uniti and UPnp control point software
Posted by: JLD on 24 August 2010
Hello,
I'm searching for a PC software able to control the uniti as UPnp renderer directly from the PC.
I've tried the several solutions:
1 Foobar + foo_upnp component(plugin) (server and controler)
2 Townky manager (server and controller)
3 Cidero media controler (just a simple control point with no Upnp server)
All of these server (foobar upnp and twonky server can be accessed from the uniti upnp menu)
But I cannot get correct results as soon as I want to use the control point of these software:
Twonky and Cidero simply cannot play anything on the uniti as renderer.
Foobar UPnp can play one time (just after the launching aof both the pc and the uniti set on the UPnp mode)
But the track cannot be paused, and if I stop the playing this action is definitive.
After I cannot control any more the uniti from the control point embedded in foobar...
My question will be very simple:
Is there an UPnp software able to control the uniti machine from a PC?
Ps (I've also tried an old plugin for winamp without any results)
Thanks in advance for any input.
JLD
I'm searching for a PC software able to control the uniti as UPnp renderer directly from the PC.
I've tried the several solutions:
1 Foobar + foo_upnp component(plugin) (server and controler)
2 Townky manager (server and controller)
3 Cidero media controler (just a simple control point with no Upnp server)
All of these server (foobar upnp and twonky server can be accessed from the uniti upnp menu)
But I cannot get correct results as soon as I want to use the control point of these software:
Twonky and Cidero simply cannot play anything on the uniti as renderer.
Foobar UPnp can play one time (just after the launching aof both the pc and the uniti set on the UPnp mode)
But the track cannot be paused, and if I stop the playing this action is definitive.
After I cannot control any more the uniti from the control point embedded in foobar...
My question will be very simple:
Is there an UPnp software able to control the uniti machine from a PC?
Ps (I've also tried an old plugin for winamp without any results)
Thanks in advance for any input.
JLD
Posted on: 24 August 2010 by Geoff P
You could try
This One
It is free because it not fully finished, but I find it works well with my Linn ADS ( so NOT proven that it will work with a uniti).
If you decide to try it and it works let us know.
regards
Geoff
This One
It is free because it not fully finished, but I find it works well with my Linn ADS ( so NOT proven that it will work with a uniti).
If you decide to try it and it works let us know.
regards
Geoff
Posted on: 24 August 2010 by 0rangutan
Have you tried the "Play To" feature of Windows Media Player 11? This works fine with my Uniti.
Posted on: 24 August 2010 by JLD
quote:Originally posted by John Bleasdale:
Have you tried the "Play To" feature of Windows Media Player 11? This works fine with my Uniti.
John, I thank you for this suggestion but except if I've missed something this feature is only available with WMP 12.
WMP 12 is only compatible with windows 7... and I actually run my home PC with Vista... (Nobody is perfect!)
JLD
Posted on: 24 August 2010 by JLD
quote:Originally posted by Geoff P:
You could try
This One
It is free because it not fully finished, but I find it works well with my Linn ADS ( so NOT proven that it will work with a uniti).
If you decide to try it and it works let us know.
regards
Geoff
Geoff,
Nice suggestion thanks,
I've downloaded this software.
The behavior is similar than foobar UPnp plugin...
At the launching I can play a track on my uniti but as soon as I try to stop the playing the uniti do not respond anymore to any command...
If I found something new with this soft I will report back here my test...
Posted on: 25 August 2010 by bartve
I have had some succes with eezUPNnP (google?),
and after some fantastic help from the Linn people also with Linn KinskyPDA (the developer made it work with the Uniti after a request from me on the Linn forums). In the meantime Kinsky Desktop should maybe also work with the Uniti ...
Bart
and after some fantastic help from the Linn people also with Linn KinskyPDA (the developer made it work with the Uniti after a request from me on the Linn forums). In the meantime Kinsky Desktop should maybe also work with the Uniti ...
Bart
Posted on: 25 August 2010 by JLD
quote:Originally posted by bartve:
I have had some succes with eezUPNnP (google?),
and after some fantastic help from the Linn people also with Linn KinskyPDA (the developer made it work with the Uniti after a request from me on the Linn forums). In the meantime Kinsky Desktop should maybe also work with the Uniti ...
Bart
Thank you very much Bart for this request to the developer of Linn Kinski (PDA or Desktop) to work on the support of the Naim Uniti.
At this time I've tried both eezUPnP and Kinski with approximatively the same results than with foobar UPnP or Twonky.
Can you indicate a link to the related discussion on the Linn Forum?
I've send a request to twonky people. I'm waiting for a response...
