In my dreams I hear and see a catalogue of chords and melodies, familiar colours and forms... The swords of fire, these outpourings of blue-orange lava, these turbulent stars...

8.

Praise to the Immortality of Jesus. Expansive solo violin, counterpart to the violoncello solo of the fifth movement. Why this second encomium? It addresses more specifically the second aspect of Jesus, Jesus the Man, the Word made flesh... Its slow ascent toward the most extreme point of tension is the ascension of man toward his God, of the child of God toward his Father, of the being made divine toward Paradise.

i hope there are other nominations on this thread.
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by stephenjohn
Fred, that's more than one. And none of them begin with B
atb
SJ
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by stephenjohn
sorry. One
SJ
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by stephenjohn
sorry again. Two
SJ
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by mikeeschman
this is not a classicals only thread.

as a result of this thread, i will be listening to tubular bells and sex pistols (already have a love supreme).
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by u5227470736789439
What about Bernstein's

Westside Story, if the non-classical is allowed?

ATB from George
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by Whizzkid
quote:
Originally posted by Mat Cork:
Can't see it W, what is it?



Matt,


Its a 12" single, Adonis - No Way Back, from 1986 pivotal moment in my music listen journey.



Dean..
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by FlyMe
Easy question answer as far as I am concerned...

Posted on: 02 March 2009 by u5227470736789439
I think Beecham understood Britten as no other conductor.

Sorry but in regard to Britten I agree with Beecham. Beecham seemed to understand Mozart, and also Wagner, so my reaction to him is indeed, to quote TB, "A Mingled Chime."

ATB from George
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by King Size
Mike,

in the spirit of keeping your thread on track and putting forward 'non-classical' works I would like to suggest Talk Talk's 'Spirit of Eden'. There is an article on this album written by Nick Southall that appears in stylus magazine. I don't want to post the url here bit if you do a google search you'll find it.

To quote one paragraph from the article:

quote:
Spirit Of Eden occupies a space outside musical genres, an area between pop and jazz that is painted vividly with the colours and textures of blues, ambient, classical, rock... The first half of the record consists of a suite of three tracks which flow organically between each other, The Rainbow starting inauspiciously with subdued strings and the rumour of trumpets, the awakening of the record heralded by squalls of over-amped harmonica and electric guitar, Friese-Green in thrall to Lamonte Young, Cage and Stockhausen while Hollis invokes his fascination with Robert Johnson and John Lee Hooker. But where Johnson’s soul was sold, Hollis finds his saved amid the fall and rise, the surging tide.
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by Mat Cork
Teenage Kicks and Gorecki's 3rd both smashing tunes, complete and insightful in an almost perfect way.
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by Guido Fawkes
quote:
Originally posted by BigH47:
Karn Evil 9 by ELP.


Good choice.

However, I'd go for



Sinfonietta for 2 flutes and piccolo, 2 oboes, cor anglais, 2 clarinets, E-flat clarinet, bass clarinet, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 9 trumpets in C, 3 trumpets in F, 2 bass trumpets, 4 trombones, 2 tenor tubas, bass tuba, timpani, cymbals, bells, harp, and strings by Leos Janáček. Janáček said it was to express contemporary free man, his spiritual beauty and joy, his strength, courage and determination to fight for victory. In some respects it is fanfare for the common man.

A rearrangement of the opening of the Sinfonietta was used by Emerson, Lake & Palmer for the song Knife-Edge on their debut album.

It was also used as the introductory music to Crown Court - the superb re-enactment of court cases starring William Mervin and John Barron as judges.

ATB Rotf
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by mikeeschman
great post, ROTF.

off to find emerson, lake & palmer.
Posted on: 02 March 2009 by Geoff P
I nominate

Gershwin's "Porgy & Bess".

It has the structure to provide so many different interpretaions across musical genres. From the duo's of Ella Fitzgerald & Louis Armstrong, via Cleo Laine with Ray Charles to Miles Davis with Gil Evans. Duke Ellington of course but also the Glyndebourne Festival Chorus, Houston Grand Opera, Simon Rattle with Willard White and so on.

