The Classical Guitar

Posted by: Mansoor on 23 June 2006

The classical guitar is a very popular, but little heard instrument outside of its group of staunch supporters and players. In addition, it has a long history going back as far as 1600 BC according to some historians.

There has always been sporadic interest on the Forum in the instrument, and I wanted to pull together something that will hopefully pique people’s interest and encourage them to explore the classical guitar further.

I will not go too deeply into the evolution of the instrument. Briefly, by about the 13th Century AD, we had the guitarra latina, which resembled most the modern instrument in that it had a single sound hole and a flat back. This was as opposed to, for example, the lute and the oud, which had curved backs.

The guitar continued improving and began to rise to prominence around the end of the 17th Century, growing in popularity until sometime towards the end of the 19th Century, when the instrument began to fall out of favour.

There are two events that propelled the guitar back into the limelight and helped to gain respectability amongst modern composers and classical audiences.

The first was the upgrade made to the guitar by Antonio de Torres around 1850. His research increased size and playability, greatly increasing the volume, projection and sustain of the instrument. Even if the volume of the guitar could not compete with the violin or piano, at least it could hold its own in the concert hall. The basic shape and construction of the modern guitar are almost unchanged from the original Torres version.

The second event was the arrival on the scene of the great Andres Segovia. Segovia, almost single-handedly promoted the guitar: he sought great composers to write for it; he introduced further repertoire through transcriptions and his own compositions; he taught students who have gone on to become great guitarists in their own right – John Williams, for example; and he gave endless concerts across the world, where his incredibly technique demonstrated to unbelieving audiences that, yes, here was a serious instrument that could play serious music.

My own interest in the guitar arose when trying to determine which instrument to take up to learn to play, this or the violin. I bought solo recordings of each and my benchmark would be the sound and performance I liked most. The clear winner, of course, was the guitar. The sound was a revelation: gorgeous, bell-like tones packed with emotion. I had heard nothing like this even from listening to finger picked (non-classical) acoustic guitars. It was a clear winner over the less alluring tones (to me) of a solo violin.

I began my music collection by deliberately avoiding Spanish composers at first. I wanted to listen to material that was not what I would expect to hear on a classical guitar. It was probably overexposure to flamenco in adverts and soundtracks that caused this! As a result, I explored 19th Century French and Viennese composers, before moving on to the 20th Century and discovering modern British, Cuban, South American and Japanese pieces. Of course, I did go back to Spain to discover the true variety of Spanish guitar music, finding for example, that the composer Joaquin Rodrigo, who wrote that utterly Spanish composition, the Adagio of the Concierto de Aranjuez, wrote considerably more works that are utterly modern.

I shall leave these ramblings here, but if there is enough (or any!) interest, I shall write more on some of the great guitarists, composers, music and the continued evolution of the construction of the guitar.

For those who wish to explore further, I shall leave you with a list of ten recordings, obviously only a small cross-section of the vast material available. You will notice that most of these are collections. Given the general lack of investment in classical guitar music, it is difficult to find CD’s dedicated to single composers. One of the great exceptions to this is the Naxos label and a vast library of guitar material can be found there. However, in pulling together this selection, I have focussed on providing, in my opinion, some of the finest recorded guitarists.

Asturias: The Art of the Guitar – Narciso Yepes (DG)
Ignore the slightly tacky cover art; this is a great collection of music superbly played by Yepes on a ten-string guitar. Includes the piece “Recuerdos De La Alhambra”, which demonstrates one of the classical guitar’s greatest virtuoso techniques, the tremelo.

Guitar Recital – Kevin Gallagher (Naxos)
Fabulous collection of Baroque and Renaissance music by the first American to win the prestigious Francisco Tarrega Guitar Competition in Spain. His rendition of “Differencias sobre Conde Claros” is stunning.

Caprice – Wang Yameng (GHA)
Tricky to get hold of, but well worth the effort. This is an astonishing rendition of 19th and 20th century music, played by a very young performer – she was winning international guitar competitions at the age of 12. I have not heard better versions than these.

Johann Sebastian Bach: New Transcriptions for Guitar – Philip Hii (GSP)
Transcriptions this time, and Hii’s technique is quite amazing, bringing these pieces alive in a way I have not heard from other performers.

The Goldberg Variations, transcribed for solo guitar – Jozsef Eotvos
An incredible accomplishment, these are played exactly as described, on a single guitar by the talented Mr Eotvos. And this is no mere technical exercise; this recording is one of the best Goldberg’s I have heard on any instrument.