Jean-Luc
Posted on: 25 August 2010 by JLD
As more or less all the control point tested give bad results with my uniti but because I was able to play a track in some circumstances from several software, I've decided to test more accurately the behavior with the first I've tried : foobar UPnP...
I can report this:
I close the UPnP controller windows and go in the network settings of my uniti to relauch the connection (set do not use wifi produce the reset of the connection)
Now I select the UPnP input and the the UPnP server (so foobar UPnP)
The Uniti is now ready to browse (and play) any of the available tracks...
Now I open the controller windows in Foobar (this re-scan the network), I select the uniti as renderer and its status is shown "buffering..." cool
At this step if I play a tracks from the control point to the uniti that works fine!
I can also stop the playing.
After that the uniti never respond to any UPnP command from the control point and the status is shown as "stopped"
As this seems to affect all control point tested I suppose that the problem come from the Naim Uniti and not from the software...
But at this step, I'm a little alone... some imputs from Uniti owners or from Naim could be very nice!
I suppose I'm not the only one users interested to control an Uniti from a pc (or a mac)!!!
The desperate house-audiophile-Naim aficionado Jean-Luc
I can report this:
I close the UPnP controller windows and go in the network settings of my uniti to relauch the connection (set do not use wifi produce the reset of the connection)
Now I select the UPnP input and the the UPnP server (so foobar UPnP)
The Uniti is now ready to browse (and play) any of the available tracks...
Now I open the controller windows in Foobar (this re-scan the network), I select the uniti as renderer and its status is shown "buffering..." cool
At this step if I play a tracks from the control point to the uniti that works fine!
I can also stop the playing.
After that the uniti never respond to any UPnP command from the control point and the status is shown as "stopped"
As this seems to affect all control point tested I suppose that the problem come from the Naim Uniti and not from the software...
But at this step, I'm a little alone... some imputs from Uniti owners or from Naim could be very nice!
I suppose I'm not the only one users interested to control an Uniti from a pc (or a mac)!!!
The desperate house-audiophile-Naim aficionado Jean-Luc
Posted on: 25 August 2010 by bubbleguuum
JLD,
I'm the author of the plugin.
How are you trigerring playback ? From you message it is not 100% clear if you trigger it from the Uniti or from foobar2000 (as shown in this screenshot). If you trigger playback from from the Uniti, it cannot work as the Control Point has no idea of te next/previous track.
If you trigger it like shown in the screenshot, the selected tracks are played immediately and put in the "UPnP Controller Playback Queue" playlist. If you double click a file in that special playlist, it should play immediately on the unity.
If it the above doesn't work you can record a log file with INFO log level and send to it bubbleguuum@free.fr. here are the instructions to record a log file:
Logging can be enabled in File->Preferences->Tools->UPnP->Server->Basic. If log to file is enabled, a log file called foo_upnp.log is generated in either your foobar install directory or in <Document and settings>/<login>/Application Data/foobar2000 (on XP) or in <user dir>/AppData/Roaming/foobar2000 (on Windows Vista/Seven). This file is overwritten on each foobar2000 launch. .
I'm the author of the plugin.
How are you trigerring playback ? From you message it is not 100% clear if you trigger it from the Uniti or from foobar2000 (as shown in this screenshot). If you trigger playback from from the Uniti, it cannot work as the Control Point has no idea of te next/previous track.
If you trigger it like shown in the screenshot, the selected tracks are played immediately and put in the "UPnP Controller Playback Queue" playlist. If you double click a file in that special playlist, it should play immediately on the unity.
If it the above doesn't work you can record a log file with INFO log level and send to it bubbleguuum@free.fr. here are the instructions to record a log file:
Logging can be enabled in File->Preferences->Tools->UPnP->Server->Basic. If log to file is enabled, a log file called foo_upnp.log is generated in either your foobar install directory or in <Document and settings>/<login>/Application Data/foobar2000 (on XP) or in <user dir>/AppData/Roaming/foobar2000 (on Windows Vista/Seven). This file is overwritten on each foobar2000 launch. .
Posted on: 26 August 2010 by JLD
quote:Originally posted by bubbleguuum:
JLD,
I'm the author of the plugin.
How are you trigerring playback ? From you message it is not 100% clear if you trigger it from the Uniti or from foobar2000 (as shown in this screenshot). If you trigger playback from from the Uniti, it cannot work as the Control Point has no idea of te next/previous track.
If you trigger it like shown in the screenshot, the selected tracks are played immediately and put in the "UPnP Controller Playback Queue" playlist. If you double click a file in that special playlist, it should play immediately on the unity.
