Who is (or was) the greatest sportsman of all time?
Posted by: acad tsunami on 28 May 2007
Who is (or was) the greatest sportsman of all time? Not just the greatest athlete but a gentlemen too.
(please, no knee-jerk votes (unless you really can't help yourself)for that buffoon M. Ali as any claim to his being the greatest sportsman of all time won't stand scrutiny for more than five seconds.)
(please, no knee-jerk votes (unless you really can't help yourself)for that buffoon M. Ali as any claim to his being the greatest sportsman of all time won't stand scrutiny for more than five seconds.)
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Jet Johnson
...I'm still trying to work out why voting for Ali would be a knee jerk reaction in any sense and as for being a buffoon ...well only if Ayrton Senna was a crap racing driver ..and Gordon Banks couldn't catch a cold..
....The whole thread starts off with dissing the ONLY correct answer .......?!
..but hey surely I'm being "whooooshed" here?
....The whole thread starts off with dissing the ONLY correct answer .......?!
..but hey surely I'm being "whooooshed" here?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Jet Johnson
Re Kevin Beattie..
A cracking player ..I was just telling Jet Junior about him the other day ..I seem to remember him playing as a full back against us (Sunderland) a few times ...was there a stronger player in England at the time?..and I have to admit I thought he'd won about 20 caps (which would still have been far too few!)
Not sure there is any mackem equivalent of "The Tank" although I could wax lyrical about "The King" Charlie Hurley for a few months ..but another time perhaps!!
...Escape to Victory, widely acknowledged as the greatest war epic ever made
A cracking player ..I was just telling Jet Junior about him the other day ..I seem to remember him playing as a full back against us (Sunderland) a few times ...was there a stronger player in England at the time?..and I have to admit I thought he'd won about 20 caps (which would still have been far too few!)
Not sure there is any mackem equivalent of "The Tank" although I could wax lyrical about "The King" Charlie Hurley for a few months ..but another time perhaps!!
...Escape to Victory, widely acknowledged as the greatest war epic ever made

Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Ian G.
quote:Originally posted by BigH47:quote:He got his scrotum torn open in a game (against France I think) and one testicle was hanging out.
People want to play this game?
Only if they have the balls for it...
(sorry couldn't resist...)
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
For those struggling to comprehend why Ali should not be considered I would draw your attention to the constant claims of match fixing, his swaggering loud-mouthed rants at the expense of his opponent - both in and out of the ring (hardly very sporting)and the fact that he was a serial adulterer etc. etc. Was he undefeated? Was he free from scandal? Was he a good role model? No and no and no. In fact he is one of the worst examples of a true sportsman it is possible to find imo. He was/is also a racist.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
My vote goes to Jahangir Khan the former world squash Champion.
'During his career he won the World Open six times and the British Open (The British Open is to squash what Wimbledon is to tennis)a record ten times. Between 1981 and 1986, he was unbeaten in competitive play for five years. During that time he won 555 matches consecutively. This was not only the longest winning streak in squash history, but also one of longest unbeaten runs by any athlete in top-level professional sport'. (wikipedia)
For three years of the five year period of being unbeaten he did not even drop a single game (a squash player must win the best of 5 games to win a match).
Imagine a tennis player winning all the Grand Slams for five years and for three of those five years not even dropping a single set?
He did this all while never ever arguing or even questioning a refereeing decision and having total respect for his opponents and leading an private life that was beyond reproach.
It has often been said that Jahangir Khan had a dominance over his opponents not seen in any other sport ever and a gentleman to boot.
This is a photo of Janangir playing Gamal Awad one of the most talented players the game has ever known. The opening rally lasted for a punishing 20 minutes and the first game lasted over an hour and 11 minutes - the match lasted a total of 2 hours and 46 minutes - a record. Gamal Awad gave so much that he was psychologically crushed and never played top International squash again. (I'm in the crowd watching)
'During his career he won the World Open six times and the British Open (The British Open is to squash what Wimbledon is to tennis)a record ten times. Between 1981 and 1986, he was unbeaten in competitive play for five years. During that time he won 555 matches consecutively. This was not only the longest winning streak in squash history, but also one of longest unbeaten runs by any athlete in top-level professional sport'. (wikipedia)
For three years of the five year period of being unbeaten he did not even drop a single game (a squash player must win the best of 5 games to win a match).
Imagine a tennis player winning all the Grand Slams for five years and for three of those five years not even dropping a single set?
He did this all while never ever arguing or even questioning a refereeing decision and having total respect for his opponents and leading an private life that was beyond reproach.
It has often been said that Jahangir Khan had a dominance over his opponents not seen in any other sport ever and a gentleman to boot.

