n-Vi Problems - help please
Posted by: Ray C on 17 November 2009
Can anyone advise us, please, on what quirks it is reasonable to put up with in an n-Vi’s operation? We love its performance (especially now we have added a NAP250 to the system) but our pleasure is quite often spoilt by operational troubles.
We bought the n-Vi in December 2008 and have had constant troubles of some kind ever since. It has been back to NAIM, I think (as the dealer returned it without us getting it back), four times and our dealers have put lots of time and effort into helping us (as have NAIM) but we still have problems which, we suspect, they think are minor quirks we should put up with. We were offered a replacement or total overhaul in the summer and were advised to accept the latter. The main fault of the CD player cutting off the beginning of the first track when PLAY is pressed was then corrected but the n-Vi was soon often, now almost always, cutting off the beginning of every other track when a track number is pressed. Usually re-pressing the button puts it right but sometimes this has to be done several times. I tend to press PLAY, get a burst of the opening of track 1 (which I MUTE) and then the track number which usually then starts at the beginning. On a few occasions this process has apparently triggered some programming operation because after finishing the CD we have found it started replaying it from the beginning.
Occasionally the n-Vi will not play the later track but is locked into track 1 (until the CD finishes playing or we turn the machine off at the back).
Our dealer has asked NAIM and we were told these are “matters of functionality” not faults but we do not know what this means!
Other frustrations are the DISPLAY turning off very quickly (eg after 20secs) before the above operations have been completed.
Also when switching to CD use after SATELLITE or DVD operation the MODE usually remains on the surround sound setting it has automatically moved to for the SATELLITE or TV input. Presumably the only way to change it is to start the CD playing, correct it then start it again. This seems very cumbersome, especially if a later track is wanted and the above procedures are being used. Is something wrong here?
Do other n-Vi users with the built in tuner have FM problems? We get frequent “blips” (perhaps momentary interruptions of reception) and a good deal of hissing or fizzing, not just at dusk when atmospherics might mess up the signal. NAIM suggests the latter are ongoing FM broadcasting problems. We have had a directional aerial installed but it does not improve either of the above faults.
We are hi-fi innocents so hope some of you experts can comment.
Ray
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by james n
Ray - i'd take this up directly with Naim - some of these are not 'matters of functionality' but a problem with the unit and your dealer sounds like he's side stepping the issues.
How well does the radio work when using DAB ?
James
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by Ray C
Thanks James for that lightening response. We've returned the n-Vi to our dealers at our request for further checks so they (and/or NAIM) might be helping us more but in view of recent responses we wanted to be prepared with wise counsel!
DAB is pretty good but just lacking a certain something, especially for big orchestral sound.
Ray
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by Ray C
PS I should have said that our dealer offered to swap our model with the shop's which does not mal-function, he says. As ours is presumably newer we did not know if this was wise.
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by BigH47
quote:
Originally posted by Ray C:
PS I should have said that our dealer offered to swap our model with the shop's which does not mal-function, he says. As ours is presumably newer we did not know if this was wise.
As long as the warrenty conditions are the same, no problem, I would have thought.
Does it have an earlier S/W drop?
It would be interesting to see if the dealers version works OK at home though.
It would confirm whether there is any problem with your system or not.
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by SC
quote:
Originally posted by Ray C:
Our dealer has asked NAIM and we were told these are “matters of functionality” not faults but we do not know what this means!
Is that a piss-take ?!....I would have gone ballistic if given such an answer....No, I don't know what it means either...
£3k+ hey...
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by Ray C
quote:
Originally posted by BigH47:
quote:
Originally posted by Ray C:
PS I should have said that our dealer offered to swap our model with the shop's which does not mal-function, he says. As ours is presumably newer we did not know if this was wise.
As long as the warrenty conditions are the same, no problem, I would have thought.
Does it have an earlier S/W drop?
It would be interesting to see if the dealers version works OK at home though.
It would confirm whether there is any problem with your system or not.
Thanks but what's S/W drop, please?
Ray
PS to SC Thanks too - I saved my ballistics until the message had sunk in!
We've been told British equipment is prone to minor functional faults.
Ray
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by BigH47
Software Drop ie latest update.
"British equipment" as you put it, is no more or less prone than any others.
We even have fully functioning plumbing and dentists too.
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by SC
Ray - I vaguely remember you posting much earlier in the year (?) when you were considering adding the separate power amp to the n-Vi and you were listing problems then....Reading your above post again, and considering you purchased the machine almost a year ago now and have been plagued ever since, in my opinion you have shown the patience of a saint !
WHO told you British gear is 'prone to functional faults' ?!!...I'm the first to shout that Naim haven't exactly covered themselves in 100% glory with their AV range, with some very checkered products, but to hang that on a British manufacturing hook is going too far I think.....If you were talking about issues such as HDMI handshakes or buggy AV software then even the best of the Japanese seem to occasionally be found wanting in the AV world, but you're not, you are asking for a CD to play blip free or FM radio to not drop out - fairly basic features in a 'one box' playing machine - one would presume....
No, I don't think it's 'British manufacturing' or 'functional faults' that you are suffering from...It's one product, from a particular manufacturer - that lets be honest, hasn't exactly been trouble free since birth - that you paid a lot of money for, a long time ago, and have have been having problems of one sort or another ever since......
Personally, I think it's time you stamped your feet....!