If it the above doesn't work you can record a log file with INFO log level and send to it bubbleguuum@free.fr. here are the instructions to record a log file:
Logging can be enabled in File->Preferences->Tools->UPnP->Server->Basic. If log to file is enabled, a log file called foo_upnp.log is generated in either your foobar install directory or in <Document and settings>/<login>/Application Data/foobar2000 (on XP) or in <user dir>/AppData/Roaming/foobar2000 (on Windows Vista/Seven). This file is overwritten on each foobar2000 launch. .
wow!
that's cool to have directly contact with you.
I will send you a message on the address above.
(eventually in french?
I can answer to your questions.
Of course I use one of two method describe in you message. I play FROM foobar. (exactly as shown on your screenshot or by double click in thethe Upnp queue)
I will try to send you the log file.
Thank you very much to respond here!
Jean-luc
Posted on: 26 August 2010 by Andy McGhee
Hi, my only experience is using PlugPlayer (iPod Touch app which is a uPNP control point) and this works well with my Uniti and uPNP NAS drive. I do not know if they do a PC version of PlugPlyer however.
I'm sorry if this doesn't help but it's the only experience I have and sorry it took a while to reply to you.
I'm sorry if this doesn't help but it's the only experience I have and sorry it took a while to reply to you.
Posted on: 28 August 2010 by JLD
quote:Originally posted by Andy McGhee:
Hi, my only experience is using PlugPlayer (iPod Touch app which is a uPNP control point) and this works well with my Uniti and uPNP NAS drive. I do not know if they do a PC version of PlugPlyer however.
I'm sorry if this doesn't help but it's the only experience I have and sorry it took a while to reply to you.
Andy, I thank you very much for pointing PlugPlayer.
I've search for a PC version, but I think this is not available.
I've found their forum, but I'm actually concentrated on Foobar UPnP plugin and I hope Bubleguuum will find a solution for Naim renderer.
I'm also waiting for a feedback from Twonky...
JL
Posted on: 05 September 2010 by Stevesky
Hi Guys,
SteveH from Naim R&D here. My reply also covers the thread raised by BubbleGuuum on his investigation into problem. This can be found at: https://forums.naimaudio.com/ev...2903417/m/7842913437
Firstly thanks for all your feedback and comments, we do listen and action.
On the original NaimUniti it was only really intended to be used via the front panel user interface. People did notice that it could be used with external UPnP control points, but there were a few known compliance issues.
In v3 of the codebase that is shipping in Qute and all new Unitis for the last month has had a fair bit of work in that area.
As a sanity check have gone through the issue on this thread and it all seemed to work ok now.
Pause - on v3 we have gone through all the UPnP server we can get our hands on and the Pause works nicely. If the server does drop the connection then we can't do anything about that, BUT while in Pause mode we actively try and keep the connection open by handling zerowindow probes.
As for dev stuff we actively work behind the scenes with the varioud third parties. If you email the Naim helpdesk they can pass your email into R&D and we can then deal direct.
Regards
Steve
PS. and for existing Uniti's we are scheduling the v3 upgrade to be available by the end of this month. There are a few upgrade dillemas we are ironing out and hence the extra time needed.
SteveH from Naim R&D here. My reply also covers the thread raised by BubbleGuuum on his investigation into problem. This can be found at: https://forums.naimaudio.com/ev...2903417/m/7842913437
Firstly thanks for all your feedback and comments, we do listen and action.
On the original NaimUniti it was only really intended to be used via the front panel user interface. People did notice that it could be used with external UPnP control points, but there were a few known compliance issues.
In v3 of the codebase that is shipping in Qute and all new Unitis for the last month has had a fair bit of work in that area.
As a sanity check have gone through the issue on this thread and it all seemed to work ok now.
Pause - on v3 we have gone through all the UPnP server we can get our hands on and the Pause works nicely. If the server does drop the connection then we can't do anything about that, BUT while in Pause mode we actively try and keep the connection open by handling zerowindow probes.
As for dev stuff we actively work behind the scenes with the varioud third parties. If you email the Naim helpdesk they can pass your email into R&D and we can then deal direct.
Regards
Steve
PS. and for existing Uniti's we are scheduling the v3 upgrade to be available by the end of this month. There are a few upgrade dillemas we are ironing out and hence the extra time needed.
Posted on: 09 September 2010 by JLD
Hi Steve,
Thanks for this answer and... action !)
Also, thank for opening the door to dev guys...
I will wait for the v3 upgrade.
Jean-Luc
Ps, hope this also will solve the behavior about network settings (DHCP and static IP) already reported here
https://forums.naimaudio.com/ev...2903417/m/8122917337
Thanks for this answer and... action !)