This is a photo of Janangir playing Gamal Awad one of the most talented players the game has ever known. The opening rally lasted for a punishing 20 minutes and the first game lasted over an hour and 11 minutes - the match lasted a total of 2 hours and 46 minutes - a record. Gamal Awad gave so much that he was psychologically crushed and never played top International squash again. (I'm in the crowd watching)
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Ian G.
Good spot Acad..
I had the privilege of seeing Jahangir Khan in action a few times - awesome speed, accuracy and edurance. He also had a fun line in party-tricks to keep the crowd stupified whle he was "warming-up".
At one exhibition game they picked a seat in the audience at random and the lucky occupant got to play a 'game' against him for a laff. I missed out by one seat - and so my friend (who was a pretty good club player) got the runaround much to everyone amusement.
Kahn was a fun entertainer and decent chap as well as a truly great athlete.
I had the privilege of seeing Jahangir Khan in action a few times - awesome speed, accuracy and edurance. He also had a fun line in party-tricks to keep the crowd stupified whle he was "warming-up".
At one exhibition game they picked a seat in the audience at random and the lucky occupant got to play a 'game' against him for a laff. I missed out by one seat - and so my friend (who was a pretty good club player) got the runaround much to everyone amusement.
Kahn was a fun entertainer and decent chap as well as a truly great athlete.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
Ian,
I played Chris Dittmar in 1983 and lost 9-1 9-1 9-0. He didn't even get a sweat up!
Jahangir stuffed Dittmar 9-3, 9-6, 9-0 in the same year. In the third game Dittmar, the world's no.2 was a totally knackered wreck.
I played Chris Dittmar in 1983 and lost 9-1 9-1 9-0. He didn't even get a sweat up!
Jahangir stuffed Dittmar 9-3, 9-6, 9-0 in the same year. In the third game Dittmar, the world's no.2 was a totally knackered wreck.

Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Chillkram
How about Ed Moses then, who was unbeaten for nearly 10 years?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Cheese
Oh acad. Good grief, I am speechless.quote:Originally posted by acad tsunami:
and the fact that he was a serial adulterer etc.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
quote:Originally posted by Chillkram:
How about Ed Moses then, who was unbeaten for nearly 10 years?
Well, it depends...
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Guido Fawkes
quote:Originally posted by bob mccluckie:
C B Fry played football and cricket for England .. at the same time!
That is impressive. I suppose he could bat at half time and play in goal during the tea interval - I'd have liked to have seen it. I'm still trying to figure out how he played football and cricket simultaneously.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Guido Fawkes
quote:Originally posted by Jet Johnson:
Re Kevin Beattie..
A cracking player


quote:
...Escape to Victory, widely acknowledged as the greatest war epic ever made![]()
Well, widely acknowledged by me for it's great cast from Portman Road - that and The Great Escape and The Goose Steps Out are the only three war films I like.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Bob McC
Read the history. C B Fry was offered the crown of Albania. At the time he was a demigod. Meanwhile the rest of the contributors prattle on about lightweights.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Guido Fawkes
quote:Originally posted by bob mccluckie:
Read the history. C B Fry was offered the crown of Albania. At the time he was a demigod. Meanwhile the rest of the contributors prattle on about lightweights.
But was he a better cricketer than Derek Pringle who had sweaters and crisps named after him

Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Bob McC
Have you never heard of the chocolate?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
Albania? Albania is twinned with a public toilet in Northern Algeria. Who would want it?
Seriously though CB Fry is a good suggestion, he is a hero of mine. I think there have been many worthy contenders thus far.
Seriously though CB Fry is a good suggestion, he is a hero of mine. I think there have been many worthy contenders thus far.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by jayd
quote:Originally posted by acad tsunami:quote:Originally posted by Chillkram:
How about Ed Moses then, who was unbeaten for nearly 10 years?
Well, it depends...
...on?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Chief Chirpa
quote:Originally posted by ROTF:
But was he a better cricketer than Derek Pringle who had sweaters and crisps named after him![]()
Rotf - yeah, he was.