Leo Brouwer, Guitar Music Vol. 1 – Ricardo Cobo (Naxos)
Brouwer is one of the greatest guitar composers of the 20th Century and his work covers some of the most beautiful and lyrical pieces, included here, to considerably more challenging material. To hear the latter (and more of the former), get Volume 2. Cobo is bettered only by Brouwer himself, but Brouwer’s recordings are difficult to obtain and the sound is not a good as the Naxos.

From the Jungles of Paraguay – John Williams (Sony)
An essential CD, this showcases the work of composer and performer Agustin Barrios-Mangore, who has been described as the “Chopin of the guitar”. A listen to this will quickly demonstrate why. And there is no better performer than Williams.

Nocturnal – Julian Bream (EMI)
20th Century guitar works, including the title piece by Benjamin Britten. These are not easy pieces, but Bream brings them to life and gives them tension and excitement.

Bach Guitar Recital – Julian Bream (EMI)
Yes, yet another recording of Bach, but I defy anyone not to enjoy this. Superbly recorded to boot.

Rodrigo: Fantasia Para Un Gentilhombre – Conductor Enrique Jorda, Performer Andres Segovia (DG)
I will admit now, I am not a fan of Segovia’s style of playing. This recording, however is a major exception - in my opinion it is the best version of this concerto. Rodrigo wrote this work for Segovia – he is the gentilhombre referred to in the title.
Posted on: 23 June 2006 by stephenjohn
Brilliant. Thank you.
SJ
Posted on: 23 June 2006 by tjb
Mansoor, what a great idea.

I'll certainly try the recordings I'm not familiar with. I have both Naxos volumes of Brouwer. I can manage a distinctly unimpressive version of one of the Estudios Sencillos myself, which gives me a certain insight into how stunning Ricardo Cobo is.

As an introduction to recorded classical guitar I would like to add another Naxos disc, Guitar Favourites by Norbert Kraft. This is a fine introduction to a number of important composers: Albeniz, Torroba, Granados, Falla, Villa-Lobos, Turina, Barrios, Tarrega, Paganini & Myers.

Cheers, TJB
Posted on: 24 June 2006 by Nigel Cavendish
Julian Bream has a CD on which he plays with some of the evolutions of the guitar.


Bream, Julian: Guitarra CD RCA RD 86202
Posted on: 24 June 2006 by Robert Derwae
Mansoor: Thanks for taking the time to record your observations. I fairly recently discovered classical guitar recordings myself - though I haven't had the time to explore the genre in depth as you have. I've been pleasantly surprised at my reaction to the music. The classical guitar, as it turns out, is a very interesting and expressive instrument.

Robert
Posted on: 25 June 2006 by erik scothron
Mansoor,

Great post. I adore the clasical guitar but you have listed some stuff that is new to me. Thank you.

Erik
Posted on: 25 June 2006 by JamH
Quote ....
"
The Goldberg Variations, transcribed for solo guitar – Jozsef Eotvos
An incredible accomplishment, these are played exactly as described, on a single guitar by the talented Mr Eotvos. And this is no mere technical exercise; this recording is one of the best Goldberg’s I have heard on any instrument.
"
end-Quote

I have looked for this on CD-universe .. can you give me more details ? Thanks...
Posted on: 25 June 2006 by Gianluigi Mazzorana
http://sologuitarist.net/jozsef_eotvos.html
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by worm
Mansoor

Great thread.

Thanks for taking the time to share your insight.

Many CDs already added to my Amazon wish list Eek

Thanks again.

worm
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by JamH
Thanks Gianluigi for the reference ...
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by Mansoor
Nigel - thanks for the recommendation. Bream is one of my favourite guitarists and I could happily listen to him for hours. He does have an enormous back catalogue of material, but I hope that he will release new recordings of new material in the near future.

James - if you are interested, there is another Goldberg, performed by Kurt Rodarmer and this is on the Sony label so is easier to obtain. Rodarmer's performance is double-tracked, which in itself is no mean feat, and is more faithful to the score as a result. I still prefer the Eotvos, more for interpretation than say, technical accomplishment, but you may prefer Rodarmer.

