CD ripping for dummies

Posted by: nickpeacock on 03 September 2010

Dear All,

CD ripping for Dummies

I'm hoping to get (and in the process provide for others) some answers to some fairly simple issues surrounding CD-ripping for dummies.

My aim is to rip all CDs (600+ but due to double) to a NAS drive (in my case a ReadyNAS duo with 2x 1.5TB drives) in lossless format. I then plan to (i) play via the NAS drive to my home hi-fi (including multi-room streaming) and (ii) continue to use iTunes to prime my iPod.

My PC will not have enough internal hard drive space to rip all my (present and future) CDs, hence the NAS.

So here are the questions:

1. Can I use iTunes to rip CDs straight lossless to my NAS drive? [If so, (i) how? and (ii) I assume the best lossless format would be ALAC but all comments appreciated.}

2. In reality, should I use alternative software (DBpoweramp/EAC/other?) to create the lossless database on the NAS drive? [If so: (i) why? and (ii) in what format should I rip in an ideal world (FLAC or other), assuming eventual playback via Sonos/Naim nvi/NAP200?]

3. Having created a lossless database on the NAS, how can I then best use iTunes to maintain a lossy database, so I can prime my iPod as now? Should I make 2 copies from the CD initially (one lossless to NAS and one lossy)? Or should I make a lossy copy from the lossless NAS copy?

4. Any pros and cons to having the lossy database on the PC (backed up to NAS) or only on the NAS? Will iTunes try and "copy" the lossless music back into its library, thus clogging up my PC's hard drive? [This latter question betrays my dummy status so please forgive.]

5. Any settings/pitfalls/tweaks I need to know about in order to then access the ReadyNAS via Sonos?

I recognise that this is all pretty simple for you guys out there but having reconciled myself to ripping many hundreds of CDs (mostly for the second time) over the next few weeks I don't want to make basic errors and have to start again.

Cheers! Smile
Posted on: 03 September 2010 by likesmusic
You also have to consider where and how re-tagging - often necessary for classical music or older cds - fits into your work-flow.
Posted on: 03 September 2010 by totemphile
Have a read through this thread:

https://forums.naimaudio.com/ev...417/m/7062992617/p/1

It won't answer all you questions but makes for some very intersting reading.
Posted on: 03 September 2010 by John R.
There is an excellent article about CD ripping at the computeraudiophile forum. It covers everything you need to know about CD ripping.
Posted on: 03 September 2010 by nickpeacock
Thanks for the threads, guys. I am about to wrap a cold towel round my head to see if I can make sense of this. However, provisionally, the idea of having one software package that rips two or more copies of a CD to different locations AT THE SAME TIME sounds like a winner. Now if I can just get that to work...
Posted on: 03 September 2010 by gone
Use dBpoweramp to do the lossless ripping first to one location. Then use dBpoweramp batch converter to compress the whole lot to another location in one go. Lots of guidance on the dBpoweramp site for optimal settings for ripping
Cheers
John
Posted on: 03 September 2010 by naimUnT
The Unitiserve is pretty much CD ripping for dummies! Stores them as well! Smile
Posted on: 04 September 2010 by Alonso
quote:

1. Can I use iTunes to rip CDs straight lossless to my NAS drive? [If so, (i) how? and (ii) I assume the best lossless format would be ALAC but all comments appreciated.}


quote:

2. In reality, should I use alternative software (DBpoweramp/EAC/other?) to create the lossless database on the NAS drive? [If so: (i) why? and (ii) in what format should I rip in an ideal world (FLAC or other), assuming eventual playback via Sonos/Naim nvi/NAP200?]


quote:

3. Having created a lossless database on the NAS, how can I then best use iTunes to maintain a lossy database, so I can prime my iPod as now? Should I make 2 copies from the CD initially (one lossless to NAS and one lossy)? Or should I make a lossy copy from the lossless NAS copy?


quote:

4. Any pros and cons to having the lossy database on the PC (backed up to NAS) or only on the NAS? Will iTunes try and "copy" the lossless music back into its library, thus clogging up my PC's hard drive? [This latter question betrays my dummy status so please forgive.]


quote:

5. Any settings/pitfalls/tweaks I need to know about in order to then access the ReadyNAS via Sonos?


quote:

I recognise that this is all pretty simple for you guys out there but having reconciled myself to ripping many hundreds of CDs (mostly for the second time) over the next few weeks I don't want to make basic errors and have to start again.
Posted on: 06 September 2010 by nickpeacock
@Alonso,
Thanks for this, but your replies didn't get included.
How are those Neat Motive 2s of yours, as I am considering upgrading from my Harbeth HL3PEs?

@All,
Unitiserve does not have enough hard drive capacity (unless using SSD version - which brings me back to NAS drives...)