Stephen Sondheim

Posted by: Tam on 09 September 2008

This forum doesn't appear to have the biggest fan base so far as musical theatre is concerned, unless it's passed me by, which is entirely possible since I'm not a huge fan of the genre either. However, in the last couple of years I've seen a few pieces that have prompted me to buy a couple of recordings.

The first piece of Sondheim I came across in full was Sweeny Todd in a production at the Royal Opera House at Christmas a few years back - it has a rather more operatic score than a lot of Sondheim and so worked very well (I'm also told that the recent film was very good though I haven't got round to it yet). I have picked up the CD of the original cast recording, and will probably discuss it later in the thread.

The second thing was Marry Me A Little which one of the youth theatre companies brought to the Fringe venue I help run at the Edinburgh festival last year. An odd piece, made up of songs cut from other works, and yet woven together into a moving story (and with what in my view is one of the more sexually charged numbers I've heard in any genre). Again, I've picked up the original cast (and, indeed, only) recording.

However, what prompted this splurge of buying was another amateur production again at the Edinburgh festival, this time just a few weeks ago. The Durham University Light Opera Group brought Assassins. It has never enjoyed commercial success in the states, the original production didn't run long, and the broadway revival was shelved as it was originally stated to go on just after 9/11. When it did make it to broadway in 2004 it again didn't last long. It tells the story of those who have either assassinated or tried to assassinate a president of America (which, along with things like John Wilkes Booth singing "damn you Lincoln" probably explains why). The songs and text is wonderfully sarcastic and subversive.

I've picked up recordings of both the original and the broadway (as both have actors who I very much admire).

So far I've only listened to the original and already comparison to the amateurs is interesting. The 'proprietor' of the bar where all the assassins meet is rather weak (character wise, rather than vocally) on the recording. It's also a shame that all we're getting is the songs and not the text, as much of the context goes with it. Victor Garber is excellent though as John Wilkes Booth as is Patrick Cassidy as the Balladeer (though in fairness so to was Durham's, but they provided no programme so I cannot credit him). Of course, in many ways the recording is superior - for example nearly every word is clear in the fast paced chorus number where the crowd describe how thanks to their quick thinking each save Roosevelt.

So, anyone else here like Sondheim?


regards, Tam
Posted on: 10 September 2008 by droodzilla
I don't know, but I'm tempted to try him at some point, simply because our mutual friend Joss is such a big fan! Winker
Posted on: 12 September 2008 by Tam
I didn't know that, but now that you mention it it makes perfect sense that he would be. I'd suggest that if you like the musical episode of Buffy you might light some Sondheim.

I think Assassins is by far my favourite of the ones I've heard, though it occurs to me that Into the Woods (his sendup of the fairy tale genre) might be worth exploring.

There are two available as noted above (the original 1991 production and the 2004 Broadway production). For a little more context you might like to see my review of the stage production I saw.

The Proprietor, who runs the purgatory-like shooting gallery where the assassins meet was, in the production I saw, more cynical and harsher such than on both recordings, where he seems soft in comparison (though better in the 2004 revival) and less powerful as a result. The balladeer (who provides a lot of linking narrative) is good on both recordings, probably slightly preferable on the first for his more folksy feel, though in 2004 Neil Patrick Harris, Doogie Howser M.D., if you're of a certain age is rather special though his singing voice at times strains ever so slightly but his overall performance is so good the flaws don't matter too much.

Booth is okay on the revival but can't hope to match Victor Garber in the origian (Jack Bristow if you're an Alias fan).

As far as the other parts go there isn't a huge amount to choose between the two, though orchestrally the later production is probably better.

As ever, each have some performances stronger than the other. The revival also has a new song (written for the 1991 London performances, and the need to capture America's sorrow at the events and make up for what might be seen as the mocking of the American people in How I Saved Roosevelt) and much more, though sadly by no means all of the text. Indeed, that is perhaps the great reservation of these recordings, there is so much wonderful dialogue omitted from both, such as Byck's message to Bernstein, or Moore and Fromme's various discussions. Still, both can be had for around £5 on Amazon so there's little reason not to own both.


regards, Tam
Posted on: 23 September 2008 by Peter Golding
You may have missed an excellent professional production of Assassins in Sheffield a couple of years ago, and a well reviewed one in London at the Donmar before that (they also put on an excellent production of Pacific Overtures). A good source to monitor UK productions is http://www.sondheim.org/php/home.php?menu=0&submenu=0&latest=5 which is the website run by the UK SS society and keeps a tally of all pro and amateur productions among other things.
Posted on: 24 September 2008 by Wolf2
I have friends who are HUGE fans, and a couple serious classical guys that really liked Sweeney, the original, with Angela Landsbury.

PBS has run Sunday in the Park with George? I couldn't watch it thru. Tho I do love Bernadette Peters.

I've certainly heard many of his song's in reviews, or someone's recital, which I enjoy, but can't say I'm engaged in a whole night of it. Tho in light of the recent productions of all too stupid and poorly written musicals, he is the last of the great broadway composers and producers.