TJB - I shall check out the Norbert Kraft. I tend to overlook his solo performances since these tend to cover material that other excellent guitarists have also recorded. I do have a number of his Paganini duets, which are very good. I am surprised that Kraft has time to record at all given how busy he is teaching, composing and generally enhancing the availability of guitar music. He seems to have a hand in every recording of classical guitar on the Naxos label.

I do not think there are any major modern composers out there who understand the capabilities of the classical guitar as well as Brouwer (I am happy to be shown to be wrong on this - please let me know of other great composers who, in your opinion, are as good or better). The Estudios Sencillos demonstrate almost everything that can be done on the instrument and yes, a great number of them are not so simple! I do not think I will tackle number 7 for example, with its instruction to play as fast as possible, just yet.

Cobo, if I remember rightly, actually plays the estudios a little faster than Brouwer notates. Costas Cotsiolis, another Brouwer interpreter, plays them closer to tempo, yet is not as powerful and persuasive as Cobo in my opinion.

Brouwer, has recently written a new set of studies. To my knowledge, there is no recording of these yet but any new work by Brouwer is exciting news and I will have to get hold of a copy of the score and work my way through it.

Mansoor
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by Tam
Dear Mansoor,

As others have said, great thread (and will find itself on my next update of the classical threads worth readings).

However, I am more than curious as to how the Goldbergs work on a single guitar. Prompted by the sound of the natural [I think] 8 foot stop on the harpsichord, I commented on the Walcha thread how interesting it would be to hear them arranged for a guitar duet. However, particularly listening to the harpsichord, where one hears the lines of the two hands so clearly, I find it difficult to understand how it works on a single guitar. (However, this may simply be down to my ignorance of the guitar works and is used as an instrument - so I would be grateful for enlightenment on this score.)

regards, Tam
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by JamH
Dear Tam,

If you go to
http://www.spinnst.at:16080/BZ/Gitarre/eoetvoes/
and follow the links to the CD's you will get some MP3 samples ...

James
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by Mansoor
Tam

There is obviously a compromise in reducing the work to be played on a solo guitar, and much depends on the ability of the performer to convince us that this is actually how the piece should sound. Good performers are able to produce the effect of multiple lines, but there are physical limits, especially on a piece such as the Goldberg and then the trick becomes what to leave out, yet maintain the continuity of the musical line and phrase. As discussed above, a more "conventional" approach to maintain the integrity of the score is a duet, which the performer Kurt Rodarmer achieves through double-tracking on his particular recording.

However, I will have to throw your question out to people far better qualified than me in guitar transcription for a more satisfactory answer.

Try and get a copy of the recordings, I would love to hear your thoughts on them.

Mansoor
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by Tam
Dear James - Thanks for the link.

Dear Mansoor - Thanks for this, I shall certainly look out for some of these recordings.

regards, Tam
Posted on: 26 June 2006 by fred simon


Not quite guitar, but I highly recommend Paul O'Dette's recordings of the works of John Dowland on lute. Sublime.

Fred


Posted on: 28 June 2006 by Davidmanne
Thanks for the Goldberg variations recommendation. I listened to the MP3 file. Still prefer the Gould version on the painno.

Co-incidently, whilewoking in my study, I've been listening to soem guitar recordings as well.

Itzak Perlman and John Williams playing duos by Paganini & Giuliani.

John Williams and friends playingtwo guitars, two marimbas & bass by a variety of composers including Bach, Dqquin, Mozart, Purcell, Telemann and Vivaldi. Beautiful to listen to.

Regards to all

DM
Posted on: 28 June 2006 by Mansoor
I have provided some more recordings for those looking for further inspiration. None of these will be surprises to those of you who already listen to the instrument, but I am hoping that you will be able to provide further recommendations.

19th Century French and Viennese
Napoleon Coste, Guitar Works, Vols 1 to 4 – various performers (Naxos)

Nicolo Paganini, Sonate & Ghiribizzi for Guitar - Pavel Steidl (Frame). Steidl plays a period instrument by Stauffer, one of most famous 19th Century luthiers of the Viennese school. Franz Schubert himself owned and played a Stauffer guitar. Paganini was an accomplished guitarist and had the same mastery on that instrument as on the violin according to his circle of friends. In addition to the Stauffer, Paganini played guitars made by Fabricatore, of the Italian school and Grobert, of the French.

Mauro Giuliani, Solo Guitar Music Performed on 19th Century Guitar – David Starobin (Bridge). Giuliani was a guitar virtuoso who contributed a vast body of material to the repertoire. Friend of Beethoven, Schubert, Rossini, Hummel and Diabelli, he also played cello at the premiere of Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony in 1813.