Posted on: 17 November 2009 by Ray C
Yes I asked for help earlier in the year! Now we have replaced the NAP200 with a 250 we (mostly) love the sound and the DVD and satellite performance is usually brilliant – it’s just the CD bit that has continued to be troublesome – it only worked properly the day the heavily worked on by NAIM n-Vi was returned and re-installed by the dealer (or maybe a few days after)! I bombard the charming chap at the dealers (who made the comment!) with e-mails but …! Thanks again. Friends say we should not put up with the faults but we just wondered whether they went with the good bit! Ray
Posted on: 18 November 2009 by Rick Lieberman
I'm on my 5th n-Vi in 2-1/2 years. I've had some of the problems you have as well as many others. Although there have been people at naim & my dealer who have tried to be helpful, in general it has been only too clear from the beginning (before I even bought the first specimen) that naim's attitude is to pretend there really are no significant problems with this model, never were, & that most problems are caused by the rest of the world (CDs, DVDs, cable system, FM stations, etc., all not good enough to work will with this "complicated" device). I have used naim equipment since the company was young & have had quite a few of their different products. This is the only one that, despite its good sound & picture, is clearly a poorly-designed piece of crap, like an old PC that crashes every time you try to use it. I personally don't believe they've ever made one n-Vi that wasn't defective in some way or other. I've put a lot more time into diagnosing & describing its myriad problems than anyone connected with naim ever has in trying to remedy them. It appears naim-usa has stopped even carrying the n-Vi, & one doesn't have to spend long figuring out why; I assume the return rate is stratospheric. It has certainly changed my long-standing opinion of the company (& my old habit of recommending it) to go through this. I, like you, am not sure what I want to do at this point; it's quite expensive for a box that can't perform some of its most basic functions & is so unstable that which ones it can't perform change over time, yet I've stopped believing that naim has the will or the way to just make things right. If they still cared, there would at least have been a more recent code update. I think they're trying to just stonewall it until the whole n-Vi adventure blows over.
Posted on: 19 November 2009 by SC
quote:
Originally posted by Rick Lieberman:
I think they're trying to just stonewall it until the whole n-Vi adventure blows over.
And not JUST the n-Vi...Seems as though they won't talk or mention the whole AV line, period.
There a still a lot of pissed off guys & girls out there from the DVD5 scaler fiasco...never did turn up, did it. Not to mention the switch unit. I've conversed with a few on a AV forum, and there's a real deep anger on the way they felt they were treated (even banned from here)...for sure they'll never come back to Naim...And that is a real real shame.
It's certainly stopped me and made me think twice about my original plans - and I'm just one person. Not good PR.
It wouldn't be so bad, and far more respectful, if they removed the stuff from the website, made a formal announcement and put their hand up, but seemingly, no.....It all seems DAC and Uniti priority these days, which I've always thought a bit bizarre when you consider the % of page space given to AV products in any popular consumer magazine - must be a massive market out there.....
It's so frustrating, because the stuff is damn good (apart from not being HD and no way to upgrade it
now seems ) - when it works!
It's even more frustrating - and ironic - because I keep hoping, wishing and hanging that they are going to pull a rabbit out of a hat and give us the AV products many of us would LOVE to see......
Steve.
Posted on: 19 November 2009 by Ray C
Wow! Thanks Rick – that is most illuminating! And have all those replacements been under guarantee with no extra costs? Even if so the future does not look good for we n-Vi owners! Food for thought and frank talks with our dealer indeed!
Ray
Posted on: 19 November 2009 by Ray C
PS And sorry to hear, Rick, of all the frustration and hassle you've had to cope with intstead of the pleasure it should all be about!
Ray
Posted on: 19 November 2009 by Richard Dane
I think it's only fair to say that Naim stand by their products and are willing to work with their dealers and customers to work out any issues that may be experienced. AV products can be notoriously tricky - there are lots of n-Vis out there working fine, but a few seem to be plagued by digital gremlins. I have pointed Naim towards this thread and Ray (And Rick), I urge you to get in touch with Naim's Customer Service manager, Steve Hopkins at Naim HQ so he can help you.
Posted on: 19 November 2009 by Rick Lieberman
Thanks, Richard, though I do have to tell you that I went the route you suggest a while back out of desperation & my message was kicked back to the same gent at naim-usa who'd been trying to help me & get answers himself from the Home Office; I did receive a reply, though, (I believe it was from Steve H., though I'm not looking it up now so I'm not positive) of the "gee, that's surprising, mine works great" variety, which I have to consider disingenuous. I have tried every avenue multiple times in as thorough a way possible during all this, including pointlessly replacing auxiliary equipment. I know at this point that talking to my dealer again is likely the only way to approach this without totally wasting my own time excessively once again, but I'm leery of getting another unit that's worse than the one I have. I don't really believe that there are lots of n-Vi's out there working perfectly (unless so far only minor quirks have not yet deteriorated into extreme inconvenience for a lucky few). I never said Naim didn't stand behind the product, as mine has been replaced 4 times. But Naim has never come to grips with important problems that so many units have had in common (acting like each one is a new surprise that never came up before when I've known that's not the case), nor even that they've put out a product that in many basic ways doesn't work as well as the cheapest consumer electronics are routinely expected to. Many of the problems are not "digital gremlins", but failure of basic, even simply mechanical, functions to operate like something that is determined to be ready to sell to the public. As I posted earlier, I've owned a good sampling of Naim products throughout most of the company's history, & this one is a lemon, just like a bad, misconceived car model. Naim saying it's a "complicated" lemon doesn't do anything to make the experience less bitter. Excuses about how hard it was to design shouldn't be needed; cutting the company some slack over a few glitches or birth-pangs is one thing, but the n-Vi is in a whole other category of trying the patience of an usually loyal customer-base that had been earned because of a vastly different level of quality.
Posted on: 20 November 2009 by Ray C
Thanks Richard. I thought NAIM liked us to only go through dealers but I will phone as you suggest.
Ray