All that glitters isn't gold?

Posted by: Voltaire on 29 October 2008

I find myself increasingly frustrated with established bands/singers who seem to think that replicating the formula of their last hit album is the key to future success!

I understand that a fan base is built on the band/singer 'doing what they do (Iron Maiden for example)' and the maxim 'if it ain't broke don't fix it (Meatloaf)' but come on...how long can they continue to churn out facsimile's of their most successful album?

Some of the most successful bands/singers of all time have built their success on reinvention.

Grrrr. Frown

I guess this was brought on by first play of The Cure's new album.

Which bands/singers do you wish would stop trying to replicate their past glory and innovate?
Posted on: 29 October 2008 by Diccus62
The vast majority of them with the exception of real talent.
Posted on: 29 October 2008 by Harty601
quote:
Originally posted by Voltaire:
I find myself increasingly frustrated with established bands/singers who seem to think that replicating the formula of their last hit album is the key to future success!

I understand that a fan base is built on the band/singer 'doing what they do (Iron Maiden for example)' and the maxim 'if it ain't broke don't fix it (Meatloaf)' but come on...how long can they continue to churn out facsimile's of their most successful album?

Some of the most successful bands/singers of all time have built their success on reinvention.

Grrrr. Frown

I guess this was brought on by first play of The Cure's new album.

Which bands/singers do you wish would stop trying to replicate their past glory and innovate?


I have the new cure album on order, I hope I am not so disappointed!!
Posted on: 30 October 2008 by Nigel Cavendish
Voltaire

If you don't like it don't buy it.

Why would/should artists who make money from what the majority of people want to buy risk their liveihood for the sake of the minority who want them to do something different - and who might not even like what they then produce?
Posted on: 30 October 2008 by Voltaire
quote:
Originally posted by Nigel Cavendish:
Voltaire

If you don't like it don't buy it.


Erm, I already have bought it, thats how I found out it was just a poor replica of their past glory and I don't think I'm in the minority in asking the bands/singers that I like to stop being lazy and produce something worthy of their fan base handing over hard earned money for. Also, they are hardly risking their livelihood as they made their money in past decades.

Confused
Posted on: 30 October 2008 by Voltaire
I am not asking them to reinvent themselves or to distance themselves from their established fan base, nor am I expecting them to detract from their sound...I guess I'm just disappointed that a band who I rate highly have lumped themselves into the 'bat out of hell I, II, III' bracket, the 'replicate don't innovate mind set.
Posted on: 30 October 2008 by Voltaire
quote:
Originally posted by Nigel Cavendish:
Voltaire
Why would/should artists who make money from what the majority of people want to buy risk their liveihood for the sake of the minority who want them to do something different - and who might not even like what they then produce?


This is the sound of the music industry being murdered by popular culture. God forbid that a band/singer might record something that their fans don't like. I suspect that Bowie & Dylan are turning in their beds.
Posted on: 30 October 2008 by Voltaire
For example check out Tom Jones new single '24 hours'. This is not going to please his typical fanbase as it isn't a power ballad but, as a piece of music, it is gorgeous and it tests the reaches of his popularity.

Sure, the beat is simple and the lyrics aren't gonna win a Literature award but the spirit of innovation, of a seasoned pro with an established fanbase unfurling his wings within the confines of the cage he created are haunting.

These are my opinions and they are valid.