Jahann Kaspar Mertz, Bardenklange – Adam Holzman (Naxos). Recommendations requested of other works by Mertz.

Chamber
Given the guitar’s general lack of volume and sustain, pairing the instrument with violins, cellos and pianos would seem a recipe for disaster. Most of the works I have heard end up using the guitar as a backdrop of chords over which other instruments play. By comparison, the following works give the guitar a major role by literally playing to its strengths:

Francois de Fossa, Guitar Trios – Simon Wynberg, Martin Beaver, Bryan Epperson (Naxos)

Terry Riley, The Book of Abbeyozzud (New Albion Records)

Duo Sylphide, Pas de Deux Fantastique (HOMA). This is a collection of the only successful pairings of guitar and piano I have heard. Includes a work by Mario Castelnuovo-Tedesco. This recording is a little tricky to get hold of, but can be ordered from http://www.homadream.com/eng/CD.htm

Concertos
Steve Gray: Guitar Concerto; Richard Harvey: Concerto Antico – John Williams and the London Symphony Orchestra (Sony)

Christopher Rouse: Concert de Gaudi; Tan Dun: Guitar Concerto (Yi2) – Sharon Isbin and the Lisbon Gulbenkian Foundation Orchestra (Teldec)

Schubert: “Arpeggione” Sonata; Giuliani: Guitar Concerto – John Williams and the Australian Chamber Orchestra (Sony). My recommendation is for the Giuliani – the Schubert is a transcription. Williams plays his Concerto Number 1 on a Gaetano Guadagnini guitar from 1814.

English Guitar Concertos – Craig Ogden and the Northern Sinfonia Chorus (Chandos). Works by Matthew Arnold, Lennox Berkeley and William Walton.

Leo Brouwer: Guitar Concerto No. 5 “Helsinki” – Timo Korhonen and the Tampere Philharmonic Orchestra (Ondine)

There are a lot of concerti to choose from, even after putting aside the Vivaldi’s, the Villa-Lobos’ and the Rodrigo’s. Let me know of any you particularly recommend.

Transcriptions
Paul Galbraith plays Haydn (Delos). Former Young Musician of the Year, Galbraith not only has superb technique, but plays on a custom designed eight string guitar built for him by luthier David Rubio. Galbraith holds the guitar in the same posture as a cello and a metal endpin connects the guitar to a wooden resonance box. The result is greater projection and deeper bass. In addition to the Haydn, he has transcribed the sonatas and partitas for unaccompanied violin, by Bach.

Thoughts on transcriptions by Kazuhito Yamashita? I am particularly curious about his arrangement of Mussorgsky’s “Pictures at an Exhibition” and Beethoven’s Violin Concerto in D (for solo guitar!) but these are not easy recordings to get hold of. Also, is anyone aware of transcriptions of the Schubert Impromptus?

20th Century Works
Tippett: The Blue Guitar – Craig Ogden (Nimbus). Works by Richard Rodney Bennett, Lennox Berkeley, Benjamin Britten, William Walton and the title piece by Michael Tippett.

Concerto Barroco – Manuel Barrueco and the Orquesta Sinfonica de Galicia (KOCH). There are many standouts on here, but the killer piece is Arvo Part’s Fratres, arranged by Part himself for guitar and orchestra. The performance is beautifully intense.

Nikita Koshkin: The Prince’s Toys – Nikita Koshkin (Soundset Records). Koshkin, whose “Usher Waltz” is much recorded, is another composer pushing back the possibilities of the classical guitar.

Spirit of the Guitar: Music of the Americas – John Williams (Sony). Works include Venezuelan waltzes by Antonio Lauro, Argentinian tangos by Astor Piazzolla and the dazzling opener, “Sunburst” by Andrew York.

Possession - Lily Afshar (Archer). A collection of modern works, some written just for her.

There is so much material to choose from that it is difficult to know where to start, and I have found quality to be very variable - a lot depends on how much passion a particular composer has in understanding the capabilities of the guitar, an instrument they may not actually be that familiar with. Please let me know your recommendations in this area.


Mansoor
Posted on: 30 June 2006 by worm
Mansoor

Thanks to your post I have the Kevin Gallagher / Wang Yameng / Leo Brouwer CDs winging their way to me as I type.

Have you any other details on the Bream / Bach CD as I am struggling to identify which of the many Bream recordings it is?