Anyhow, back to the matter at hand. So who's man of the match in 'Escape to Victory'? For me, it's got to be Carlos Rey/Ossie Ardiles. His goal after beating four defenders and the keeper is a peach; he sets up the third goal; and he's just everywhere, dominating the whole game with his mix of flair and crisp, incisive passing - he's a thorn in the Germans' side all afternoon.
Acad - while 555 matches unbeaten is amazing, and Jahangir Khan was undoubtedly a great sportsman, he can't be ranked above The Greatest, simply because squash is such a relatively minor sport.
Ali bomaye!
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
quote:Originally posted by jayd:quote:Originally posted by acad tsunami:quote:Originally posted by Chillkram:
How about Ed Moses then, who was unbeaten for nearly 10 years?
Well, it depends...
...on?
Whether he voted for GW Bush or not

Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
quote:Originally posted by Chief Chirpa:
[QUOTE]
Acad - while 555 matches unbeaten is amazing, and Jahangir Khan was undoubtedly a great sportsman, he can't be ranked above The Greatest, simply because squash is such a relatively minor sport.
I'm sorry, clarification is needed. Who is The Greatest?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Chief Chirpa
quote:Originally posted by acad tsunami:
I'm sorry, clarification is needed. Who is The Greatest?
Dry up, Acad. Apology accepted.
Jockie Wilson is The Greatest.
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
quote:Originally posted by Chief Chirpa:quote:Originally posted by acad tsunami:
I'm sorry, clarification is needed. Who is The Greatest?
Dry up, Acad. Apology accepted.
Jockie Wilson is The Greatest.
Ah yes, did you see Jockie Wilson on 'A Question of Sport'?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Chief Chirpa
No, I can't say I did.
Though I do remember Jockie's appearance on Top of The Pops with Dexy's Midnight Runners!
Though I do remember Jockie's appearance on Top of The Pops with Dexy's Midnight Runners!
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by acad tsunami
quote:Originally posted by Chief Chirpa:
[QUOTE]
he can't be ranked above The Greatest, simply because squash is such a relatively minor sport.
Ali bomaye!
Methinks more people play squash then box. What say you?
Posted on: 29 May 2007 by Jim Lawson
With all due respect to your choices, it is time to cut through the Eurocentric drivel!
"Identified as a hockey prodigy at a very young age, Gretzky regularly played at a level far above his peers. He became a full professional at the age of 17 in the World Hockey Association, leading to a long career in the NHL. He set 40 regular-season records, 15 playoff records, 6 All-Star records, won four Stanley Cups with the Edmonton Oilers, and won 9 MVP awards and 10 scoring titles. He is the only player ever to total over 200 points in a season (a feat that he accomplished four times in his career). In addition, he tallied over 100 points a season for 15 NHL seasons, 13 of them consecutively.
He retired from playing in 1999, becoming Executive Director for the Canadian national men's hockey team during the 2002 Winter Olympics. He also became part owner of the Phoenix Coyotes in 2000 and following the 2004-05 NHL lockout became their head coach."
Perhaps more importantly, he has shown himself to be a true gentleman off the ice; his selfless work for charities in particular.
That is all.
(Nod to C. B. Fry, though...and the guy with the torn sack)
Regards,
Jim
"Identified as a hockey prodigy at a very young age, Gretzky regularly played at a level far above his peers. He became a full professional at the age of 17 in the World Hockey Association, leading to a long career in the NHL. He set 40 regular-season records, 15 playoff records, 6 All-Star records, won four Stanley Cups with the Edmonton Oilers, and won 9 MVP awards and 10 scoring titles. He is the only player ever to total over 200 points in a season (a feat that he accomplished four times in his career). In addition, he tallied over 100 points a season for 15 NHL seasons, 13 of them consecutively.
He retired from playing in 1999, becoming Executive Director for the Canadian national men's hockey team during the 2002 Winter Olympics. He also became part owner of the Phoenix Coyotes in 2000 and following the 2004-05 NHL lockout became their head coach."
Perhaps more importantly, he has shown himself to be a true gentleman off the ice; his selfless work for charities in particular.

That is all.
(Nod to C. B. Fry, though...and the guy with the torn sack)
Regards,
Jim