Also, thank for opening the door to dev guys...
I will wait for the v3 upgrade.
Jean-Luc
Ps, hope this also will solve the behavior about network settings (DHCP and static IP) already reported here
https://forums.naimaudio.com/ev...2903417/m/8122917337
Posted on: 09 September 2010 by Stevesky
Hi Jean-Luc,
Was just going through that other thread. From what you describe it indicates that when the streaming core attempts to use those IP details, that it decides something is invalid and rejects them and doing so returns back to DHCP so leaving itself in a safe state.
For your original post you have a DHCP range of 192.168.0.10 to 19.168.0.90.
The address requested when in static mode was 192.168.0.100 and hence outside the DHCP range which is fine.
Could you let me know:
1. What netmask you entered into 'Mask' setting in the static setup.
2. What default gateway was entered into the 'Gtry' setting in the static IP setup.
3. What DNS address was set in DNS1 and optionally DNS2.
We'll then recreate the same network environment here and see what happens.
Many thxs
Steve
Was just going through that other thread. From what you describe it indicates that when the streaming core attempts to use those IP details, that it decides something is invalid and rejects them and doing so returns back to DHCP so leaving itself in a safe state.
For your original post you have a DHCP range of 192.168.0.10 to 19.168.0.90.
The address requested when in static mode was 192.168.0.100 and hence outside the DHCP range which is fine.
Could you let me know:
1. What netmask you entered into 'Mask' setting in the static setup.
2. What default gateway was entered into the 'Gtry' setting in the static IP setup.
3. What DNS address was set in DNS1 and optionally DNS2.
We'll then recreate the same network environment here and see what happens.
Many thxs
Steve
Posted on: 12 September 2010 by JLD
Hi Steve
Sorry for the delay...
here are the requested informations:
1- Mask: 255.255.255.0
2- Gateway: 192.168.0.254 (Ip adress of the ADSL Box / Router)
3- DNS 1: 212.27.40.241
3- DNS 2: 212.27.40.240
You can also contact me direct to jldaureil[at]alicepro[dot]fr in you need some additional informations (screeshots, photos... etc)
Thanks for investing this.
Jean-Luc
Sorry for the delay...
here are the requested informations:
1- Mask: 255.255.255.0
2- Gateway: 192.168.0.254 (Ip adress of the ADSL Box / Router)
3- DNS 1: 212.27.40.241
3- DNS 2: 212.27.40.240
You can also contact me direct to jldaureil[at]alicepro[dot]fr in you need some additional informations (screeshots, photos... etc)
Thanks for investing this.
Jean-Luc
Posted on: 16 September 2010 by Tom_W
Hi bubbleguuum,
Great to have you on the Naim forums and in contact with the devs. I really hope some of the compatibility issues can be sorted out as your plugin is nearly everything I need.
I hope the non-pausing behaviour will be sorted in Naim's V3 update as Steve claims.
Currently I am not able to use the shortcut alphabetical letter search when browsing my Foobar library (this is done from the remote control)
From the NaimUniti Reference Manual
In long lists the handset numeric/text keys can be used to jump through the list alphabetically.
From the NaimUniti Troubleshooting guide
4.8 Cannot jump lists when using UPnP server
• Some UPnP servers do not return the browse data in alphabetically sorted lists. If this is the case then the Uniti cannot perform an alphabetical jump to a position in the list.
Can this functionality be enabled in your plugin?
As JLD said in another thread, having a specific Uniti profile in the UPnP preferences would be be useful.
Thanks for all your work.
Nice tunes in your Foobar library screenshot by the way!
Tom
Great to have you on the Naim forums and in contact with the devs. I really hope some of the compatibility issues can be sorted out as your plugin is nearly everything I need.
I hope the non-pausing behaviour will be sorted in Naim's V3 update as Steve claims.
Currently I am not able to use the shortcut alphabetical letter search when browsing my Foobar library (this is done from the remote control)
From the NaimUniti Reference Manual
In long lists the handset numeric/text keys can be used to jump through the list alphabetically.
From the NaimUniti Troubleshooting guide
4.8 Cannot jump lists when using UPnP server
• Some UPnP servers do not return the browse data in alphabetically sorted lists. If this is the case then the Uniti cannot perform an alphabetical jump to a position in the list.
Can this functionality be enabled in your plugin?
As JLD said in another thread, having a specific Uniti profile in the UPnP preferences would be be useful.
Thanks for all your work.
Nice tunes in your Foobar library screenshot by the way!
Tom