Here are a few snippets of opinion that make a few salient points:

In 1935 when the first public performance of Porgy & Bess took place, the immediate result was a cultural confusion which would have been comical had it not also been unfortunate for its' performers and costly for those who financed it. It was also acutely disappointing for its' composer who never lived long enough to enjoy the eventual vindication of the work, although perhaps we need not feel too badly on that account, for George Gershwin, buttressed by an impregnable and wholly justified self-esteem when it came to his own work, appears to have known perfectly well that the ultimate survival of the opera was a foregone conclusion.

Gershwin had been raised in the toughest of schools where you either came up with a good tune or you went out and found a job. That is the vital fact about his background which seperates him from every other operatic composer who ever lived. When you were selling a song like "Swanee" there was no tenors' rich vibrato and throbbing jugular to help the demonstration, no lush orchestral effects to prop up the structure, no pretentious wedding of plot and characterisation to excuse a hackneyed harmonic pattern. Most significant of all, your singer was performing in English so there was not even the mysticism of an incomprehensible foreign language to cow the listener into humble respect. All you had was your melody, and it better be a good one.

At the time of the composition of 'Porgy and Bess' the american public at large had little interest in or understanding of conventional classical opera. Sensing the fundemental absurdity of a heroine complaining that she is dying of consumption when it is plain to see that she is thirty five pounds overweight, and bravely refusing to be browbeaten into an enthusiasm it did not feel, by the orundities of operatic Italian, America stayed away in its millions.

To the nose in air critics in the 1930's the reasoning went: X is a much venerated opera of the modern school; X has no discernible melodies; therfore no venerated opera of the modern school should possess any discernible melodies. It was as though the british admiralty having noticed how well Lord Nelson was doing with one eye, were to cashier every officer with two.

In spite of this climate and its inauspicious start in life 'Porgy and Bess' has so many great melodies and emotional lyrics that it is an irresitible listen, however interpretted, for a large audience today.

regards
Geoff
Posted on: 03 March 2009 by mikeeschman
last night i went on youtube and listened to mike oldfield's tubular bells, the sex pistols god save the queen and my way, emerson, lake & palmer's knife edge, and i pulled out my janacek sinfonetta, and three different readings of porgy & bess - oscar peterson, miles davis/gil evans, and the opera itself.

so now i know of whom we are speaking :-)
Posted on: 03 March 2009 by Wolf2
To me the most "profound work" I've heard in a decade is Britten's War Requiem. I'd not heard it before, but LA Phil put it on last year and it terrified me and brought me to tears at places. It goes out with a whisper and they dropped out the house lights till it was just a spot on the conductor and at the end, they kept the lights off for 30 seconds. That was a long 30 seconds to ponder.

Odd how Britten isn't considered a major composer. he didn't do many plain orchestral works but tons of vocal pieces. The best recording is Britten's own and has been remastered.
Posted on: 03 March 2009 by mikeeschman
quote:
Originally posted by Wolf2:
To me the most "profound work" I've heard in a decade is Britten's War Requiem.

Odd how Britten isn't considered a major composer.


i have been a fan of britten since about 1971, when i studied the war requiem and billy budd, of which i have the original recordings, and a black-and-white dvd of billy budd with the original cast from the recording.

i think the reason he is not considered a major composer is that he's a one trick pony. if we played drop-the-needle with the war requiem, billy budd and peter grimes, you would be hard pressed to tell one from the other in many sections. he uses the same voicings and the same keys in every work (or so it seems to the listener - no score available to verify).

never the less, i still love his music. BTW, he did a salute to percy grainger in the 60s that is available as a cd, and it is one of my most listened to disks - beautiful tunes played stunningly well and recorded with great clarity and dynamics (it is a london recording).
Posted on: 03 March 2009 by graham55
Gustav Mahler: Symphony No 9.