Many thanks

worm
Posted on: 30 June 2006 by Mansoor
Worm

The Bream Bach recording is EMI Classics catalogue number 7243 5 55123 2 1, and contains the Chaconne BWV1004, Suite BWV996, Partita BWV1006a and Prelude, Fugue and Allegro BWV998.

Enjoy the CD's!

Mansoor
Posted on: 03 July 2006 by Davidmanne
And for those who like Spanish.

(Please note that all my recommendations are those that I listen to.)

Guitar classics from Spain
by Marcelo Kayath - an IMP recording
Posted on: 03 July 2006 by Edot
I'm rather fond of Sharon Isbin. Her transcription of Bach's Lute Suites on Virgin is brilliant. She studied with Tureck for some time before making the recording. Highly recommended.
Posted on: 07 July 2006 by worm
Hi Mansoor

When I got home yesterday Julian Bream – Nocturnal and John Williams – The Great Paraguayan were waiting on the doorstep.

I listened to The Great Paraguayan last night. I think this is the UK version of From The Jungles of Paraguay which I could not track down anywhere? I really enjoyed this CD – Williams’ performance is stunning. Would you recommend any other of Barrios’s work?

Have not had a good chance to listen to Nocturnal, just 40 minutes in the car on the way into work which did not do it justice. I will give it a proper listen over the weekend which I am looking forward to.

Thanks again for the recommendations.

Cheers

worm
Posted on: 20 July 2006 by Mansoor
Worm

I have not had the opportunity to check back on this thread until now but if you liked the Barrios, you may want to check out two CD's that Naxos has of his works. I have only listened to volume one, ably performed by Antigoni Goni (who studied under Julian Bream at the Royal Academy of Music, and under Sharon Isbin at Julliard) and I can recommend this recording.

There are also CD's of Barrios playing his own and other compositions, recorded during the period 1913 to 1942. I have not heard these, but if you decide to buy them, I believe that CD's released after 2004 have been digitally restored and much of the original surface noise - and hopefully nothing else - has been removed. finefretted.com seems to have a number of these original recordings and is a good place to start.

Ed - I too am a fan of Sharon Isbin and have seen her perform a number of times in New York. I shall definitely get hold of her Bach Lute Suites - I believe that Tureck was actually involved in the editing and some of the arrangements of the pieces for guitar. One thing I found interesting is that Isbin turned to Tureck to study Bach and Baroque after having no success studying under a harpsichordist at the faculty at Julliard. I would have expected the opposite, since I feel that a guitar is closer to a harpsichord than a piano. However, I suspect that this speaks volumes for the calibre of Tureck!
Posted on: 30 August 2006 by worm
Mansoor

A quick update on my progress with your excellent recommendations.

Having had time to sit down and enjoy the recordings over several weeks my clear favourite of those I have bought so far is Leo Brouwer, Guitar Music Volume 1 – Ricardo Cobo (Naxos). It is exactly what I thought I would not have liked beforehand and I was sceptical after my first listen – now I love it. The Naxos recording sounds fabulous as well.

I enjoyed the Brouwer Volume 1 so much I have already bought Volume 2 performed by Elena Papandreau which I am enjoying just as much. I can’t say whether it compares well to other recordings of the same pieces as I have not heard any. However, as a lapsed schoolboy guitar player I marvel at some of the sounds she gets out of her instrument. I am already looking forward to getting Volume 3 by Graham Anthony Devine (and I think he has just recorded Volume 4 as well).

As I mentioned before I really enjoyed the Barrios – Jungles of Paraguay by Williams. I found it more accessible than the Brouwer but have not found myself putting it on as much (although it still gets plenty of play). I will try the Barios – Goni disc on Naxos next.

Probably next would be the Wang Yameng – Caprice disc. Her playing is beautiful. I listened last night and enjoyed the Sor piece on it. Any recommendations on a good Sor disc to start with, I see there are plenty available from Naxos but don’t really know which to start with.

I have also been enjoying the Kevin Gallagher – Guitar Recital. His playing is breathtaking.

One disc I do need to give a bit more time to is the Julian Bream – Nocturnal. I have enjoyed it when I have listen to it but at the moment I always find myself reaching for a Brouwer disc first.

I am working through your second list as well now. The Rouse – Isbin disc is on its’ way and my Amazon wish list is stuffed with the likes of Coste etc.

Thanks again for the recommendations.

worm