Turntable advice

Posted by: KC on 17 November 2001

Has anyone compared LP12 and Roksan latest TMS-2 on a Naim system? Which do you think will be a better choice? LP12 has been in existance now for almost 30 years and the design has remained almost unchanged throughout this period. Whereas Roksan is a more recent TT and this is the 2nd version of TMS. I am looking for good investment in terms of sound quality as well as future resale value. Mostly listen to classical and rock music.
Posted on: 18 November 2001 by Craig B
If the TMS is anything like the original Xerses but with more of the same (haven't heard the TMS so can't say for sure) then I would say that you had better get yourself out for a few dems as the Sondek and Xerses were in two different geosynchronous orbits. You will definitely prefer one spin on things over the other. But who can tell you which one that would be? Chaulk and cheese my friend.

And, BTW, the LP12 has changed no end on a continuous basis since its debut. I believe that the outer platter and the rubber feet are the only parts that have remained the same since day one. It just looks and acts the same. I always thought that the perfect vinyl source would combine the best of both decks. I think that Linn were actually aiming for this when they got round to the Cirkus bits. But since they had all surely gone a bit deaf by then, one can't be too sure.

quote:
I am looking for good investment in terms of sound quality as well as future resale value.
You are not a commercial estate agent by any chance are you? Sorry for being pedantic, but this choice should come to you via your tapping toes, not your cheque book.

Get listening and keep us informed (we like to live vicariously through others purchases you know)

Craig
(Mint early '90s LP12/Ittok LVIII (yes III) on its way - at least it better be...)

Posted on: 18 November 2001 by Martin Payne
quote:
Originally posted by Craig Best:
two different geosynchronous orbits


Hmm, tricky that one.

If they were much different to each other one of them wouldn't be geosynchronous!

cheers, Martin

Posted on: 18 November 2001 by Craig B
Martin,

If my geosynchronous analogy demanded to be picked apart by someone then I am glad that it turned out to be by your doing.

Stephan,

New domed shaped rubbers? Sounds somehow both safe and comfortable at the same time. Maybe they are to compensate for the retentive bum squeezing that the Cirkus imparts to the proceedings?

Mr Pig,

Yes, Linn's general lack of tolerance lately has become very unplattering.

Posted on: 19 November 2001 by Martin Payne
quote:
Originally posted by Craig Best:
Martin,

If my geosynchronous analogy demanded to be picked apart by someone then I am glad that it turned out to be by your doing.



Craig,

sorry, I think I was put into a very pedantic mood by discussions of boats and NAP135s used as ballast (padded cell).

'Pedant' Payne

I will not torment other forum users.
I will not torment other forum users.
I will not torment other forum users.
I will not torment other forum users.
I will not... (cue Simpsons theme).