And there are so many wonderful recordings of it.
Posted on: 03 March 2009 by Analogue
I agree with Geoff P,
The most oustanding composition for me is Rhapsody In Blue.
It simply blew me away when i first heard it as a teenager in the middle 1950s and still does, i am now aproaching 66.
Bearing in mind that this time was the launching of music that would change many peoples lives ie - Elvis and Bill haley etc...
Posted on: 03 March 2009 by Florestan
Sorry Mike, I just can't restrain myself. I was trying to be good and not post because I knew I simply couldn't limit myself to present the "single" greatest; there is simply just an abundance of wonderful music created in the 20th century (or the 19th or 18th or 17th etc. for that matter) for me to keep from brimming over with excitement or keep my mouth shut and settle for one (but I will limit myself to eight suggestions based on composers here...

Ravel - Gaspard de la nuit
Ravel - Trio for piano, violin and cello

Debussy - Preludes Book I & II and Etudes

Scriabin - Preludes and Etudes

Shostakovich - Trio for Piano, Violin and Violoncello No. 2 in e-

Rachmaninov - Etudes-tableaux and Preludes

Medtner - Vergessene Weisen (Forgotten Melodies)

Prokofiev - Visions fugitives

Janacek - In the Mist or On an Overgrown Path

and an Encore...

Mompou - El lago (Le Lac)

I would really encourage anyone who isn't familiar with any of these composers to give them a try period. I realize my suggestions are mostly piano centered but others can suggest more non-piano works if that is your goal. There is much to be gained here to enrich your life. I know these have enriched my life....


Best Regards,
Renegade Doug
Posted on: 04 March 2009 by mikeeschman
quote:
Originally posted by munch:
So what did you think of Mike Oldfield then?


munch, i enjoyed it very much, but i had one peculiar reaction :

an intense urge to smoke something that would make me goofy :-) don't know where that came from, but i felt like i was in my twenties again.

next batch of new cds is going to include tubular bells (after i've paid for the current batch).
Posted on: 04 March 2009 by fred simon
quote:
Originally posted by Florestan:

Ravel - Trio for piano, violin and cello


Wonderful suggestion, Doug. I love all of Ravel's music, but this one and the equally wonderful Sonata for violin and cello and Sonata for violin and piano are so delightfully piquant, more austere than the Daphnis et Chloé type of works for which Ravel is better known.

And I adore the music of Mompou, as well as that of his musical "cousin" Satie.

Best,
Fred


Posted on: 04 March 2009 by Huwge
Much good music here and evidence of the broad church here on the forum. For me (stream of consciousness):
Zoltan Kodaly - cello sonatas, runner up Britten
Duke Ellington - the Blanton-Webster years
Samuel Coleridge-Taylor - Violin Concerto
Thelonious Monk - Monk's Music / Brilliant Corners
Malcom Arnold, William Walton, Erich Korngold - various orchestral bits, but especially their film music
Ralph Vaughan Williams - Tallis and Lark Ascending as starters for 10
Cole Porter

Not very easy to nail one down and I haven't really thought about a lot of other genres, especially those two to three minute anthems that moved me in the late 70s / early 80s - Strummer & Jones, Jake Burns, et al
Posted on: 04 March 2009 by JamH
Rite of Spring by Stravinsky

a) Great really enjoyable music which I love to listen to
b) Really changed what was possible with an orchestra

James H.

P.S. There was a vote on RTE [Irish Radio] on the best piece of the 20th century and the winner was the Rite ...

ends==
Posted on: 04 March 2009 by mikeeschman
stravinsky rite of spring - impossible to argue with that choice.

a little disappointed no one nominated Pulcinella.
Posted on: 04 March 2009 by u5227470736789439
Dear Mike,

Many years ago, I went to a BBC Promenade Concert where Pulcinella was programmed with Parade [Satie, I think - anyway the piece with the typewriter in the percussion group!], and I honestly found the Parade more memorable.

I was young! I should probably revisit both and see if my appreciation has changed since!

ATB from George